Starting today August 7th, 2024, in order to post in the Married Couples, Courting Couples, or Singles forums, you will not be allowed to post if you have your Marital status designated as private. Announcements will be made in the respective forums as well but please note that if yours is currently listed as Private, you will need to submit a ticket in the Support Area to have yours changed.
The Bible assumes that "whoever believes" is available to all.
Only after they believe. Initially, "whosoever" is the part that is available to all.The group "whosoever believes" is limited to "whosoever believes", ie, the ones who believe.
3) Also how does this remove human boasting, which is what the passage is about?...
Here's your soteriology: "You chose God, so God in return chose you, therefore, you cannot boast!"
Dies-I,Hmm, "I am a loser who only accepted the Gospel because I lacked the worldly prowess to survive without it" doesn't have much of a boastful ring to it.
Faith, generally, is the assent given to truth; and divine faith is that which is given to truth divinely revealed. The foundation on which divine faith rests is two-fold - the one external and out of or beyond the mind - the other internal and in the mind. The external foundation of faith is the very veracity of God who makes the declaration, and who can declare nothing that is false. The internal foundation of faith is two-fold - both the general idea by which we know that God is true - and the knowledge by which we know that it is the word of God. Faith is also two-fold, according to the mode of revelation, being both legal and evangelical, of which the latter comes under our present consideration, and tends to God and Christ.
Evangelical faith is an assent of the mind, produced by the Holy Spirit, through the gospel, in sinners, who, through the law, know and acknowledge their sins, and are penitent on account of them, by which they are not only fully persuaded within themselves that Jesus Christ has been constituted by God the author of salvation to those who obey him, and that he is their own saviour if they have believed in him, and by which they also believe in him as such, and through him on God as the benevolent Father in him, to the salvation of believers and to the glory of Christ and God.
The object of faith is not only the God and Father of our Lord Jesus Christ, but likewise Christ himself who is here constituted by God the author of salvation to those that obey him. The form is the assent that is given to an object of this description; which assent is not acquired by a course of reasoning from principles known by nature; but it is an assent infused above the order of nature, which, yet, is confirmed and increased by the daily exercises of prayers and mortification of the flesh, and by the practice of good works. Knowledge is antecedent to faith; for the Son of God is beheld before a sinner believes on him. But trust or confidence is consequent to it; for, through faith, confidence is placed in Christ, and through him in God.
The author of faith is the Holy Spirit, whom the Son sends from the Father, as his advocate and substitute, who may manage his cause in the world and against it. The instrument is the gospel, or the word of faith, containing the meaning concerning God and Christ which the Spirit proposes to the understanding, and of which he there works a persuasion. The subject in which it resides, is the mind, not only as it acknowledges this object to be true, but likewise to be good, which the word of the gospel declares. Wherefore, it belongs not only to the theoretical understanding, but likewise to that of the affections, which is practical. The subject to which [it is directed], or the object about which [it is occupied], is sinful man, acknowledging his sins, and penitent on account of them. For this faith is necessary for salvation to him who believes; but it is unnecessary to one who is not a sinner; and, therefore, no one except a sinner, can know or acknowledge Christ for his saviour, for he is the saviour of sinners. The end, which we intend for our own benefit, is salvation in its nature. But the chief end is the glory of God through Jesus Christ.
Arminians do not teach that they conjure up their own faith.
dies-l said:I don't have any suggestions as to how Paul should have written it; I think he did just fine. The problem is that you are reading your Calvinist presuppositions into the text. Nothing in this passage indicates that Paul is promoting individualistic predestination.
Okay, then show me how, from the text, that you come up with the view that God calls those who believe. And where in chapter 8 does Paul switch from individuals to corporate?
Okay, then show me how, from the text, that you come up with the view that God calls those who believe. And where in chapter 8 does Paul switch from individuals to corporate? Also, why us Romans 8:28-30 corporate, but 1 Cor 1 individualistic? What in the langue Paul uses leads you to this conclusion?
Only after they believe. Initially, "whosoever" is the part that is available to all.
The clear teaching from the Bible is that salvation is the gift of God; and eternal life and the Holy Spirit also I believe are referred to as the gift of God.
Salvation includes believe.
Part of being saved by God is being brought to faith by God. It's all God's work. By grace.
This is Paul's point in Eph 2:8-9. Being saved by grace through faith is the gift of God, IT IS NOT YOUR OWN DOING, so that no man can boast.
You'd think that would end the debate. Only Calvinists can consistently say with Paul "the fact that I believe in Jesus is 100% God's doing, not mine".
Dies: I noticed you never provided a single Bible exegesis for your strange idea that election is somehow not personal in nature but rather God simply predestined a faceless, nameless, corporate group of people. Then, it's up to the people themselves whether or not to "get in" to the group called "the church" so that they can be predestined.
All the predestination verses in the Bible are personal and individualistic in nature. You'd have to be reading your own ideas into the text to come away with anything else.
Okay, then show me how, from the text, that you come up with the view that God calls those who believe. And where in chapter 8 does Paul switch from individuals to corporate?
Hupomone10 said:"There is therefore now no condemnation for those who are in Christ Jesus." (Romans 8:1)
dies-l said:I had written out a rather length response, and then lost it because my browser took me to the wrong page. I don't have it in me to type it all out again, but basically, I don't see where you are getting individualism out of 1 Cor 1, either. Both passages address the Christian community as a whole, not in an individualistic capacity. 1 Cor 1 describes the types of people who are drawn to the gospel. Likewise, I don't see this individualism you are talking about in Romans 8, either. Both passages address Christian community, how it comes about, and how it is blessed.
ETA: to answer your first question: "And we know that in all things God works for the good of those who love him".
In other words, the grammar of the sentence says, "people love God" then "God works for their good". Not the other way around. Who loves God? The church. Whose good does God work for, then? The church. Who is the church? Those who believe and love God.
One step at a time.
You, however, are not in the flesh but in the Spirit, if in fact the Spirit of God dwells in you. Anyone who does not have the Spirit of Christ does not belong to him. (Rom8:9)
Is Paul speaking corporately or us he referring to individuals?
dies-l said:The context would indicate that he is talking to the Roman church. And, he indicates that whoever is not part of that collective you does not "have the Spirit of Christ" and "do not belong to him."
So "anyone who" could be interpreted as "any church that". Is that correct?
dies-l said:No. That is not at all what I said, and I think you know that. "Whoever" or "anyone who" likely does refer to individuals, families, and others who are outside of the church and are therefore outside of Christ.
My bad, bro. I misread my own reference. I see where you are coming from. Let's look at 8:5 because I really am trying to understand where you see this as being corporate without presupposing that it is.
For those [churches] who live according to the flesh set their minds on the things of the flesh, but those [churches] who live according to the Spirit set their minds on the things of the Spirit.
Is this how you understand this to mean?
ok.You know there's no such thing as the word "whosoever" in the Greek language right?
Whosoever believes is the literally translation of the phrase "pas ho pisteuwn" which is, literally "all the believing". So "whoever believes" includes only those who meet the qualification: believes. It does not include those who do not believe.
There's two kinds of people: Whosoever believes, and whosoever does not believe.
This shall go down as one of my all-time favorite quotes from 5-pointers. I hope you don't mind. This statement does a lot to clarify the difference between 5-pointers and other Calvinists, the restatement of one of the most popular general verses in the Bible to make it support limited atonement. This should show readers to what extent we will go to to defend our doctrine once it becomes an integral part of our faith, IOW once our faith and security in part depends on defending it. Once we start looking through pink-tinted glasses, everything has a tint of pink to it.John 3:16 for example does not apply to the unbelievers. God demonstrated his love for the world by sending his son to save all the believers. Notice the verse does not say "so that everyone could have eternal life", but rather "so that the believers have eternal life"
John 3:16 is one of most particular/limiting verses in the whole Bible.
Okay, I know election to be true because the Bible teaches it but where I am still confused is the area of how and why God elects certain individuals and not others.
The way I was tought growing up was that God calls and then its up to us to respond to his call, so if this is the case then does God elect upon the basis of knowing who would respond to his offer of salvation and who would not?
To me thats the only way I can see it and because we are told in the scriptures of warnings against hardening our hearts etc so apparently when God calls we have the choice to respond to his call or to turn away and harden our hearts.
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?