The Catholic-only board is definitely necessary, in my opinion. If I have a question specifically about Catholic pracitices I want to be able to ask it to other Catholics.
As an example, I accidentally posted to Interfaith Discussion the question "I am going to Confession on Saturday, I need some help knowing exactly what to do" or something like that. It turned into yet another "is confession Biblical" debate. This happens with *every* Catholic-oriented thread unless you have a separate forum.
Of course, in a perfect situation the divisions would not be necessary -- people would realize that a question from a Catholic about a Catholic practice should be respected as an "intrafaith" question, but this is clearly not a perfect situation.
-Chris
As an example, I accidentally posted to Interfaith Discussion the question "I am going to Confession on Saturday, I need some help knowing exactly what to do" or something like that. It turned into yet another "is confession Biblical" debate. This happens with *every* Catholic-oriented thread unless you have a separate forum.
Of course, in a perfect situation the divisions would not be necessary -- people would realize that a question from a Catholic about a Catholic practice should be respected as an "intrafaith" question, but this is clearly not a perfect situation.
-Chris
Upvote
0