New "Are you a Heretic?" thread.

I knew when I came to one question that I would be a heretic. However some of the questions were a little ambiguous. Nonetheless it tested the little grey cells.

Hooray! Not a heretic!

I got 100% Chalcedonian compliant which quite surprised me. I'm surprised I didn't have heretical leanings out of any sort of ignorance.

Bananna said:

LOL I think that was a Catholic test.

I wonder if I can find a Baptist one. It ofcourse would lean toward Baptist.

Yes, I'm rated a Heretic, no surprise to me.
I'm in UT for a reason.
bananna

Click to expand...

The doctrine set to determine who is a heretic was defined by the Catholic Church. Originally any disagreement with Catholicism made one a heretic.

I am allegedly a Pelagian, which doesn't surprise me. After all Judaism has always taught that keeping mitzvos leads to righteousness. No Tzaddik ever ate pork.

Anyone surprised that chr*stiaity thinks me a pagan? Ironic that before my Tshuva I was thinking of becoming an Orthodox monk.

Yochanan

You Scored as Chalcedon compliantYou are Chalcedon compliant. Congratulations, you're not a heretic. You believe that Jesus is truly God and truly man and like us in every respect, apart from sin. Officially approved in 451.

Yes, well, I may not be a heretic in this test but the RCC considers me a heretic anyway for believing ALL will be saved and none will experience endless torment...

You are a Pelagian. You reject ideas about man's fallen human nature and believe that as a result we are able to fully obey God. You are the first Briton to contribute significantly to Christian thought, but you're still excommunicated in 417.


Apollanarian 67%
Pelagianism 67%
Monophysitism 33%
Chalcedon compliant 33%
Nestorianism 33%

Chalk up another Chalcedon Compliant!

Bananna said:

How many of these quizes can we find to use as reference points.

Please do not use this to decide you can call people Heretics. This is to help discern what belief system you are functing under to promote communication and understanding of what people are saying.

Most people won't be 100% anything.

bananna
http://quizfarm.com/quizzes/new/svensvensven/are-you-a-heretic/

Click to expand...

Thank you for the link,it is a very funny test ! Though I have some doubts concerning the accuracy of my results.

You Scored as Chalcedon compliant
You are Chalcedon compliant. Congratulations, you're not a heretic. You believe that Jesus is truly God and truly man and like us in every respect, apart from sin. Officially approved in 451.


Chalcedon compliant100%Monophysitism67%Nestorianism67%Apollanarian50%Pelagianism33%Monarchianism33%Donatism33%Modalism33%Adoptionist33%Albigensianism17%Arianism17%Socinianism17%Gnosticism0%Docetism

Quite a few I answered in the neutral, I didn't understand the wording of them.

You are a Nestorian. You hold that Jesus is two distinct persons, one human and one divine, sometimes acting out of one nature, and sometimes out of the other. Rejected by the Council of Ephesus in 431, but persisted until the middle ages.


Nestorianism92%Chalcedon compliant83%Monarchianism75%Apollanarian67%Monophysitism67%Socinianism67%Arianism67%Modalism58%Pelagianism25%Adoptionist17%Gnosticism8%Donatism0%Albigensianism0%Docetism

Bananna said:

How many of these quizes can we find to use as reference points.

Please do not use this to decide you can call people Heretics. This is to help discern what belief system you are functing under to promote communication and understanding of what people are saying.

Most people won't be 100% anything.

bananna
http://quizfarm.com/quizzes/new/svensvensven/are-you-a-heretic/

Click to expand...

Woo-hoo!!

You Scored as Chalcedon compliantYou are Chalcedon compliant. Congratulations, you're not a heretic.
You believe that Jesus is truly God and truly man and like us in every respect, apart from sin. Officially approved in 451.


Chalcedon compliant
67% Nestorianism
33% Monophysitism
33% Modalism
33% Apollanarian
17% Albigensianism
8% Socinianism
0% Monarchianism
0% Donatism
0% Pelagianism
0% Adoptionist
0% Docetism
0% Arianism
0% Gnosticism
0%



Some of the questions were difficult for me to understand.
I think only a scholar of theology would understand some of what they were saying.
I thinks it's a test that's difficult to score well on if you haven't heard much formal theology taught, even if you're not a heretic.

Luckily I'm a theologian! Imagine how much harder it would have been not to fall into heresy before a lot of these definitions were made.

You Scored as Monophysitism
You are a monophysite. You do not hold to the idea of a hypostatic union of the divine and human in the person of Christ and instead hold that Christ had only one nature, which is a fusion of the divine and human. Condemned at the Sixth Ecumenical Council in 681.


Socinianism50%Monophysitism50%Chalcedon compliant50%Monarchianism42%Modalism42%Pelagianism25%Gnosticism17%Nestorianism8%Apollanarian8%Albigensianism0%Donatism0%Adoptionist0%Docetism0%Arianism0%

Well....ain't that sumpthin. First time I've not been called a heretic in a long time. LOL

I thought people who believed in Ultimate Reconciliation were automatically heretics.

kat


Chalcedon compliant
100%
Apollanarian
100%
Nestorianism
67%
Monarchianism
67%
Monophysitism
67%
Adoptionist
58%
Pelagianism
58%
Socinianism
33%
Modalism
33%
Gnosticism
33%
Arianism
17%
Donatism
0%
Albigensianism
0%
Docetism
0%

katallasso said:

Well....ain't that sumpthin. First time I've not been called a heretic in a long time. LOL

I thought people who believed in Ultimate Reconciliation were automatically heretics.

kat


Chalcedon compliant
100%
Apollanarian
100%
Nestorianism
67%
Monarchianism
67%
Monophysitism
67%
Adoptionist
58%
Pelagianism
58%
Socinianism
33%
Modalism
33%
Gnosticism
33%
Arianism
17%
Donatism
0%
Albigensianism
0%
Docetism
0%

Click to expand...

Ya know, I don't think the RCC is as dead set against Ultimate Reconciliation as what the Fundies are!