I surrender to Jesus out of fear of God's wrath, but not out of love. I do not know how to surrender to him out of love. I want to turn from my sin in fact I am working on that right now.
I fear for my soul and I fear for my life. But Christians have told me that my motivations are wrong. I have argued with them in the past, but now I'm thinking maybe they could be right.
How does one surrender to Jesus with the right motivation? I can't seem to work up the right motivation.
I think ShoeToYou's advise is helpful. Doing anything because one is afraid of wrath, be it God's or just another human, is completely unhealthy. Two things happen, one is that you encourage more wrath when someone finds it is effective, the other is that you become a totally miserable person because you allow another to control you.
What Jesus calls people to do is to live a life that expresses His teachings. Most of His teachings are contrary to how humans are used to living. One doesn't love one's enemies, one doesn't stifle lust in one's heart, one doesn't live a humble life, one doesn't give away wealth to follow Jesus and one certainly doesn't trust God with their very existence.
These are all things which are centered on other people and not on oneself. They are things that make others more important and you less important. It flies in the face of all things human.
But it can be done. One starts by making a conscious effort to do little things as often as one can remember to do them. Hold the door open for others even if the other is someone you don't like. Look women in the eye when talking to them regardless of how attractive they are. Smile at people even when they glare at you. (that one drives others crazy) Drive courteously even when you are late.
What will happen is gradually you will do these things without thinking about them. You are forming a habit when you consciously think of others first. Once these small things become a habit, consciously start tackling larger things. Offer to work on a community event, join a community oriented organization where things you know how to do can be used to benefit others, start bringing in cans of coffee for the break room...all the time so others don't have to.
Soon that becomes a habit too. My guess is that about this time, you will find your concern about yourself will fall away and become replaced with a concern for those around you. And you will find that you are happier than you ever have been because helping others is the greatest work of life.
And that is really all following Jesus is about. It is lifting others up who are behind you and pushing those ahead of you even further ahead. And it all starts when you see someone without a smile and you give them one of yours.