LOSTies vs. Others

[AirPo]

In episode 3.18, D.O.C., Desmond said the LOSTies have killed more Others than the Others have LOSTies.

Is that right?

 

[MtDoraAngel]

YUP!

The others have just taken people. I haven't seen where they actually killed anyone.

Other kills:
Goodwin - Nathan (Other)
Goodwin - Steve/Scott (Lostie)
Juliet - Picket (Other)
Tom - shot Sawyer but didn't kill him
Patchy - shot Sayid but didn't kill him

Lostie kills:
Charlie - Ethan
Sun - Colleen
A. L. - Goodwin
Locke - Patchy (well sort of)
Eko - 3 the night of abductions

Lostie/Lostie kills:
A.L. - Shannon
Michael - A.L. and Libby
Nikki - Pallo and herself (if even by mistake)

I can't think of any more. Please add to the list.

 

[AirPo]

Juliet - Picket (Other)

That's "other" vs Other, so I wouldn't count it.

Ethan killed Scott(Steve?)

I thought some tailies were killed, or were they only kidnapped?

Micheal was under the influence of the Others, so does that count as Other kills Lostie?

 

[MtDoraAngel]

I think they were only kidnapped.

So if our calculation is correct, so far we have

Others kill Lostie = 1
Others kill Other = 2
Losties kill Other = 6+
Lostie kills Lostie = 6 (including the marshall)

 

[snoochface]

I thought it was interesting that Desmond knew that. Unless they've suddenly started sharing information with each other - which was indicated last night, but seems to be a rather recent trend among this bunch - I wonder how he would know what was going on while he was in the hatch. More flashes or just, finally, some conversations between each other?

 

[MissVegas]

kinda makes ya wonder what ALL desmond really does know!

 

[desmalia]

Ethan killed Charlie... or at least he thought he did. Jack was able to revive him. But I still think that counts!