Immaculate Conception - Why Did It Take 1,854 Years to Discover This Doctrine?

[Kepha]

Can't be proven by God written word that is for correction reproof and fully equipping the man of God. Where do we see that God has spoken orally and it has not been written down?

If the Written Word was all you needed then all the Apostles would have penned it to paper would they not? Show me where Jesus told one of them to Write. Oh and this you must show explicity since you guys love to have explicit writings from us for your own reading.

Think about it, wouldn't all of the writings that they sent out have survived as well? We know that didnt happen. You guys like to claim how Jesus always used it but did you ever stop to think how Christ would cite a tiny verse then expand greatly on it? That is What the Church does but you choose not to listen. Get out of your Sola Scripture theory IamAdopted before it hurts you anymore than it already has.

Oh and show us in the Bible your table of contents to which books belong in there and which do not. I want Chapter and verse. Thank you.

 

[ScottBot]

I have not seen this scripture. No where. Please site it again. It is not in there. Can't be proven by God written word that is for correction reproof and fully equipping the man of God. Where do we see that God has spoken orally and it has not been written down?

[bible]john 21:25[/bible]

 

[HisBelovedMelody]

[bible]john 21:25[/bible]

that is what JESUS said and did...NOT the apostles...come on read the black and white there...it didn't say nothing about apostles teachings....

 

[Hentenza]

Of course it is not talking about Jesus since I never said it was. Can you even interpretate on here.
My point is that you are picking and choosing which verse of psalms 69 you want to be talking about Christ and which are not which again is zero proof by you. You quoted one to disprove our stance on Mary not having kids. That is your interpretation and not ours.

Yes I can, Psalm 69 is messianic. God's will has been revealed plainly in the New Testament and prophetically in the Old. I am not picking and choosing. The evidence stands by itself. It is not even YOUR interpretation, it is the Catholic's church interpretation.

Since when did Jesus not come first when talking about Mary? I'm pretty sure if they meant Mary the Mother of Jesus, they wold have said just that or made sure we knew exactly which Mary it was as done in John 19 when still talking about who was at the cross. Oh and look, there were 3 Mary's there.

Jn 19:25, "Now there stood by the cross of Jesus His mother (Mary) and His mothers sister, Mary the wife of Cleophas, and Mary Magdalene."

If the argument does not suit the Catholic church then they need to defend it. Are you grabing at straws? I'll let you figure that one out.

 

[Hentenza]

This pretty much sums it up doesn't it?

Yep! It does for me. But the saga continues.................

 

[Hentenza]

I'm truely sorry if you don't like the answers that have always been given to the question of the Immaculate Conception and Perpetual Virginity of Mary. I'm sorry you've rejected them in favor of your own counsel. I'm sorry if you can't see the hypocrisy of your own arrogance. But go right ahead, enlighten me with your new revelations and insight into the intended meaning of Scripture.

I am still waiting for your refutal. See if you can enlighten me, after all according to you your revelations are correct.

 

[Hentenza]

It's been done.

Where? :o

 

[HisBelovedMelody]

they aren't answers..just throwing catholic doctrine around...try reading the book for youself and see whatcha come up with..

 

[Kepha]

Yes I can, Psalm 69 is messianic. God's will has been revealed plainly in the New Testament and prophetically in the Old. I am not picking and choosing. The evidence stands by itself. It is not even YOUR interpretation, it is the Catholic's church interpretation.

What evidence. You mean the kind where YOU cite a verse then tell us it HAS to be about Christ because someone told you? Or has the Bible verbally spoken to and said it? You said verse 4 was talking about him, oh but not verse 5, oh but the one after that was talking about him again. Make up your mind. Sheesh.

If the argument does not suit the Catholic church then they need to defend it. Are you grabing at straws? I'll let you figure that one out.

I'm grabbing at nothing. I just showed you it said there were 3 Mary's there yet you're too proud to admit you may be wrong on your first interpretation of that verse you threw at me.

 

[Hentenza]

[bible]john 21:25[/bible]

Do you actually know what that verse means? Is there anything in that verse that says to listen to oral tradition? I think not. Stop trying to change the topic.

 

[Kepha]

they aren't answers..just throwing catholic doctrine around...try reading the book for youself and see whatcha come up with..

Thanks but no thanks. All that would do is have us splinter into hundreds of denominations all claiming we know what the Bible is saying.

My friend got divorced and says its ok. My other non denom friend says he's wrong. They both read the Bible. It makes a mockery of God's Word.

 

[HisBelovedMelody]

Thanks but no thanks. All that would do is have us splinter into hundreds of denominations all claiming we know what the Bible is saying.

My friend got divorced and says its ok. My other non denom friend says he's wrong. They both read the Bible. It makes a mockery of God's Word.

and some of your doctrines don't?? That is a joke..

 

[Hentenza]

they aren't answers..just throwing catholic doctrine around...try reading the book for youself and see whatcha come up with..

Think for yourself????? LOL!

 

[HisBelovedMelody]

Think for yourself????? LOL!

nah, not smart enough for that. I mean..the scripture that was quoted was about what JESUS taught and did...NOT the apostles..so shoots that theory down...I got told the other day I was a dumb peanut....so...lol

 

[Kepha]

and some of your doctrines don't?? That is a joke..

If it did then Jesus would be a liar when he handed the Keys to Peter and said Hell would never prevail. The only joke is people believing that sola Scripture is logical when for the most part, hardly anyone could read it for over a millenium with little to go around to boot.

 

[Hentenza]

What evidence. You mean the kind where YOU cite a verse then tell us it HAS to be about Christ because someone told you? Or has the Bible verbally spoken to and said it? You said verse 4 was talking about him, oh but not verse 5, oh but the one after that was talking about him again. Make up your mind. Sheesh.

Did you miss the part where Jesus quoted Psalm 69-4 in John 15:25 and Psalm 69-9 in John 2:16-17. Actually, Jesus told me so through his word.

I'm grabbing at nothing. I just showed you it said there were 3 Mary's there yet you're too proud to admit you may be wrong on your first interpretation of that verse you threw at me.

So, are you saying that Matthew was wrong? Do you know what synoptic gospels mean? Has that been part of your cathechism classes? Yes, you are grabing at straws.

 

[Kepha]

nah, not smart enough for that.

Wow, pretty insulting there.

I mean..the scripture that was quoted was about what JESUS taught and did...NOT the apostles..so shoots that theory down...I got told the other day I was a dumb peanut....so...lol

It said not all was written down. I ask why not if it was so important? It seems allot of things are not clear to you guys or you wouldnt continue your splintering. You needed all the writings you could get your hands I would think.

 

[HisBelovedMelody]

If it did then Jesus would be a liar when he handed the Keys to Peter and said Hell would never prevail. The only joke is people believing that sola Scripture is logical when for the most part, hardly anyone could read it for over a millenium with little to go around to boot.

OH PUULLLLEEAZE....hell IS NOT prevailing against HIS children at all....OH forget it...this is SO tiring listening to this jibberish!

 

[HisBelovedMelody]

Wow, pretty insulting there.


It said not all was written down. I ask why not if it was so important? It seems allot of things are not clear to you guys or you wouldnt continue your splintering. You needed all the writings you could get your hands I would think.

darlin' that was pointed to MYSELF...NOT you. RELAX. READ THE BIBLE...it says that ALL the stuff JESUS JESUS..the main Guy...know Him?? IF ALL HE did was WRITTEN DOWN...........NOT the apostles.....for goodness sake...doesn't need that much work to read it...see it for what IT SAYS>...................................................

 

[Hentenza]

nah, not smart enough for that. I mean..the scripture that was quoted was about what JESUS taught and did...NOT the apostles..so shoots that theory down...I got told the other day I was a dumb peanut....so...lol

You don't like peanuts?