hey phil,
There are more miracles in the Scriptures than two. Pick another one and find the evidence for it. You are on the right track when you conclude that if there is no evidence for #1 then there won't be any evidence for #2, but I think that you'll find that the truth is that it's a lot more overwhelming than just #1 and #2. What you'll finally wind up having to say is, "Well so there's not evidence for #1 and #3 and #4 and #6 and #7,#8,#9,#10, #11, etc. etc. there can't be any evidence for #2." When you reach that conclusion, then yes, I'll agree as it is exactly my point.
As I have said here, if you're finding it difficult to find scientific, provable evidence that Jesus turned water into wine, then pick another miracle. There are certainly plenty more to choose from. Get back to me when you've got one that you can prove with scientific evidence.
Then you wrote: The argument simply doesn't work because it's not the act of creation that we are trying to find evidence for, it is the history of the earth we are trying to find evidence for.
Right! And it's not finding the evidence of the creation of the specific wine that Jesus made. After all, anyone can show you and demonstrate how to make water into wine. You take some concentrated grape juice and mix it with three canfuls of water as though you were making regular grape juice from concentrate, but after that you add some additional sugar and yeast and you allow it to ferment for an extended period of time, oh, a month or so. So, it's not the creation of the wine that's the miracle so much as it's the time and starting ingredients that Jesus used. Anybody can make wine!
You see, friend, any one who has made wine; even scientists who can explain the fermentation process will tell you that it is impossible to take a jug of water and within a matter of moments have wine. Therefore, Jesus could not have done it that way. Simple, right? Hopefully you see the correlation, but the design and scope are much grander and powerful and majestic in the creation.
Light travels at x speed. Therefore, it is impossible for God to have made the creation as it says. Hmmmmmm. Why does this sound familiar? Anyway, pick another one and let me know when you find just one for which you have scientifically provable evidence for how it was done.
God bless you.
In Christ, Ted