I don't think so much that its fair to say that all first marriages are God-ordained. I also don't believe that God leads every spouse into our lives. When I met my first husband, I was involved in all sorts of bad things (i.e. alcohol, partying) and I had turned from God. Why, then, would God lead an abusive man to me and say "here you go, marry him." ? That, to me, is absurd. When I met my current husband, I was involed in leading the youth group and closer to God than I had ever been and God lead HIM into my life in HIS time, not mine. You are so quick to judge those of us who are divorced and remarried, saying that we must be living in sin. However, I know at LEAST a dozen men and women who are remarried and are such key factors in God's work. They serve God with such passion and such faithfulness, and are so close in their walk with Him, how can anyone say that they are living in sin? From my experiences, when you are living in sin, God has no part of your life. In fact, God cannot look at sin so he turns his back on it.
I dont think that I or anyone else on this thread is telling her to do to him what he is doing to her. All we are saying is that it may be best at this point to walk away. If he has already walked away physically, emotionally and spiritually, that is what i call "marital unfaithfulness" and that is reason to walk away. We are called to love those who don't deserved to be loved, you are right. But we are not called to stay in a marriage where the other person is not. She can continue to love him because God created him...and not be married to him. I will always love my ex husband, not because of how he treated me but because God called me to. God didnt call me to stay in a marriage where I was abused and near-killed on several ocassions. Jesus calls us to die of self and follow him, but he doesn't call us to stay in a marriage where we are no longer even a person, just a simple being in existence day to day with no feelings and no sense of belonging. Abusive marriages do that, you know. They strip everything you ever knew.
What you see as bad counsel is what we see as life experience that God had led us through. Who are you to judge when I know for a fact that I am in accordance with God's will? The God that you are describing is unforgiving and makes no room for mistakes. I serve a God that makes room for mistakes because he knows that we are human. He also forgives us when we fall away, be that yesterday or be that ten years ago...God forgives.
All marriages have problems and trails, they are inevitable. My husband and I have the same problems that every other healthy marriage has. And we work through them and we get past them, with God's help. In my previous marriage, I tried everything; marriage counseling (with 2 diff. christian counselors who told me it was best to walk away), secular counseling, meetings with my pastor, time, waiting on the Lord..I tried it all...and God finally laid it on my heart to walk away. There was no doubt in my mind. I left him and tried to leave him countless times...and always came back. When I left him the last time, I knew beyond a shadow of a doubt that 1) I was right where I needed to be and 2) I wouldn't be going back and 3) I was right where GOD WANTED me.
So Ash, I do apologize for being so hasty in suggesting walking away RIGHT AWAY, seems my heart was calloused to God's ability to work things out...as He did this weekend for my sister-in-law and her husband. It is a process, but it is also a process that I don't think he calls each and every one of us to do. You are the ONLY one that can make the decision to walk away, dear sister. My family and friends begged me not to marry my ex husband...begged me from the first week to walk away and it took me two years to finally do so. When I did it, though, when I finally walked away, I had no regrets. So I say to you, Ash, until you know for a FACT that it is where God wants you (as I did, in spite of what some naive and judgemental people may think), I would say wiat for him, but don't underestimate our God...He loves you and he wants what is best for you, whether that be with or without your husband. You are a strong woman of God and He will see you through...no matter what! Only God can answer that question for you. God bless you and I continue to pray for you.