- Dec 20, 2009
- 30,436
- 8,631
- Country
- Canada
- Faith
- Christian Seeker
- Marital Status
- Married
Something to consider: I grew up in the Pittsburgh area which has a very definite dialect of English. When I responded to God's call to go into the military I learned pretty quickly that people not from Pittsburgh couldn't understand me, (and my dialect wasn't as strong as some people I knew), and I had to learn to speak differently. Now I live a bit further north than where I grew up and very close to an area where three very distinct dialects are common. I can think of a few convenience stores where you could easily find an Amish, a Yinzer, and a Midwestern-speaking local in the evening of the first Monday of December. So, I picture the three of them reading the same paragraph out loud at the same time and try to imagine me understanding what they are saying well enough to repeat any of it back, and I hear in two of those dialects fluently. Now add in a Bronx New Yorker and a Bostonian. We still haven't gotten southwest of the Allegheny Mountains, and I probably wouldn't be able to repeat any of it back in their words. Now let's grab a native Virginian and an Alabaman. Let's go back to NY and add in someone from Harlem. Now I'm barely picking out single words and we haven't left the Eastern time zone. Now let's get closer to at least crossing the Mississippi, but I won't be fair about this, a Cajun, and three people from different parts of Tennessee. These people all technically speak different dialects of the same language, but if you had them all all on a stage reading the same passage of literature at the same time and at the same pace and volume into microphones, it would be an indiscernible cacophony even if you spoke one of their dialects.
The Bible says in Acts 2 that every nation under the sun was represented there. How many complete languages would that have been? Yet, each person heard in his own dialect. Are we really sure that human languages were spoken in Acts 2?
In Acts 2, the people speaking spoke in their own language . the holy spirit acted as a filter that caused each person to hear what was said in their own language . it's slightly different than the gift of tongues and it's psychological counterpart/mimick baby talk . it is different because what happened was different . this is more of a "wonder" that involved translation and in a way symbolically signalled that the curse of babel has been reversed .
Upvote
0