• Starting today August 7th, 2024, in order to post in the Married Couples, Courting Couples, or Singles forums, you will not be allowed to post if you have your Marital status designated as private. Announcements will be made in the respective forums as well but please note that if yours is currently listed as Private, you will need to submit a ticket in the Support Area to have yours changed.

How to get husband to open up

Luther073082

κύριε ἐλέησον χριστὲ ἐλέησον
Apr 1, 2007
19,202
840
43
New Carlisle, IN
✟46,326.00
Faith
Lutheran
Marital Status
Married
Politics
US-Others
Maybe he's just not someone who likes to talk.

My wife can talk for hours about what happened at work today. I can talk for 15 minutes about it only if I have a really really bad day. Other then that I just figure, work is work, work is over, I'm at home and I'll leave work at work.
 
Upvote 0

Green Scottie

Newbie
Jan 29, 2013
31
1
✟15,156.00
Faith
Non-Denom
Have you tried talking to him?

Nothing personal, but this is--without doubt--the worst advice you could give her.

I suggest you read either "For Women Only" (Feldhahn) or "7 Things He'll Never Tell You" (Leaman), and try to do it with out laughing out loud and asking your husband "they can't be serious; you don't think like this, do you?" (which is what my wife did). They are serious, and your husband does think like that.

It's very likely that talking to him--in the wrong way--is one of the reasons he is shutting down. What often seems like a harmless conversation to a wife is filled with time-bombs from the husband's perspective.
 
Upvote 0
C

ChristianGolfer

Guest
Nothing personal, but this is--without doubt--the worst advice you could give her.

I suggest you read either "For Women Only" (Feldhahn) or "7 Things He'll Never Tell You" (Leaman), and try to do it with out laughing out loud and asking your husband "they can't be serious; you don't think like this, do you?" (which is what my wife did). They are serious, and your husband does think like that.

It's very likely that talking to him--in the wrong way--is one of the reasons he is shutting down. What often seems like a harmless conversation to a wife is filled with time-bombs from the husband's perspective.

This is terrible advice, IMHO.

Communication between husband and wife is VITAL.

And human beings are unique individuals. Not all men think alike and not all women think alike. To assume you know what one individual is thinking or feeling just because some fool wrote a book and claimed to know what every man and every woman thinks.....

It's foolishness.
 
Upvote 0

Satine

Life Troubleshooter
Jun 26, 2008
99
8
Visit site
✟22,774.00
Faith
Atheist
Marital Status
In Relationship
A few tecniques for getting any person to talk:

Mirroring - if the person says something that might be hinting at more to be said, mirror a word or phrase of what they've said back to you.

E.g., "I had a terrible day today."
"Terrible?"

It's a good one to do, partly because you can get the other person to say a lot without actually adding anything. It's a good way of drawing someone out while remaining neutral in your own approach to the conversation. So everything they say comes truly from them.

Reflecting - similar to the above, only you make your own choice of word.

E.g., "I had a terrible day today."
"It was a hard day?"

It's a way of showing that you're listening and of checking that you understand properly without adding very much of your own judgement to the conversation.

You can reflect anything from one word to whole paragraphs.

Summarizing - when the person has been talking for a while, if you summarize your understanding of the conversation back to them it can be a useful way of checking that you've understood. It can be that you hear a person talk about their stresses and be picking mainly up on their family problems when actually the big issue for them is being short of money. So summarizing lets you check with the person.

Asking questions - the person who asks questions in a conversation controls the conversation itself. Questions drive a conversation.

I cannot work out from your contributions to this thread so far whether you ask him much - perhaps he is shrinking away from too many questions from you or perhaps you don't come forward with questions so he has no stimulus to speak - so use your own judgement in how to use questions.

Note also that while questions open up a person to talk, they can also narrow the person's choice of things to say. So use them judiciously.

Think about using only open questions (ones that start with why, when, where, how and who). Open questions beg any answer but 'yes' and 'no'. That said, closed (yes/no) questions can have their uses. But to be aware of the difference can be very helpful.

The Ware Sequence - there are three ways of contacting a person: via feelings, thoughts and behaviour. Different personality types have different orders in which they like to be contacted. I don't have time or space to talk here about the different personality types and in any case, the information is available online, but it may be worth you trying him with each one.

A person will have an 'open door' mode. Mine is thinking, so I like to get straight into talking about deep stuff without any small talk, but another person might need to start by talking about feelings. If someone comes up to me saying, "Hi Satine! How are you feeling?" then it feels like a waste of time to me. But if I went up to the person with feelings as her open door and said, "Hi. So, do you have any ideas on what we're going to say on this thread?" then they would feel unloved and like I was being cold. Another person might prefer that you go up to them ready to do some kind of activity.

The second part of the sequence is the 'target door'. It's not a good idea to walk straight up to the person and approach them with their target door mode but once you've got into rapport with them via their open door, you can. Mine is feelings. I don't want to give up how I feel until I feel like I'm on the same wavelength as another person, but to someone else their target door might be behaviour. Make sure you contact them via their open door before asking them to do anything!

The final mode is the 'trap door'. Don't try to approach the person with this because you, and they, will get stuck. Mine is behaviour and I'm naturally quite an apathetic person. However, all is not lost with the person's trap door, because all you have to do is get to their target door and stay there with them. They will tend to do their own work on their trap door mode. I don't choose to go out for hikes but my boyfriend has a good brain (meets me at thinking), we fall into rapport together and share feelings (my open door) and from there I can do my own behaviours (when I'm feeling looked after, I'll be busy all day. But he cannot push me and when he does, I dig my heels in so hard I find it virtually impossible to stop.)

I don't know how useful these bits and pieces will be to you, but I think they're all worth trying.

Good luck to both of you and I hope you find yourselves in a warm bed of lovely rapport together soon.
 
Upvote 0

Green Scottie

Newbie
Jan 29, 2013
31
1
✟15,156.00
Faith
Non-Denom
This is terrible advice, IMHO.

Communication between husband and wife is VITAL.

And human beings are unique individuals. Not all men think alike and not all women think alike. To assume you know what one individual is thinking or feeling just because some fool wrote a book and claimed to know what every man and every woman thinks.....

It's foolishness.

Did I say to not communicate with him? No, I didn't.

What I said was there is more to "just taking" than just talking. Men and women both (as a group) communicate in different styles--styles that are often not compatible.

Taking a little time to stand in someone else's shoes and learn "how" they communicate will go a long way in establishing better communication.
 
Upvote 0

Tropical Wilds

Little Lebowski Urban Achiever
Oct 2, 2009
6,801
4,950
New England
✟261,397.00
Country
United States
Gender
Female
Faith
Non-Denom
Marital Status
Married
Politics
US-Others
Nothing personal, but this is--without doubt--the worst advice you could give her.

I suggest you read either "For Women Only" (Feldhahn) or "7 Things He'll Never Tell You" (Leaman), and try to do it with out laughing out loud and asking your husband "they can't be serious; you don't think like this, do you?" (which is what my wife did). They are serious, and your husband does think like that.

It's very likely that talking to him--in the wrong way--is one of the reasons he is shutting down. What often seems like a harmless conversation to a wife is filled with time-bombs from the husband's perspective.

Oh obviously... Talking to one's husband about their issues is stupid. Why would anybody ever do that? Really, deferring to a book to find out how my husband thinks and how I need to change myself to entice him into basic communication is the way to go. I think most spouses would be happy to know that instead of talking about marital issues, we rely on books to tell us how they think and why.

:doh:
 
Upvote 0