The purpose you mention here is self satisfaction.what they do for others is the important bit.Being loving, caring and truthful is what's important.So am i.
Yes but I'm also saying that it is not wrong to do something that gives us pleasure just because it gives us pleasure.
We are important too; we are allowed to look after and enjoy ourselves.
I have toomuch time on my hands, but hobbies don't give me the satisfaction anymore, because it is just focussed on my feelings about myself, and they entail pointless feeble works.
Well I admit that it depends on what someone's hobby is and how much time they spend on it. We are not to worship idols or do anything that may get put of control or become an addiction and hurt others.
Playing a couple of harmless computer games a day because you enjoy them, is one thing and is fine; sitting in a room for 3-4 hours at a time playing violent games, isn't.
It's vanity.The commandments are basically to love God and equal to that, love fellow humans.
This means repentance and baring fruits of the Faith.
All this doesn't imply it is 'bad' to have a hobby though.
That was my point; that hobbies are not bad, or wrong. The posts I read were implying that they are.
Hobbies can also teach us useful skills.
But on their own it's rather vain.
Not really.
First of all, if your want to practise your hobby entirely n your own, that's up to you.
Secondly, a lot of hobbies involve creative skills and these have to be practised before they can be offered to others. A boy wouldn't say, my hobby is kicking a ball; that qualifies me to teach football to others. He would have to practice, maybe on his own, to improve his skills and learn new ones. When he has done that, whether he plays football professionally, teaches it to other boys as a paid job or just relaxes by playing in a team on a Saturday, is up to him.
I enjoy making greetings cards. If I practised for hours and bought all the right equipment, I daresay I could sell them and make some money from them. If I also taught, wrote books, produced DVDs and ran courses, I dare say I could probably turn my hobby into a career. I don't want to do that; I just want to make a card for Mrs A to assure her she is not forgotten, or for Mr B who is facing an operation. Because I care about them, want to make the best cards that I can for them and believe in doing everything for the glory of God; I practice, and may experiment and learn new skills. I don't believe that is wrong. If I sit in my craft room for 2 hours, creating and playing, but don't actually produce anything at the end of it, that is still not wrong.
A couple of posts seemed to imply that it would be.
And thus more than just a hobby.
No, hobbies may benefit other people, they are still our hobbies though.
If someone asked me to make 3 cakes for a church fair, that, for me, would be a hassle and not very enjoyable - even if they were all very plain with just icing sugar on top. Someone who enjoyed cooking could probably make 5 or 6 in the same amount of time, get a lot more pleasure out of doing them, and they might well have fancy icing/sugarcraft work on them.
Maybe we mean something slightly different when we say "hobby".
Could be. Sorry, I may have reacted without knowing exactly what you meant.
I'm thinking of typical male hobbies, i think you think about people who do what they love to do of which others can benefit too.That's true....but this is all directed at a person's own well being, and therefore the centre is the self, therefore it is self centred.
We all take up hobbies to relax and because we enjoy doing them.
Whether we make cakes for ourselves that we end up eating ourselves, or give, or sell, them for good causes; that is still true - it is designing, making and decorating them which is enjoyable. I daresay that some people find playing football, darts or dominoes enjoyable; I don't. I think they are pointless and boring. But whether someone plays dominoes purely to relax or starts a competition, builds a team and so meets other people and raise money - that is their hobby and they have the right to follow it.
That's true....but this is all directed at a person's own well being, and therefore the centre is the self, therefore it is self centred.
Relaxing and doing something that you enjoy, is not a sin - although if someone has such low self esteem that they believe they are not important, it my feel like that.
I can spend hours colouring cards for other people; if I start to colour a picture for myself, that no one else will see or benefit from; I feel guilty. That doesn't mean that colouring is wrong or has suddenly become sinful, just that I feel I have to give all the time, and that I'm not that important.