Bigun said:
Sounds like our wives came from the same gene pool Wayne.
See, what's odd about Jill's suggestion is that my wife suggested the very same thing. But it seems she has more animosity to me giving money to the church rather than giving it to God.
So the question is this: Is it the same as tithing if your tithe money went to a worthy cause (homeless shelter, etc.)?
Another better question is this another attempt at her to control me? And if so, would compromising on this be an issue?
As far as the seperate checking account, that was one of the first things I mentioned, but for whatever reason, she doesn't want to do that. *shrug* I'm just plain confused.
Same gene pool? Honestly, I'm sorry for you. My wife's issues stem from her poor relationship with her father, which she transferred to all men, especially me. My FIL is laying on his death bed now, and she's preparing to go see him. One last chance, perhaps, for her to deal with issues between them.
And your wife's animosity about giving to the church (same as mine)...could be she doesn't like churches, or authority, or male authority, or like you said, just trying to control you. Who knows. If you determine it is an issue of her trying to control you, well, IMO it would be time for you to not compromise on that one. The more you allow a controlling person to control you, the more they will continue.
Is it the same as giving to the church if you give to another worthy cause? Depends on which Pastor you ask. I would not dismiss it out of hand, as every situation is different and requires prayer for God's wisdom. I will say that my Pastor doesn't believe it is the same. He often quotes Malachi 3:10, "Bring the whole tithe into the storehouse, that there may be food in my house" as being a reference to giving to the local church you are attending. And the churches need income to survive.
And of course she doesn't want a separate checking account. That would be less control for her, or perhaps she likes to share everything with total openness in a marriage. I was like that once. But when it's only one-way, it gets old after awhile.
When I felt convicted to tithe years ago, I knew the only way I could ensure it would happen was to have separate checking accounts. Otherwise, my wife could spend the money before I was able to tithe. Or hide the money somewhere. So I didn't ask her permission. I did it. And you know what? I had money to tithe. And I obeyed and pleased God. That is worth more to me than letting her control everything. Do I pay a price? Yes. Will I be rewarded in heaven? I expect so. Would I do it again? Absolutely.
For me, it boiled down to one thing: am I willing to obey God? Adam chose his wife's opinion over God's instruction, and look at the price paid for that. My wife wouldn't compromise or agree to tithing, so I took the only action I knew would ensure I would obey God. Some things are not worth compromising over.
So, if she gets mad at you, perhaps she will withhold sex from you as a punishment. God will deal with that in His own time.
Again, I'm no expert at relationships, but I do know that my wife will try to control everything I do unless I take a stand and say enough. I don't remember how long you've been married (sorry), but if that is an issue between you, the sooner you refuse to allow her to control you, the better.
I'm no expert, but I've been to hell and back many times in this relationship. Hope you fare better.
Wayne