ebia
Senior Contributor
- Jul 6, 2004
- 41,711
- 2,142
- Faith
- Anglican
- Marital Status
- Married
- Politics
- AU-Greens
You approach seems to be: construct three very broad categories. Ram every story into one of the three. Construct a simplistic explanation for each of the three. And, hey presto, pretend that this somehow proves God isn't real. You've clearly drawn your conclusions before you start, and made the "data" fit. I could easily do the reverse:Basically in asking this question, I've come to an understanding about the validity of this concept of god. If you come to "the truth" by someone else ramming it down your throat at an early age,or if you're just looking for a way to help you with your addiction, or if you're just feeling lonely and/or lost in this world.....that doesn't mean what you've found is "the truth". It just means you're either comforted by the information you've been fed and now depend on it like any other drug out there. You cannot do without christ the same way others cannot do without alcohol, sex, or a needle.
But it doesn't mean that christ is any more real just because that's what you've been conditioned to think and see from an early age, or because it's helped you get through a tough period in your life. You're just trading one addiction for another.
And I'll admit that christianity CAN BE a lot less harmful than an addiction to drugs, sex, or alcohol, but it's still an addiction. People lead fully healthy lives without christ, so it's entirely possible to do it. But the worst a single drunk man can do to harm others is drive drunk and kill others in a car accident. The worst one religious person can do who abuses their religion can be far worse, especially in today's world where you can run into a school and take out 33 people or take over an airplane and drive it into a building.
If the fact that one is brought up in an environment that acknowledges God is evidence that one only believes because one has been indoctrinated, then the converse is true of an atheist who has grown up in an athesist environment.
The militant Christian who gives up the church to become an atheist is giving up the truth in order to escape something he can't cope with about it (which may be problem with the people involved, or it may be that he can't hack it).
Or then there is the athesist who drifts out through peer pressure. "Nobody but idiots believes that rot". Enough time aqcuiesssing to that and you start to believe it.
Upvote
0