How did these life evolved out?

[Skreeper]

I gave you an evidence. What's wrong with that one?

You mean this?

You can SEE the rock is fine in water, but is not good in lava.

That's a sentence on a internet forum not evidence for the proposition that non sentient beings or objects have desires. Got anything remotely scientific?

 

[bhsmte]

yes and yes.

Do stones, fall in love?

 

[AirPo]

Do stones, fall in love?

No, but we fall in love with The Stones!

 

[Skreeper]

No, but we fall in love with The Stones!

 

[juvenissun]

You mean this?

That's a sentence on a internet forum not evidence for the proposition that non sentient beings or objects have desires. Got anything remotely scientific?

A child see a chalkboard full of formulas and ask: is that math?

I don't have much time. If you do not want to learn, then bye bye.

 

[juvenissun]

Do stones, fall in love?

Yes. some stones attract each other, and some repel each other.

 

[juvenissun]

If no more serious conversation, then I will ask to close this thread.

 

[sfs]

If no more serious conversation, then I will ask to close this thread.

You had a real opportunity to learn something here, but you turned out to be one of those bad students you keep talking about.

 

[Skreeper]

A child see a chalkboard full of formulas and ask: is that math?

I don't have much time. If you do not want to learn, then bye bye.

An actual expert gave you some pretty good explanations that you just rejected without sufficient justification. Who's the one not willing to learn?

 

[Larniavc]

If no more serious conversation, then I will ask to close this thread.

I should make that request, if I were you.

You admitted that you think you can read the mind of rocks!

How embarrassing.

 

[bhsmte]

If no more serious conversation, then I will ask to close this thread.

Projection.

 

[dad]

Not if you are Tom Brady!

No?

 

[pitabread]

A stone does not WANT to be in a lava lake.

 

[bhsmte]

Priceless!

 

[juvenissun]

You had a real opportunity to learn something here, but you turned out to be one of those bad students you keep talking about.

I think the only possibility for me to learn something about this issue here is from you. But this time, you failed. I know that very clearly. If you are to get serious, I am listening.

 

[bhsmte]

I think the only possibility for me to learn something about this issue here is from you. But this time, you failed. I know that very clearly. If you are to get serious, I am listening.

That ship has sailed.

 

[bhsmte]

I think the only possibility for me to learn something about this issue here is from you. But this time, you failed. I know that very clearly. If you are to get serious, I am listening.

You keep forgetting: no bad teachers, just bad students.

 

[Allandavid]

This is off the topic. But, I don't expect any good (or even challenging) answer anyway.

A rock does have a desire. It desires to get rid of uncooperative members in the rock.
If you do not understand, you may keep asking.

Well, this is getting weird....

 

[TagliatelliMonster]

Evolutionists:

Why would these animals want to evolve into this place where there is no sunlight, hot (300°C+) and crushing (~2000 atm) ?

Organisms don't "steer" their evolution.
So your question of why these animals "want" to evolve in such and such, is a nonsensical loaded question, which just exposed an extreme ignorance on how the process of biological evolution actually works.

 

[TagliatelliMonster]

No serious taker. I figured.

OK. Then I change the question a little bit to fit your shallow requirement:
Where do those animals come from?

Or, if you enjoy this more reasonable one better:
What makes life appear and thrive in that special niche, which 99.99% of life on the earth do not like?

Frankly, we do not know, and for sure, you do not have to know. But this feature could make you think harder about the validity of life evolution. And this issue is going to be hot. NASA people ARE looking at this issue on Europa and Enceladus. Stay tuned.

2 fish are swimming by the coast.
They see humans sunbath on the beach.

One says to the other "how nuts!!! don't they realise that they will die there????"