I did read what you wrote and I would like to know why you say that intellectual experiences can not have life changing power. The way I understand this statement is that you think that understanding something intellectually can not change your life like a spiritual or physical encounter with God can. I don't think this is true, and I say this because it is only the intellect that can change your life. It is the beliefs that ultimately convert circumstances and desires into decisions. If your beliefs change, then your decisions will be impacted. Beliefs change when existing beliefs are challenged by information that causes you to accept that the previous belief is wrong. You are saying that a physical experience will give you that information. I do not disagree, I just say it is not the only way, and the necessity of it happening is His decision. Should you insist on something He doesn't agree is right, you will only get frustrated. I cannot see any other result than that. Obedience is to accept His will when it contradicts our own.
When I said that intellectual evidences in favor of the christian God has no life-changing power, I should admit that I was mainly talking based on my personal experience. I will try to explain this as clearly as possible. It's true that changing your ideas, your thoughts, your beliefs will have an impact in your decisions and that can be interpreted as a change in your life. That's true. But by life-changing power I was really meaning a profound change in your heart, and as I understand, a profound change of heart is beyond the scope of mere changes at rational level, and I will show you why. First, I will talk about my personal experience regarding this matter and then I will give you scriptural support.
1) Personal Experience:
As I said in the last lines of my first post, I used to be a skeptical agnostic. I am a very logic, rational person and I understand how to think and reason in a skeptic way, like any atheist, agnostic, skeptic in general. I appreciate the methodic skeptic way of reasoning of Science which has allowed it to come up with impressive theories to describe the physical reality with amazing practical applications (I even mentioned the computer you are using to read this post as a good example in my first post). As you can guess, I developed a very deep rational mindset when I was a skeptical agnostic, and I have not lost any rational abilities at all in spite of having made the decision of seeking the christian God and starting to develop a believer mindset.
That being said, I has been specially and obsessively concerned with the desire of knowing the Truth, but not in a sense of philosophical curiosity, but as an existential issue that will define everything I will do in my life (a lot of people just see existential issues as mere philosophical curiosities to have interesting conversations while driking coffe, nothing that will affect the status quo of their lives). My obsession with this existential issue is the result of early stimulation in my life to consider and concern about the existential meaning of life together with personal problems that have made my life unhappy (I guess if I had been totally happy with my terrenal life, I would not have even worried about existential issues, I would probably be too entertained living in the Matrix). In seeking the Truth, I am looking for the true meaning of my life in order to be clear about what I have to do and also I hope that somehow knowing and living according this Truth will bring peace, joy, existential fullness to my life.
Finally I get to the point. I have been exposed to a lot of evidences (although not logical certainties at all) that gives somewhat rational support to the christian God, not scientifically of course, but a least it makes the logical possibility that Christianity is truth more plausible. I gave some reasons in the first post, but for me the reason that triggered my decision of seeking God by myself was the testimonies of people, and it's easy to see why: testimonies of people (whether inside or outside the Bible) give me hope that I could eventually know God by myself as well (If they could, I can). Ok, here is the point: rational evidence gave me motivation to seek God, gave me hope that I would eventually find Him and my life would be changed. That's the idea. However, my life has not deeply changed. It's true that there were decisions I rationally made out of the movitation provided by these rational evidences in favor of Christianity (indeed I refered to it as my own version of the Pascal's Wager, I recommend you to google "Pascal's Wager" to have a better insight of it), but my life has not deeply changed. Something is missing, and I think that it must be a personal spiritual encounter with God. Now I will give scriptural support to this in point 2.
2) Scriptural Support:
When talking about a deep change of heart, the Biblie is clear describing it as a supernatural spiritual process performed by God (so it is not a mere psychological intellectual process, although it obviously has impacts on that area).
Ezekiel 36: 25-27
25 I will sprinkle clean water on you, and you will be clean; I will cleanse you from all your impurities and from all your idols. 26 I will give you a new heart and put a new spirit in you; I will remove from you your heart of stone and give you a heart of flesh. 27 And I will put my Spirit in you and move you to follow my decrees and be careful to keep my laws.
This passage clearly states a deep transformation of a person's heart performed by God. Furthemore, you can see the promise of the Holy Spirit also stated here. The result is that a person regenerated like this will have a new heart and will be guided by the Holy Spirit to follow God's decrees and laws. Needless to say that this is a supernatural process beyond a mere "change of intellectual ideas".
Here is another passage about the life-changing promise of the Holy Spirit:
Joel 2:28-29
28 “And afterward, I will pour out my Spirit on all people. Your sons and daughters will prophesy, your old men will dream dreams, your young men will see visions. 29 Even on my servants, both men and women, I will pour out my Spirit in those days.
Not only it is stated the promise of the Holy Spirit, but also you can read about some clear manifestations, such as prophecy, dreams, visions. We can see this supernatural and spiritual operation of the Holy Spirit in the book of Acts (I already gave examples in post #38):
You can see a clear tranformation fruit of the baptism of the Holy Spirit in Peter's life. Peter, who some time before had denied Jesus three times, now he was filled with the Holy Spirit so that he preached with such power that more than 3000 people converted to Christ in that very moment. In his speech he even quoted the passage of Joel 2 I gave you before (a bit more in fact):
Acts 2: 14-17
14 Then Peter stood up with the Eleven, raised his voice and addressed the crowd: “Fellow Jews and all of you who live in Jerusalem, let me explain this to you; listen carefully to what I say. 15 These people are not drunk, as you suppose. It’s only nine in the morning! 16 No, this is what was spoken by the prophet Joel:
17 “‘In the last days, God says,
I will pour out my Spirit on all people.
Your sons and daughters will prophesy,
your young men will see visions,
your old men will dream dreams.
Acts 2:40
40 With many other words he warned them; and he pleaded with them, “Save yourselves from this corrupt generation.” 41 Those who accepted his message were baptized, and about three thousand were added to their number that day.
As you can see, there is a profound life-changing power in the Holy Spirit and the Bible talks about this promise, describes it and gives examples (reread my post #38 to see more quotations).
I know that your decisions can change based on new ideas, new thoughts, new beliefs, but in my personal case rationality has not had the power to change my life and the Biblie says that a deep change of heart is the result of something supernatural and spiritual, namely the work of the Holy Spirit.
No I am not saying that at all. I have had physical experiences which I believe were the action of God. I am saying that you seem to be hung up on it instead of just trusting Him and getting on with life. You have a lot to potentially give to the kingdom, I suggest concentrating on that. You say you want to know the truth, I say you have a pretty good grasp on it, certainy enough to share with others. What I was actually saying is that your idea of a spiritual experience may be different from what it really is. Remember 1 John 4:2-3, that is the verse that when I recommitted to Jesus, showed me what had been going on in my spiritual life. This does seem to show that spirits speak to the mind. I don't know why so many people think that an emotional experience is evidence of The Holy Spirit, do you?
To respond to this paragraph, I think that it would be a good idea to make clear this confusion about physical emotional experiences. Everything started when you made the assumption that I am looking for an emotional experience, a mere result of chemical activity in the brain. In other words, as though I were looking for a physical experience (since Chemistry is based on Physics). This sounds like a prejudice, as if you had some inclination to deny real spiritual experiences and assume that everything is nothing more than pure emotions, brain trickeries. If that is the case, I think you are wrong and I think that you are ignoring all the scriptural support in favor of real spiritual experiences with clear manifestations.
With regards to contributing to the Kingdom, I sincerly don't feel prepared to carry out the great comission. I have a lot of intellectual knowledge about Scriptures, I have read all the Bible, I have seen and listened many preachings, read books, in short, I know. However, I have not truly experienced this intellectual knowledge in my life. My current desire is to have a personal encounter with God that changes my life, that allows me to know the reality of God, not just knowledge or theory.
If I went to contribute to the Kingdom, I would have first to be a witness of Jesus, but in order to be a witness of Jesus I need the power of the Holy Spirit, as Jesus himself said:
Acts 1:8
8 But you will receive power when the Holy Spirit comes on you; and you will be my witnesses in Jerusalem, and in all Judea and Samaria, and to the ends of the earth.”
What do you expect the reward to be? Is a reward always a wish granted?
Since the reward is intended for somebody who is seeking God with all their heart, then the reward should be to find Him, which is indeed assured by the same Bible:
Jeremiah 29:13
13 You will seek me and find me, when you seek me with all your heart.
A reward is not necessarily a wish granted as long as your wish is not subject to God's will.
James 4:3
3 When you ask, you do not receive, because you ask with wrong motives, that you may spend what you get on your pleasures
However, according to the whole Bible it is actually God's desire to reestablish the communion between man and Him. There are just a lot of scriptural evidences and testimonies that support this.
What do you think is actually making God so hard to find?
I guess that my lack of faith, my lack of perseverance and the fact that I am struggling with sinful habits that have made me hard to remain in holiness. I understand that I must be faithful and remain in holiness in order for God to pour out his Holy Spirit in me. Otherwise everybody would be filled with the Holy Spirit and we would be living in a utopia right now (that's not the case).