Bingo. And it has everything to do with faith in an interpretation.Belief in a young Earth has nothing to do with faith, at least not faith in God anyway.
Upvote
0
Starting today August 7th, 2024, in order to post in the Married Couples, Courting Couples, or Singles forums, you will not be allowed to post if you have your Marital status designated as private. Announcements will be made in the respective forums as well but please note that if yours is currently listed as Private, you will need to submit a ticket in the Support Area to have yours changed.
Bingo. And it has everything to do with faith in an interpretation.Belief in a young Earth has nothing to do with faith, at least not faith in God anyway.
I agree. For me, the question isn't whether day was meant literally, but whether it was meant historically.While the thread already seems to be past this, I should point out that I agree with Mark Kennedy as "day" literally meaning "day" and not unspecificed period of time or era or age or something like that. In its context of numbers and attachment to morning and evening, it is most definately a literal day.
So if you were to think of Genesis 1 as a literal, historic event, then an acurate interpretation would require no more than 1 week's time for the events to take place.
While the thread already seems to be past this, I should point out that I agree with Mark Kennedy as "day" literally meaning "day" and not unspecificed period of time or era or age or something like that. In its context of numbers and attachment to morning and evening, it is most definately a literal day.
So if you were to think of Genesis 1 as a literal, historic event, then an acurate interpretation would require no more than 1 week's time for the events to take place.
Literal meaning of morning: more light shows up. So, the evening would be the light is partially or totally covered or receded. Repeated morning and evening literally means: cycles.
So, there could be A LOT of other factors involved in the whole system, such as the source of light, the time duration of a cycle, the degree and the mechanism of lightening and darkening, etc. . Our normal understanding of day/night is only a special case, not a general case.
Yom said:852 יוֹם (yôm) day, time, year.
Derivative
852a יוֹמָם (yômām) by day.
The ASV and RSV translate yom similarly with the latter frequently representing the sense more accurately (exception: Gen 2:17; 3:5 attest the same Hebrew construction, yet the RSV confuses the reader by rendering them differently).
Our word is the most important concept of time in the ot by which a point of time as well as a sphere of time can be expressed. The word is also common in Ugaritic. It can denote: 1. the period of light (as contrasted with the period of darkness), 2. the period of twenty-four hours, 3. a general vague time, 4. a point of time, 5. a year (in the plural; I Sam 27:7; Ex 13:10, etc.). Especially note the following special meanings: bĕyôm (frequently when; bĕ can be replaced by min or ʿad), hayyôm (frequently today, or some particular day), bîmê in the time of, yĕmê as long as (Deut 11:21; Gen 8:22). Akkadian ūmu day, is often combined with ina in, in the form inūma, enūma to mean when (e.g. enūma eli), exactly as Hebrew bĕyôm. There is no real synonym to our word although compare ʿēt (time) and ʿôlām (eternity) in some contexts (Ezk 21:25 [H 30]: Num 13:20, etc.). Other Hebrew words sometimes translated day are: ʾôr light, bōqer (the usual Hebrew word for morning the period of light before noon; Jud 19:26), aḥar (the Northwest Semitic word for morning-goddess, see aḥar, hālal, UT 19: no. 2399; Gen 32:25). Finally, yôm used adverbially (kōl-hayyôm, Job 1:5; Gen 6:5) parallels tāmîd (continually) in meaning g)num 4:7). Antonyms of our word are: layĕlâ (Gen 8:22), and ʿereb (Gen 1:5; cf. Dan 8:14). Our word, a common Semitic root (UT 19: no. 1100), and the concept of time surrounding it do not present a unique Hebrew understanding of time (Jenni, THAT I, yôm, tag). The root occurs 2355 times.
It is important to note that the daytime was not divided into regular hourly divisions, but according to natural phenomena (Ex 18;13; Gen 43:16; 15:12; 18:1, etc.). The night, however, was divided into three watches (perhaps Lam 2:18; Jud 7:19; Ex 14:24). Furthermore, there is apparently a certain duality in the determination of the beginning and ending of the day with the former being sometimes evening (Est 4:16; Dan 8:14), and sometimes morning (Deut 28:6667: AI, I, pp. 180ff.).
Day is surrounded by many theological themes related to Gods sovereignty. God, being eternal, antedates (Isa 43:13; Dan 7:9) and transcends time (Ps 90:4). Time (days) was created by God (Gen 1) and is under his control (Ps 74:16). Especially, note Joshuas miraculous day (SOTI, p. 259 ff.). Man is called to recognize this sovereignty by conforming life to the time divisions established by God (Ex 20:11; 31:17, etc.). God assured the regularity of time (Gen 8:22), but this does not mean that regularity is a law to which God is subject. Indeed, it will someday be divinely suspended (Zech 14:7). Like cosmological and terrestrial time mans lifespan is ordered (Ps 90:10), determined (Ps 139:16), and controlled (Deut 30:20; Ps 55:23 [H 24]); 91:16; Isa 38:5) by God. The Bible gives repeated indications of Gods interest in and concern for time and its events (Gen 26:33; 24:55). Moreover, a unique (to the ancient world) and ever-present philosophy of history is exhibited therein.
[The myth makers of the Ancient Near East did not conceive of time in terms of a horizontal, linear ordering of events reaching from a historical beginning to a final consummation of all things. Rather, they regarded time as cyclical, the annual reordering and revitalizing of the universe. Their creation myths were recited at annual New Years festivals as magical words to accompany a magical ritual in order to reac-tualize the original cosmology, the passage from chaos to cosmos. In mythopoeic thought time has no significance and history no meaning.
But Genesis 1 betrays a totally different notion about time. Here time is conceived as linear and events occur successively within it. Moreover, from the biblical viewpoint mans behavior in the present determines his state in the future. Time is the defined arena in which it will be demonstrated that righteousness is rewarded with life and evil is punished with death. Such a viewpoint invests mans time with the greatest moral value and history serves as an instrument whereby Gods character can be displayed B.K.W.]
Special notice should also be given to the theological significance of several constructions and phrases. yôm ʾăer the day when is used preponderantly to introduce events with particular importance in the history of salvation (Deut 4:32; Num 15:23, etc.; see also the use with ā. The period forty days and forty nights frequently signifies a time of reformation (Gen 7:4; Ex 16:35; 24:18) and/or trial (Jon 3:4). The word hayyôm sometimes signifies a redemptive time (if not moment) when repentance is divinely summoned (Ps 95:7), salvation divinely bestowed (Ps 118:24), or adoption divinely effected (Ps 2:7). For the meaning of the phrase days of old, see qādam. One of the most debated occurrences of yôm is its use in reference to creation. The difficulties in exegesis there are complicated by many factors (see E. J. Young, Studies in Genesis One, Presbyterian and Reformed, 1964, pp. 43ff.). Like Young, this writer believes the days of Gen 1 to be intentionally patterned, chronological, of indeterminable length, initiated with 1:1, intended to show step-by-step how God changed the uninhabitable and unformed earth of verse two into the well-ordered world of verse thirty-two, and straight-forward. trustworthy history (ibid., p. 103ff.). Another much debated phrase is the day of the Lord. It can be used eschatalogically or noneschatalogically. It is a day of judgment and/or blessing (Isa 2). Hence, the eschatalogical meaning embraced by this idea entails all of prophetic eschatology (George A. Gay, Day, Baker Dictionary of Theology, p. 156; Jenni, op.cit., loc. cit.; K. D. Schunck, Der Tag Jahwehs, VT 14:31930). Similar expressions are bayyôm hahûʾ in that day which can refer to ordinary expected events (Isa 21:6) or can be eschatological and ʾaḥărît hayyāmîm which can refer to events in the general future (Deut 31:29) or to the eschaton (Harris, R. L., The Last Days in the Bible and Qumran, in Jesus of Nazareth Savior and Lord, C. F. H. Henry, ed., Eerdmans (1966)).
יוֹמָם (yômām). By day. This adverb modifies the verbal activity by specifying that it occurred while it was yet light. Its antonyms are layĕlâ (Ex 13:21) and bāʿereb (Ezk 12:34). Our word occurs fifty-one times.
Bibliography: TDNT, II, pp. 94348. THAT, I, pp. 70726.
Harris, R. L., Harris, R. L., Archer, G. L., & Waltke, B. K. (1999). Theological Wordbook of the Old Testament (electronic ed.) (370371). Chicago: Moody Press.
Actually I just checked some sources and you have a valid point. While I still think that the specific choice of morning and evening to denote the light and darkness implies an actual "day", your interpretation can also be justified.
Here is the entire section on yom in TWOT. Note specifically the area I put in bold (I am posting the entire entry so people can see the whole scope of the word presented in this book. Although its not the most comprehensive Hebrew dictionary, it is a standard resource for quick referencing and generally contains the same basic information as the more exhaustive ones, without the plethora of references and individual special cases).
What I don't understand is how (or why) would the Hebrew use the same word to represent both day and year? Would it be much better to use two words?
I agree. For me, the question isn't whether day was meant literally, but whether it was meant historically.
All languages are full of strange quirks -- and all outsiders point to each case and say, "that's a strange quirk!" But it seems perfectly natural to native-speakers. In English, we have many such cases. It allows poets and clever people to play with the language.
But each language has its own, different set of quirks.
Cool! Well, if you choose to view Genesis 1 as meaning literal 24-hour days ...
What I don't understand is how (or why) would the Hebrew use the same word to represent both day and year? Would it be much better to use two words?
What he means to say is that within the context of the story the days are 24-hour periods of time, but that the story itself needs to be set in its own wider context.
I think the text itself gives enough hints that the days are not what they seem.
Evidence 1: Morning and evening before the creation of the sun and moon; surely the Hebrews even if they were geocentric flat-earthers (and they may not have been) would at least have the dimmest awareness that morning and evening are related to the relative motion of the sun in the sky.
Evidence 2: Why does the seventh day have neither morning nor evening? (Answer: because it has lasted at least seven thousand years.)
You can perceive it that way, but then you have Genesis 2, and if you disregard Genesis 1 as a metaphor or parable or poem, then Genesis 2 would read Adam -> Plants -> Animals. Adam was the Son of God and the first Adam, and Jesus Christ was the Son of God and the last Adam. Adam was the first ancestor of Christ, and Adam is the figure in Genesis 2. Adam lived to be 930 years old.
Revelation 21
23And the city had no need of the sun, neither of the moon, to shine in it: for the glory of God did lighten it, and the Lamb is the light thereof.
The sun is not the only source of light.
The six days / sabbath pattern is the pattern of the God's week cycle. On the sabbath day no work is to be done. God rested the seventh day. However, soon enough he would do work by making clothes for Adam and Eve, and placing cherubim to guard the garden of Eden. The women in the gospels could not even prepare spices on the Sabbath because it would not be resting. God would proceed to make clothes and place cherubim -- two 'errands' -- not to mention all of his following works.
The seventh day is beyond over. It says God rested.
Genesis 2:3
And God blessed the seventh day, and sanctified it: because that in it he had rested from all his work which God created and made.
Exodus 20:11
For in six days the LORD made heaven and earth, the sea, and all that in them is, and rested the seventh day: wherefore the LORD blessed the sabbath day, and hallowed it.
Hebrew does have a word for year, Shanah (long a's) (or it could be Sanah. I forget whether it starts with sin or shin.)
in the 2284 occurances of Yom, it is only translate into year 32 times (in NASB), and its meaning is a combination of "period of time" and year. Think of it in reference to years as cycles instead of individual years.
For example:
Exodus 13:10: "Therefore you shall keep this ordinance at its apointed time from year (yom) to year (yom)."
As another example (and my personal favorite), the Twelve Days of Christmas are 24-hour days; they do not represent, for example, the twelve separate dynasties of England or anything like that. But just because they mean 24-hour periods of time does not mean that I actually believe that any suitor actually gave such an extravagant and ludicrous series of gifts to his lover over a fortnight leading up to Christmas.
Thanks, shern. That's precisely what I mean.What he means to say is that within the context of the story the days are 24-hour periods of time, but that the story itself needs to be set in its own wider context.
I think the framework interpretation takes care of some of those issues, although Day 7 is still a tricky point for me.As it is, I think the text itself gives enough hints that the days are not what they seem.
Evidence 1: Morning and evening before the creation of the sun and moon; surely the Hebrews even if they were geocentric flat-earthers (and they may not have been) would at least have the dimmest awareness that morning and evening are related to the relative motion of the sun in the sky.
Evidence 2: Why does the seventh day have neither morning nor evening? (Answer: because it has lasted at least seven thousand years.)
Long post