How does God both allow freedom yet maintain control?
Have you seen evidence of this in your life?
Have you seen evidence of this in your life?
Starting today August 7th, 2024, in order to post in the Married Couples, Courting Couples, or Singles forums, you will not be allowed to post if you have your Marital status designated as private. Announcements will be made in the respective forums as well but please note that if yours is currently listed as Private, you will need to submit a ticket in the Support Area to have yours changed.
Realistically, what is God in control of?...crime?.....war?.....hatred/resentment?,...
corruption?...cheating, etc.?
If He 'took control', He would have to refuse/deny us "freewill" control of this world.
Who told you that God is "in control" and that you should feel that everything is fine and dandy?.....MAN told you that, not God.
Most people are completely satisfied with things as they are. The pastors, scholars, etc. tell them to simply comply with a book and pretend that "God is in control". That way, the moneychangers can simply continue to get money from us.....THAT is why they want us to believe that "God is in control".
That saying/attitude was simply 'made up' by the modern day moneychangers for self serving purposes.
No matter how sad it is and spiritually criminal (betraying Christ), it is also humorous that a spiritual person ever sees fit to gain any spiritual knowledge from or consult THE DICTIONARY.........(need I say more?).
There are many, many things that we've been taught to SAY that are IN CONFLICT (contradictory) to each other.
Two of them are that (they are TWO different things, NOT 'ONE')...
1) GOD "controls" our life.
2) we have free will.
...it cannot be both ways, it has to be either/or.
.....WHAT does He TAKE CONTROL of?
He ALLOWS storms, earthquakes, tornadoes, crime, drugs, wars, hatred, car accidents, torture, poverty, widespread disease, etc. Of course, one popular excuse for some things is that they are a judgement against society, but is that the reason for war, crime, drugs, torture, corruption, hatred, etc.?....of course not.
You SUGGESTED that there was a "personal attack". You avoided directly STATING that I am guilty of a personal attack (by SUGGESTING it).
Check online to see how the NEW King James Version (NKJV) is DEMONIC because it has been changed so much and IS VERY SPIRITUALLY HARMFUL.
No matter how sad it is and spiritually criminal (betraying Christ), it is also humorous that a spiritual person ever sees fit to gain any spiritual knowledge from or consult THE DICTIONARY.
In pursuing spiritual wisdom, people will use the dictionary and encyclopedias. I'm not even going to try and make sense out of that.
wisdom and knowledge are to be sought after also:I came to Christ 23 years ago and I've seen it all my life. In pursuing spiritual wisdom, people will use the dictionary and encyclopedias.
I'm not even going to try and make sense out of that. The Lord is the only one who can explain to you that it doesn't make sense.
There is a difference between SPIRITUAL and SECULAR. Our worship is supposed in SPIRIT (spiritual) and TRUTH (our source of TRUTH is Jesus, John 14:6), not DICTIONARIES/books.
We pursue a SPIRITUAL truth (wisdom) for a SPIRITUAL kingdom and SPIRITUAL understanding so we can be SPIRITUALLY inside Jesus's body as a SPIRIT (new) creation.
Acts 17:28
"In Him, we live and move and have our being".
This is what we should seek....
Song of Songs 3:2.....................(Song of Solomon)
"I will seek him whom my soul loves"
.
Since God is all-powerful and all-knowing which I hope you believe he is, then how could he not be in control? And if we didn't have free will, how could we choose to follow him? We couldn't, we would just follow him because we had to which on Gods part would make us love him. However, there is no love if there is no choice. So I believe he has the power/control over everything. He has a plan and it is irresistible. If it were not irresistible then we could simply change his plan. And like in one of the other boards about Gods Voice you mentioned that you need to pray for Gods Will not your Own Will. I am paraphrasing, mind me. But that is suggesting that God has a will and a purpose for each one of us. Is it because he changes us? Or is it because he is all-know and he is outside of time? Either way he can make it to where everything that we do is working in with his plan. Like my dad said, its like playing chess with God. But he knows ever possible move on the board, he knows every move that you will make, and with that knowledge he could set up the board to just win like cutting melted butter. lol The melted butter part was what I said.iloveringyou, So far, I've received only RATIONALIZATIONS in order to justify what is false. What exactly is God in control of? Explain some of the day to day events that God prevents happening/occuring. The statement that He is "in control" is a very hasty and SHORT (not FULLY explanatory) statement. The QUESTION (instead of a blank STATEMENT) should be... .....WHAT does He TAKE CONTROL of? He ALLOWS storms, earthquakes, tornadoes, crime, drugs, wars, hatred, car accidents, torture, poverty, widespread disease, etc. Of course, one popular excuse for some things is that they are a judgement against society, but is that the reason for war, crime, drugs, torture, corruption, hatred, etc.?....of course not.
Actually I do believe the bible is full of examples. First of all you have him saying, "Let there be light." And well there was light. So right there he has control over light and everything else he he made during creation. He had the control over Adam and Eve to kick them out, to curse them for eating from the tree, and to provide them with clothes, lamb, and I am not sure what else. Then there is Noah, he told him to build an arch so that humans could live on after he sent the flood. See he was in control of the corruption, he just destroyed all those people because of how bad they were sinning and such. I don't know that story all too well but you get what I mean, I hope. D: The Tower of Babel, he scattered the people and confused them with different languages. So he has control over the tongues of man. There are signs of Gods control throughout the life of Moses also. There is so much more, in which I also need to get more into the OT. And there is plenty of signs of his control in the NT also. Just look in Revelation, God is still as powerful as can be. From Genesis, the start of Creation to Revelation, to the demise of Creation, God is never changing and will always be in control. I judt don't see anyway around it. The understanding of the contradiction may seem confusing but that is only because we have a human understanding, not Gods understanding. And Gods understanding/knowledge makes ours look liek a grain of sand, if that.Explain what He HAS "taken control" of (actually SPECIFY some EVENTS that He has "taken control" of).
I was not trying to say our bad behavior is to be blamed on anyone else. Because we as humans are in a war against- Satan, Ourselves, and the World. But as Christians I believe that Satan is not longer in the picture, in a sense we are not longer slaves to sin, but slaves to righteousness as Romans 6 says. Like many other verses. If we sin after becoming a Christian then it is our fault, either because we are just not obeying God like we should or simply we can not over come the temptations of this world. But as a Christian/believer in God, you must strive to be all that you can be, not for yourself- but for God. While no amount of works could even compare to the gift of God we still must take responsibility for our sins, repent, and continue trying our best to please God.For the most part, He does not intervene or interfere with the operation of 'human nature' and our free will. It is HUMANITY and the war mongers who cause war, not God,....(not even satan is responsible for wars, hatred, etc., everybody has the free will to cause evil or NOT CAUSE evil). Humanity has always used satan as a scapegoat instead of accepting responsibility for our own actions (satan does not cause evil things to happen, WE do). Likewise, it is a 'cop out' to say that we are not responsible for ungodly behavior. God is not in control of our behavior, WE are. When we resent/hate someone, it is because WE want to redeem our conscience and our ego (because of the underhanded things WE do),....but instead of accepting responsibilty for what we do (because the truth is that WE are in control with our freewill), we avoid having to admit responsibility by saying that we are not "in control"/responsible.
In my honest opinion, I don't think the issues is what exactly he /takes/ control of, I think it is the fact he CAN take control of whatever he wants. Because he is God.So, what exactly does He TAKE control of?
The tone in which you said it seemed like an attack or diminishing. Your being just as suggestively accusative with the whole betraying Christ thing. I just thought it was a little uncalled for.You SUGGESTED that there was a "personal attack". You avoided directly STATING that I am guilty of a personal attack (by SUGGESTING it). That is a false accusation. Satan didn't put a gun to your head and force you to make that accusation, you decided of your own free will to 'suggestively accuse' me of that. God did not "take control" in order to prevent that (neither was it satan who made that accusation).
Thats hasty generalization. D:Christians will never accept responsibility for their own actions as long as they can say that either God or satan are responsible.
There is so many languages in the world. So many different people that need to hear the word of God. We have to translate it for people. And of course since we are not all-knowing, nothing but amateur thinkers(at least compared to God) there is going to be some mis-translations. And yes some versions are more bias then others. And if you are the type of person that needs to get technical and down to every last detail which I think is great(for the fact you probably strive to learn more about Gods word) then I suggest that you try and learn Hebrew, Greek, or both so you can read a version more accurate to the original text. But all-in-all the word of God is powerful and good. The mistranslations are bad and misleading. However, I think if people get the general idea instead of none at all then it is good. People need to hear Gods word so they can better choose whether they will be followers of God or followers of their own selfish desires making them children of Satan. Look at the dictionary as the internet. The internet a a great tool for learning. The dictionary is too. But they both become bad as they are abused or used for the wrong reasons. Jwesker was using the dictionary to better understand the bible. I use the internet to better understand the bible. Both are compilations of knowledge that help you learn more so that reading the bible wont seem like your reading a book on physics as a kindergartner. All the same I also do not believe that it should be a set in stone study device. If that makes sense.Scripture was originally written in ancient languages (Hebrew, Aramaic, Greek) and translated into modern languages (our native language). Some of the PRECISE/exact meaning is almost always lost in translation. On top of that, many bible translators have always taken great liberties in adding their own bias to the final translation. Add to that, many modern bible versions have been re-worded in certain ways to make them politically correct.... ........and remember, the proper language used by dictionaries was not in use in Jesus's time or during King James time or during most bible translator's times. So, a dictionary can only be helpful with a word that we have never really used in everyday language, but cannot offer ANY spiritual meaning/definition, only rough approximate definitions related to modern word usage.
Yes people should be careful. But I think the base idea of Gods Word is still in every version. God made us, we sinned, he came to earth, he died to save us, so in him we can live again with him in heaven if we receive his gift. Soooo long sorry. D:The KJV was made for the Church of England. There are discrepancies (some are borderline harmful, some not harmful at all, and others that actually do make a difference). Many modern versions (especially the NIV) have very meaningful discrepancies and deletions. In the KJV, Acts 12:4 has the Jews celebrating "EASTER" instead of PASSOVER... "intending after Easter to bring him forth to the people"........(because it was made for the CHURCH OF ENGLAND). So, beware of different bible versions, and take special care when using any text or reference outside scripture. The bible version I use (Revised Standard Version, RSV) is 30 years old (the book itself is 30 years old,....before too much political correctness). Check at this link to find many bible versions and see how the words change.... (iloveringyou took out the link I need 50 posts first) Check online to see how the NEW King James Version (NKJV) is DEMONIC because it has been changed so much and IS VERY SPIRITUALLY HARMFUL (it even has a LOGO on the front cover that has 3 points and 6 lines,...666, an old demonic symbol). Mankind has always taken the three aspects of God (creation, salvation, spirit) and taught them as though man (the 6th day creation) should be glorified instead of God. Satan will not OVERCOME ("prevail AGAINST") the true church, but, because of today's greatly fallen society, satan has infiltrated the institutions of Christianity. Beware of the many false beliefs and attitudes of mistrust/fear.
Goodbye J Wesker, I'm leaving this thread.
Loverlingyou your response above is filled with wisdom beyond your years, God has been working in you I see. Thanks for all you have expressed to moreexcellentway. Also to JWesker you have handled this with humility and love and I thank you for that, may we endeavor to answer all with love above all.
To MoreExcellentWay I offer you my brother, the peace that passes all understanding through the love of the Messiah, may you continue to pursue the truth and may God give you understanding, your messeges are most zealous and passionate as our brother JWesker has mentioned.
Jeffrey