Do you know how many people disagree with you? On many points? Are you going to say... you are all heretics, and not consider them Christians?
Even Paul and Peter disagreed. It is natural in Christianity, when there are very deep and complicated ideas, and the light that people have received is not all the same. (I am not saying that there is different Truths, rather that some people are have different components of the Truth)
And I am not saying that you should be completely silent either. I am not here, over the heresies the SDA church has been teaching about jewelry, alcohol, and some other things. But I am also not saying that the good Christian people who think that wearing jewelry is sin should be removed from the church (that the church should be purified ). Now there are some things that I think are different enough that you should worship with someone else, like if you beleive that Sunday is the correct day to worship on (and I would try to convince you of the Truth of the Sabbath).
But I wouldn't say that you were a heretic, and try to kick you out of the church.
JM
I already told you in my post that I am not referring to minor exegetical problems (I'm not talking about jewelry, or the theater here) when I speak of heresy; rather, I am referring to outright false doctrine, such as the idea that humans have evolved, which is a denial of a literal six day creation.
Ideas like these can not only cause people to turn away from God altogether, and thus become atheists, but they can also corrupt an entire congregation, and encourage people to implement a higher critical hermeneutic (the wrong kind) when studying the Bible. This, of course, would lead people to believe that many of the stories such as Jonah are merely fables. Such people even go so far as to deny that the miracles spoken of in the Bible really happened.
As for your argument that Paul and Peter disagreed with each other, it does not apply within this context, because neither one of them were heretics. And as for their so-called disagreement, it really wasn't a disagreement. Peter knew that what he did was wrong before he did it. This explains why he did not argue with Paul after being rebuked for siding with the Jews while refusing to sit with the Gentiles. It wasn't an issue of Peter teaching falsehood, but one of him being a hypocrite. And Paul was well within his right to rebuke Peter for this. Peter was a hypocrite in this case, not a heretic. There is a big difference.
It seems to me that you really need to spend some more time reading the scriptures, so that you will come to see that heresy was something that was never tolerated by God's people, except for when they were in rebellion against God. The idea that we should compromise with heretics is not Biblical.
You say that we ought to compromise with heretics, while providing no scriptural basis for such a teaching. Yet, I have provided you with Biblical proof that, without a shadow of a doubt, states that we should not do this. So as far as I am concerned this is where the discussion ends.
By the way, I never said we should throw these people out of the church. You inferred that. I said we should correct these people. And I will also add that if they refuse to accept the truth as it is in Jesus Christ they should not be allowed to teach in the church, since they would endanger the spirituality of the church by inculcating false doctrine.
Here is an example of how Paul instructed Timothy to regard heretics:
"But shun profane and vain babblings: for they will increase unto more ungodliness. And their word will eat as doth a canker: of whom is Hymenaeus and Philetus; Who concerning the truth have erred, saying that the resurrection is past already; and overthrow the faith of some."(2Ti 2:16-18)
Notice how he says nothing about compromising with them; rather, he instructs Timothy to shun their teachings. In othwer words, the idea here is that God's people should have nothing to do with the teachings of heretics. So what does this say about pastors that allow false teachers to teach in their church? It tells me that they really don't care about their flock!