Hello Paisley!
"Read the book of James.
OSAS leaves no room for repentance, and ignores what Jesus said to repent of our sins. It is pretty farfetched and egotistical to think that you can sin, and not have to repent of anything. Repentance and prayer keeps our heart and mind in the right place. To go about day to day living, thinking you are saved while you don't have to pay attention to what you are doing, or how you are saying things to others, that your words may hurt them, or whatever you may be doing, is not paying attention to what the Apostles taught us.
As I said before, read the book of James (the one Martin Luther wanted to throw out of the Bible) - and OSAS and the book of James is a complete opposite of each other."
I don't believe that James and OSAS are even close to being at odds w/ one another. The whole idea you have in James 2:17 is that faith without works is dead and that is absolutely true. Some people take OSAS and try to say that this leads to antinomianism (i.e. I can sin w/o repentance and be just fine) and that is definitely wrong. Someone who thinks that way is most likely not saved (Jude 3-4). If someone is truly saved they will be heartbroken over sin and will repent because of their love for God and desire to glorify Him. The whole point of James is that if someone truly is saved, their lives will reflect it in what they do. Faith alone is what saves us, but saving faith is never alone (Eph. 2:8-9 and James 2:17)
I believe OSAS is true because salvation is dependant upon God and not me. If it were dependant upon man we would all be taost b/c ALL of us are unfaithful. When you were saved, the penalty of your sin (not just you individual sins, but your sin as a whole) was paid for by the shed blood of Christ. The Scriptures say that all who believe are justified...made right before God. And that all that God has justified He has glorified. (Rom. 8:28-30). Your salvation in God's eyes is already complete because He will not go back on His justification of you by His Son and He won't quit working on you until the day of Christ (Phil. 1:6). Salvation is not a work of my will but a total work of God in my life. I wasn't saved because of my will, but because of God's will (John 1:13). The works that I do don't contribute one ounce to my salvation, nor do they keep me in the faith. Rather, they are in place to show that I truly believe and have been saved by Christ.
I would love to continue a discussion like this, but sadly I need to go.
In Christ
Matt