Starting today August 7th, 2024, in order to post in the Married Couples, Courting Couples, or Singles forums, you will not be allowed to post if you have your Marital status designated as private. Announcements will be made in the respective forums as well but please note that if yours is currently listed as Private, you will need to submit a ticket in the Support Area to have yours changed.
That's just silly.
The planet Jupiter contains no goodness. Does that make it an evil planet?
That's just silly.
The planet Jupiter contains no goodness. Does that make it an evil planet?
Actually, the planet Jupiter was created good.
We're talking about actions here, not created things. Created things are good until they choose to do evil and fall into sin.
Actually, the planet Jupiter was created good.
We're talking about actions here, not created things. Created things are good until they choose to do evil and fall into sin.
I think there's a big difference between "Created in the intended manner without mistake" and "Acting for the benefit of others."
As a working definition, evil is the will to intentional badness. You can't be an evil person without consciously and intentionally willing something bad upon someone else. There is also no such thing as an intrinsically or objectively bad thing or event; something is only evil by intentionality, by subjectivity. Another distinction should be made between an evil person and evil actions: the former is a person whose intentionality has become such that he constantly wills badness on others, whereas anyone can commit evil actions intermittently.
What causes someone to be evil? We often speak about this like people choose evil just for the heck of it, or are evil because they differ ideologically or culturally than us. But I think what motivates evil is accumulated perceived injustices in a person's life which the person displaces onto others in a decontextualized way. "The world screwed me over, and so I'll screw the world over back," is the motto for evil. One commits evil as a way of punishing others for the unfairness that the self perceives has been done to it, not just from the particular other but also additional instances of injustice done by others as well. Evil often involves overpaying the other person in badness given this displacement, and this is one of the big problems of evil: it repays too much badness on a single person at any given time. Hence, perhaps, the "blindness" involved with evil. Think about the people who grow up in bad homes or neighborhoods. They're much more likely to commit evil actions because they've had more accumulated injustices thrown their way.
Another way of saying this is that evil would be impossible without a standard of justice. If this is true, then all evil has an element of goodness in it, and in a real sense goodness is a main ingredient in motivating evil. This goodness (justice) is twisted or misapplied, but still, without a sense of justice there could be no evil.
"Acting for the benefit of others" is not an exhaustive Christian definition of goodness.
Christianity presupposes the act of creation itself is good. Unless you want to be a nihilist of some sort ,that is hard to argue against.
So basically, you're changing your position from your previous answer?
(Not that there's anything wrong with that...I just want to be sure before I respond)
Actually, the planet Jupiter was created good.
We're talking about actions here, not created things. Created things are good until they choose to do evil and fall into sin.
Inanimate objects can't choose to do anything.
Maybe that person should have distinguished between created "things" and created "beings"
The person called the planet Jupiter good until it chooses to be evil. I am not sure the distinction would have worked for their point.
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?