• Starting today August 7th, 2024, in order to post in the Married Couples, Courting Couples, or Singles forums, you will not be allowed to post if you have your Marital status designated as private. Announcements will be made in the respective forums as well but please note that if yours is currently listed as Private, you will need to submit a ticket in the Support Area to have yours changed.

Doctrine verses Faith

Status
Not open for further replies.
G

Godz Marine

Guest
Under the law wasn't atonement made through sacrifice and not grace by repentance?

Jesus may have quoted a generalization from someone else concerning the law but Jesus being Lord commanded it. And then added a second cocerning our relationship with others. These are not issues of the flesh man but one of the Spirit man.

In light of this, does the law produce the fruits of the Spirit as we read in the book of Galations?


As a general rule, I use the NIV for study references only. I rely mainly on KJ and NKJ along with the AMP version and Strong's Concordence.
 
Upvote 0

Charlesinflorida

Well-Known Member
Jan 2, 2004
503
18
74
Florida, US
Visit site
✟753.00
Faith
Messianic
Godz Marine said:
Under the law wasn't atonement made through sacrifice and not grace by repentance?

Jesus may have quoted a generalization from someone else concerning the law but Jesus being Lord commanded it. And then added a second cocerning our relationship with others. These are not issues of the flesh man but one of the Spirit man.

In light of this, does the law produce the fruits of the Spirit as we read in the book of Galations?


As a general rule, I use the NIV for study references only. I rely mainly on KJ and NKJ along with the AMP version and Strong's Concordence.

On the atonement issue:

It begins 40 days prior to the day of atonement. These forty days are the days of Teshuvah, (returning or repentence). During this time you are to do a lot of self inspection and prayer, to see where you might have offended or gone wrong. If you harmed someone you are to ask them or forgiveness and make any restitution that is needed, such as paying for any financial losses you caused. The last ten days of this 40 day period is alled the days of awe. It is the final chance to repent, beause on the day of atonement, only those sins you have confessed and repented of will be forgiven. This ten days begins with YomTeruah, the "last trumpet". It signals the opening of the gates of heaven. The "great trumpet" occurs at the end of the ten days, and signifies the closing of the gates of heaven. It was during these 40 days the John the Baptizer was preaching the message of Teshuvah, Repent and make straight paths for him for the day of the Lord is at hand.


Quote Marine "Jesus may have quoted a generalization from someone else concerning the law but Jesus being Lord commanded it."

No, really it was already commanded. As I said it was the feature of Judaism from the begining. The law always was spiritual in nature. It was a perverting of this spiritual law into a system of legalistic observance of Torah comands that was the problem that needed correction. The law was not bad or weak. It was man who was weak through the flesh and unable to keep it correctly. But God in his mercy, gives us the spirit to live in us so that the just requirements of the law are fulfilled in those who live not by the letter of the law (legalism) but by the spirit.(living according to the requirements of the law. If the gentiles who had not the law do the things contained in the law, then they have become a law unto themsleves, for the law is written upon their hearts.

Quote Marine "In light of this, does the law produce the fruits of the Spirit as we read in the book of Galations?"

Only the spirit can produce the fruit of the spirit. But as it does, the life of the person will begin to resemble that which is required of the law. Someone who has never studied the law, but who believes and is filled with the spirit will begin doing things differently, according to the leading of the spirit. They will find themselves doing the basics, loving God, loving neighbor, being more charitable, becoming more humble, being more helpful to others, less argumentative, putting away things that are harmful, like drugs alchohol. If we want to accelerate the process Paul says that we should STUDY (what?) the word (Tanahk) to show yourselve approved, and profitable unto all good works. Paul always points new believers in the direction of the scriptures because that is our first hand instruction from God. It is where he learned what he knew. Scriptures in light of Messiah Yeshua.

On the NIV, I would caution you that they take some liberties in places. If in doubt, go with a literal translation.

Charles in Florida
 
Upvote 0
G

Godz Marine

Guest
Charlesinflorida said:
On the atonement issue:

It begins 40 days prior to the day of atonement. These forty days are the days of Teshuvah, (returning or repentence). During this time you are to do a lot of self inspection and prayer, to see where you might have offended or gone wrong. If you harmed someone you are to ask them or forgiveness and make any restitution that is needed, such as paying for any financial losses you caused. The last ten days of this 40 day period is alled the days of awe. It is the final chance to repent, beause on the day of atonement, only those sins you have confessed and repented of will be forgiven. This ten days begins with YomTeruah, the "last trumpet". It signals the opening of the gates of heaven. The "great trumpet" occurs at the end of the ten days, and signifies the closing of the gates of heaven. It was during these 40 days the John the Baptizer was preaching the message of Teshuvah, Repent and make straight paths for him for the day of the Lord is at hand.


So let me see if I get this right. One can only repent of their sins within this 40 day period before the day of atonement and then you can only recieve atonement for your sins on the "Day of Atonement"? If this is as you have written then what becomes of one who dies before the time of repentance or atonement thus dying in thier sin?


Marine "Jesus may have quoted a generalization from someone else concerning the law but Jesus being Lord commanded it."

No, really it was already commanded. As I said it was the feature of Judaism from the begining. The law always was spiritual in nature. It was a perverting of this spiritual law into a system of legalistic observance of Torah comands that was the problem that needed correction. The law was not bad or weak. It was man who was weak through the flesh and unable to keep it correctly. But God in his mercy, gives us the spirit to live in us so that the just requirements of the law are fulfilled in those who live not by the letter of the law (legalism) but by the spirit.(living according to the requirements of the law. If the gentiles who had not the law do the things contained in the law, then they have become a law unto themsleves, for the law is written upon their hearts.

So then, if the law was so complicated (613 laws one needs to remember!!!) that man was unable to keep it , wasn't Jesus by saying that He had come to fulfill the law, and then giving us only 2 new commandments to remember which makes it easier to attempt to follow, wasn't He just making it easier for us to now fulfill the law?

It is quite apparent that for almost 4000 years the elect of God could not fulfill the law so how much less could the Gentiles fulfill it? Of course that is simple. We read in Revelation of how one overcomes, "by the blood of the Lamb (Christ) and the word of thier (those who overcome) testimony. This testimony is not of the Torah but of Christ and Christ alone. If all one needed to do was live the Torah and speak the Torah then the death of Christ and the outpouring of His blood would not have been needed. Nor would we have to believe in Him. We would not need to believe in our hearts and confess (our testimony) His name as the Son of God.

Marine "In light of this, does the law produce the fruits of the Spirit as we read in the book of Galations?"

Only the spirit can produce the fruit of the spirit. But as it does, the life of the person will begin to resemble that which is required of the law. Someone who has never studied the law, but who believes and is filled with the spirit will begin doing things differently, according to the leading of the spirit. They will find themselves doing the basics, loving God, loving neighbor, being more charitable, becoming more humble, being more helpful to others, less argumentative, putting away things that are harmful, like drugs alchohol. If we want to accelerate the process Paul says that we should STUDY (what?) the word (Tanahk) to show yourselve approved, and profitable unto all good works. Paul always points new believers in the direction of the scriptures because that is our first hand instruction from God. It is where he learned what he knew. Scriptures in light of Messiah Yeshua.

I believe what Paul is saying by studying to show ones self approved and rightly dividing the Word is not to accelerate the work of the Holy Spirit but so that one who has purposed to live a life led by the Spirit will know it is the Spirit of God which is speaking to them. If reading the Torah was a more accelerated method of gaining the fruits of the Spirit why was it not enough thus requireing the blood of Christ at Calvery which open the door for the Holy Spirit to come and give us power? Why was this power needed if the Torah was enough?

On the NIV, I would caution you that they take some liberties in places. If in doubt, go with a literal translation.

I am fully aware of this and thus my purpose of reserving it to a place of reference for study. Scripture does say though that we all know in part and prophecy in part being meaning that no man knows all the truth for if this were possible we would be able to walk sinless lives. We need the truth that each part holds. Have there not also been various authers of versions of the Torah and especially the 613 laws? Is it that there is only one truly and completely correct version and the rest are false because of some simple errors or liberties which were taken?
 
Upvote 0

PatrickM

What? You're not a Fightin' Irish fan????
Jan 8, 2004
1,748
85
70
Utah now!
✟24,870.00
Faith
Non-Denom
reAsonX said:
How come so many of these threads seem to get drug down into an arguement about the law?
"drug"??? Who's on drug(s)?? :D

Could it be because the title to this thread is "Doctrine vs. faith"? And when some people get very focused on an issue, the thread gets dragged down?
 
Upvote 0

PatrickM

What? You're not a Fightin' Irish fan????
Jan 8, 2004
1,748
85
70
Utah now!
✟24,870.00
Faith
Non-Denom
didaskalos said:
I like the parable of the Compassionate Father (I know most people refer to it as the parable of the prodigal son).
Wow, I like that (Compassionate Father), too!
Jesus said that the young son who left and ended up with the pigs was not "being himself".

Luk 15:17
17 And when he came to himself, he said, How many hired servants of my father's have bread enough and to spare, and I perish with hunger!
Is this a hint to your answer, re: believing in your heart a "lie"? Did the wayward son ("Kansas", 1975, oh, nevermind) for a time believe a "lie" when he thought he could make it on his own?
 
Upvote 0
Status
Not open for further replies.