David Gould
Pearl Harbor sucked. WinAce didn't.
- May 28, 2002
- 16,931
- 514
- 54
- Faith
- Atheist
- Politics
- AU-Labor
Lilly of the Valley said:Okay, then do you agree that one conclusion going w/ the assumption there is no rt. and wrong and we just go by feelings, is that there shouldn't be any punishment (ignoring the fact of preventing chaos and society's rules and etc...) if a person does something that is rt. to them (ex: kill an infant that is perfectly healthy and has done nothing) they shouldn't get punished since it was technically good and rt. for them?
I do not believe anyone should ever be punished for anything.
However, that does not mean that I think such a person should not be locked up until we can find a way to ensure that they do not do such things.
This is because I do not want to have my children murdered, or indeed the children of others murdered. I do not like it.
In other words, if people do things that I do not like I will try to stop them. One of the best means of stopping them is convincing others to help stop them - a society.
Upvote
0