Are All Christians Disciples?

[HereIStand]

I've recently encountered the idea that some Christians believe that certain Christians are called to be disciples, while others are not. Or rather, some Christians are Christians, but not disciples. I had read about something like this from an historical perspective within Lutheranism, but had not encountered a modern variation of it. My sense is that this type of teaching is at odds with the Reformed Tradition. Would that be the case?

 

[St_Worm2]

Matthew 28:19's definition for "disciple" (mathēteuō) is to 'make followers or committed students'. MacArthur says it carries the sense of both "believing and following".

I do not believe that one can be a true believer and not also be a disciple/follower/learner of Christ's. IOW, a true Christian will not hold Christ as Savior and not hold Him as Lord of their lives as well.

On the flip side, while all of those who truly believe will become disciples, I think there are some the Bible refers to as "disciples" who were never true believers (see John 6:66).

--David

 

[toolmanjantzi]

I've recently encountered the idea that some Christians believe that certain Christians are called to be disciples, while others are not. Or rather, some Christians are Christians, but not disciples. I had read about something like this from an historical perspective within Lutheranism, but had not encountered a modern variation of it. My sense is that this type of teaching is at odds with the Reformed Tradition. Would that be the case?

Awesome question. I was thinking about the same thing today and I think Macarthur's answer is great.

Then said Jesus to those Jews which believed on him, If ye continue in my word, then are ye my disciples indeed; And ye shall know the truth, and the truth shall make you free. (John 8:31, 32 KJV)

 

[toolite]

Saints and choosen?

Glory To God