I friend of mine recently put this question to a group of us. Because the group isn't a place where one would normally find those who are concerned about inerrancy, I suggested that he was asking the wrong group of people. But, maybe he could find help with his query from this group. Below is his post:
Hey everyone I have a question for you all, please post a link if you know of one that might answer this question. I run into the topic of inerrancy (I hope I spelled that right) of scripture often, occasionally with folks in my congregation and more so in interaction with other Protestants in my community. That is not a doctrine I hold with. Often when this topics comes up people hold up II Timothy 3:16, as the "proof" of it. When I read that it says all scripture is "inspired" (which I agree with and see as crucial to my understanding of the Methodist Quadrilateral) but I see nothing about inerrant. Can someone explain to me how this passage is used to try and "prove" inerrancy and or if other passages are raised up in support. I am not a proof texter (I think), however I would however like to understand where these folks are coming from, if you have any insight I am all ears! Thanks friends!