Starting today August 7th, 2024, in order to post in the Married Couples, Courting Couples, or Singles forums, you will not be allowed to post if you have your Marital status designated as private. Announcements will be made in the respective forums as well but please note that if yours is currently listed as Private, you will need to submit a ticket in the Support Area to have yours changed.
I can't.
I can say that. Material reality in no way presupposes the existence of a creator. Anyone who says it does is arguing from false premises.
Make of it what you will. But I would like someone to tell me what gives humans a conscience if it's not from God?
Ok, I bet you can make this argument yourself. Assume God does not exist (we're just assuming here) and you part of a society at the dawn of civilization. What do you suppose would be required for that civilization to run effectively? Again, we are running with the theory that God does NOT exist.
I know what you're getting at, I've heard it before. You're saying that if there was not some sort of universal laws of basic morality (as decided by society, not God as you say) then humans would have wiped themselves out.
It's a good argument, I'll give you that. But I see one HUGE problem with that. I'm a middle aged guy, and in my experience of humanity, I can honestly say that most humans are looking out for number one-each to their own. Your premise would only work if you can say that mankind is basically good and generally is concerned with one another, the society around them etc.
But this is simply not true. Mankind is basically rotten to the core, and I have the whole of human history and all its horrors, atrocities and injustices to prove my point as opposed to yours. Mankind therefore is incapable on his own to devise a basic set of morality for his preservation. I see that a God given conscience is absolutely indispensable just for mankind to survive.
It isn't a huge problem because most of the atrocities and horrors you mention are not carried out on the person's own group. We form communities as humans. We like being part of a bigger group. Once we are part of the group, we rarely turn against it.
We are quite willing to go after another group. We may even be willing to go after individuals within the group for personal gain, but we try our best not to put ourselves outside the group in that quest.
That maybe so, but in the end, mankind ultimately belongs to only one group-mankind. Without basic God given morality, every group would every turn on every other group and would have quickly wiped itself out.
How do you suppose ape communities continue to exist? Or dog packs? Or lion prides? Do they also have the conscience of God written upon their hearts?
That's a good point and exactly what I'm talking about. I don't believe animals have any free will. They are creation that is pre programmed with the most fundamental laws of survival written in them. An animal has no concept of right or wrong. Animals are governed solely by survival. And in fact, look at all the species of creation that have been made extinct.
We form those groups so we can survive, and understand that killing members of our group weakens the group.
Do you place so much faith in the goodness of man that the average man/woman doesn't kill others because they are concerned for their particular group or society as a whole?
There is no way I'd ever entertain that notion. My experience of human beings is that the average one is far from being that noble. There is absolutely no way that the average person has the interests of their group or society on their mind. My own interactions with people have taught me that.
Mankind is incapable of that type of self preservation. The only thing that stops the average person (without knowledge of God or the Bible) from killing, stealing, raping etc is their God given conscience.
And how do you explain charitable acts of mankind that are NOT good for the interests of the giver? If mankind is driven by self preservation, how do you explain someone that sacrifices himself for the sake of someone else? It makes no sense in the absence of God, but is explained by the light of God in every person.
If your average interactions show that humans are not that noble, how can you come to the conclusion that God wrote morals on their heart?
For if mankind is basically evil, what stops most people from committing the most grievious of crimes? The inbuilt directions we all have from God.
I don't believe we are evil though.
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?