• Starting today August 7th, 2024, in order to post in the Married Couples, Courting Couples, or Singles forums, you will not be allowed to post if you have your Marital status designated as private. Announcements will be made in the respective forums as well but please note that if yours is currently listed as Private, you will need to submit a ticket in the Support Area to have yours changed.

A Culture of Cruelty

TG123

Regular Member
Jul 1, 2006
4,965
203
somewhere
✟29,469.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Married
This document was released by No More Deaths today. As you may know I volunteered with this group during the summer in the desert in Arizona. During their humanitarian work, No More Deaths interviews migrants who have been deported from the US to Mexico. There has long been suspicion that abuse takes place in USBP custody and during the deportations, but the scale and intensity is truly horrifying. I have rarely read anything more disturbing.

Between November 2008 and March 2011, over thirty thousand incidents of abuse of migrants in Border Patrol custody has been recorded. They range from beatings to denial of water to taking people's money to racist taunting to putting people in paddy wagons and driving them full speed across the desert- with the result being the people inside are thrown around and banged up, sometimes with broken bones. The victims of this violence are people who for the most part have not harmed anyone but have been forced to look for work and cross the border illegally so their families back home can survive... and the desperation that drove most of them to such a situation has been caused to a large part by American and Canadian trade policies.

The whole report is 72 pages long, and it is not a pleasant read. I am copying from fragments from the report.

Some examples quoted from the report

• Derogatory racial, ethnic, and sexual epithets
• Profanity
• Yelling and screaming for no apparent reason, both in the
field and in processing centers

Agents striking and/or kicking people in custody with
hands, feet or objects
• Agents running people over with vehicles or horses
• Use of chokeholds
• Sexual assault
• Chaining people together with shackles and forcing them
to run
• Use of restraints that leave bruise marks on arms and ankles
• Forceful application of standing and sitting positions that
are painful (e.g., hand-cuffing a detainee’s hands to their ankles
and leaving them in that position alone for hours)
• Forcing people to remove shoes and walk in the desert

• Lack of seat belts in Border Patrol and G4S/Wackenhut
vehicles
• Agents driving at high speeds over rough terrain
• Agents intentionally driving in circles to cause nausea
• Hazardous overcrowding
• Vehicles kept at extreme temperatures

Vandalism of life-saving resources
such as food, water, and blankets and
interference with medical treatment

Volunteers consistently meet migrants who are dehydrated
and starving, many times necessitating emergency medical
evacuations. Individuals also tell them about finding food and
water that saved their lives as they wandered the desert. No
More Deaths consistently documents the vandalism of those
very life-saving supplies it leaves in strategic locations where individuals
in crisis can find them.
Volunteers have acquired evidence that Border Patrol agents
vandalize these life-saving supplies in the desert. During 2010,
the group documented the large-scale destruction and removal
of life-saving water and resources at least once a week on average.
Multiple reports tell of Border Patrol vehicles seen leaving
an area with stockpiles of water, food and blankets. Humanitarian
aid workers subsequently find the items violently cut up
and thrown into ravines. On at least three occasions, Border
Patrol agents have been recorded in the act of removing water
that could have saved lives. In May 2011, a Border Patrol agent
in the field told No More Deaths volunteers that supervisors
advise agents to not simply destroy the water they found in the
desert, but to remove it entirely so as to not “litter.”


Feb. 16, 2010, anonymous man, 16, from Guatemala. He
walked for two days until being apprehended by the Border
Patrol. He was thrown to the ground and kicked in the knee.
Agents took his $20 and hit him in the back of the head with a
flashlight. As he told the story, he appeared confused about why
they had beaten him. “They didn’t understand me and treated
me like a dog,” he said. Agents joked about him, saying he was
like a toy. They asked if he wanted water, but when he responded
“yes,” they wouldn’t give him any. He was also taunted with
food. Eventually, during three days in custody, he received a
small packet of cookies and a small juice box each day.

Nov. 27, 2009, with Javier, 19, from Mexico. He stated that
while crossing in the desert, a Border Patrol agent apprehended
the group and beat two of his companions. He hit one in the
head three times, and grabbed the other by the hood of his
sweatshirt to throw him to the ground, and then kicked him
in the ribs. The agent took the group into custody without giving
them food, water or medical attention even though they requested
it. They were held for four hours in one location and
then moved to another in Tucson for 24 hours. The interviewee
reported that the Tucson center was dirty and so full that, even
with 40 people in one cell, people could not move. There were
no beds, only benches, and the air conditioning was turned on
high. During 28 hours in detention, detainees were given only
one small hamburger each. At one point, the interviewee tried
to address a guard, but the guard slammed the door in his face.
The agent who drove the van carrying the migrants to the Mariposa
Port of Entry drove recklessly. Despite the fact the van was
packed with 20 people and it was very hot, he turned the heat
all the way up and ignored requests to turn it down.


http://www.cultureofcruelty.org/wp-c...ueltyFinal.pdf


These crimes are being perpetrated against people who for the most part are innocent of any wrongdoing, except trying to escape poverty. Their cries rise up to the heavens. May their victimizers and all those who profit and take part and look away as this is taking place repent. It is not only innocent people, it is also Jesus they are hurting.
 
Last edited:

TG123

Regular Member
Jul 1, 2006
4,965
203
somewhere
✟29,469.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Married
The last video down on the page. The NMD volunteers who spoke in the short 6 minute film were all people I met in Arizona.

Slashing a water bottle may not seem like a big deal to some, but when it is over 40 degrees outside and hungry and dehydrated people are dependent on them to survive, it is murder. NMD volunteers leave out water bottles in the Sonora Desert for migrants and they have often been slashed or emptied by the BP and other law enforcement agencies.

Videos | A Culture of Cruelty - No More Deaths | A Culture of Cruelty - No More Deaths
 
Upvote 0

wintermile

Bioconservative
May 9, 2011
1,320
35
✟24,222.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Single
Ok. I will respond to the call to action concerning Mexico-US border patrol violence. Blameworthy, I aim to follow activists who have researched the situations at the border and are in position to enact reform.

Ex-border patrol agent John Randolph briefly mentioned online how asylum for Mexican citizens who are subjected to the "US backed drug war" is a must . Under a catch up status, I am confounded as to why all NAFTA-induced migrating Mexican citizens are not protected under asylum. I bring up asylum because I see it as an overall solution.

For any of us beginning our aim to activism, addressing border patrol violence at the same pace as speaking out for asylum for migrants, I assume, are the two key areas of research that need to be organized. Speaking for myself, allow me to be efficient. Understanding where to tackle the mess of research concerning this crisis is pivotal to how well I ensure feedback is granted. Yes, I want feedback from officials concerning border patrol violence and I will research who is right there at the office door. Also, I aim to support justice for those who have been violated. What work has been submitted to date?

That block between rude socio-cultural pretenses and already direly paid for civil action does not warrant a pause before enacting justice. The groundwork is fair.

From border patrol agent to immigration reform activist: My journey for justice | MarioWire
 
Upvote 0

Christopher14

Crusader
Sep 20, 2011
35
1
The South
✟22,660.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Married
Politics
US-Others
Under a catch up status, I am confounded as to why all NAFTA-induced migrating Mexican citizens are not protected under asylum. I bring up asylum because I see it as an overall solution.

So NAFTA is the problem and asylum is the solution. How irresponsible. How about ending NAFTA as the solution? Look at the big picture!
 
Upvote 0

Christopher14

Crusader
Sep 20, 2011
35
1
The South
✟22,660.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Married
Politics
US-Others
Ok. End NAFTA. I will look into how organizations are taking down NAFTA. In the meantime, asylum for migrants is a temporary solution. There is nothing irresponsible about learning about all solutions.

The forces for asylum, amnesty, immigrationism, etc are much stronger than the push to end NAFTA. Remember back in '92 when Ross Perot was the only one speaking the truth about NAFTA? He was right. But he was quashed by misled politicians and special interests. Republicans and Democrats are brutal. They no longer represent the interests of the people.

We need to bring the fight to those responsible. The Mexicans are innocent in this and I hate to see them mistreated. But asylum-amnesty-immigrationism is not the answer.
 
Upvote 0

Christopher14

Crusader
Sep 20, 2011
35
1
The South
✟22,660.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Married
Politics
US-Others
Ok. End NAFTA. I will look into how organizations are taking down NAFTA. In the meantime, asylum for migrants is a temporary solution. There is nothing irresponsible about learning about all solutions.

I should have mentioned this. History is replete with examples of "temporary solutions." But these temporary solutions are never temporary. It's the same thing as kicking the can down the road, over and over again. It's procrastination. It's the result of anxiety of the masses and too much concern with temporal well-being. It's group psychology. It never works out and leads to downfall.
 
Upvote 0

TG123

Regular Member
Jul 1, 2006
4,965
203
somewhere
✟29,469.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Married
So NAFTA is the problem and asylum is the solution. How irresponsible. How about ending NAFTA as the solution? Look at the big picture!
Good idea, Christopher14. Let's end NAFTA.

While we are doing so, let us work to prevent the people who are being forced by it to cross the border illegally from dying in the desert and suffering brutalities at the hands of the BP. When we end NAFTA, most will stop crossing and there won't be any more need for asylum and groups like No More Deaths.
 
Upvote 0

TG123

Regular Member
Jul 1, 2006
4,965
203
somewhere
✟29,469.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Married
Breaking the law by default makes them not innocent. And many of them are involved in other illegal activity, namely drug cartels and human trafficking.
They're guilty of illegally crossing the border.

Unlike our politicians and business leaders who passed NAFTA and are running sweatshops south of the border, they are for the most part innocent of theft.

When you start advocating for the arrest and incarceration of Presidents Bush and Clinton and US maquiladora owners for the robbery and exploitation and displacement of millions of Mexicans in their own country from 1994 to the present day, I'll take your condemnation of the migrants more seriously.
 
Upvote 0

Vylo

Stick with the King!
Aug 3, 2003
24,768
7,823
44
New Jersey
✟212,869.00
Faith
Atheist
Marital Status
Private
Politics
US-Others
Crossing the border illegally is illegal, and thus they are criminals, and not innocent.

I suppose we could solve all the cruelty problems and simply shoot everyone who comes across like many countries do. You may also want to look at how mexico treats their illegals.
 
Upvote 0

Vylo

Stick with the King!
Aug 3, 2003
24,768
7,823
44
New Jersey
✟212,869.00
Faith
Atheist
Marital Status
Private
Politics
US-Others
Also you do realize backing out of NAFTA would actually increase illegal immigration with less work available in mexico, right?

Those factories you speak of had a 15% jump in pay when NAFTA was implemented.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Christopher14
Upvote 0

wintermile

Bioconservative
May 9, 2011
1,320
35
✟24,222.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Single
I should have mentioned this. History is replete with examples of "temporary solutions." But these temporary solutions are never temporary. It's the same thing as kicking the can down the road, over and over again. It's procrastination. It's the result of anxiety of the masses and too much concern with temporal well-being. It's group psychology. It never works out and leads to downfall.


The US Chamber of Commerce and other Free Trade proponents are targeting nations left and right in order to eliminate competition. One example is New Zealand and the TPPA. If you and the organizations you support are not able to safeguard New Zealand and Asian nations from being overtaken by the US Chamber of Commerce and unethical economists then how will NAFTA fall?

This is what I want. I want those who invest in organizations similar to NMDs to partner with other like-minds to buy land in Mexico. On that land, I want to be party to building earthdomes for Mexicans. I want to build the earthdomes and I want to watch them plant and harvest organic gardens. As we all know, those who live in the US often send money home to a family member overseas. It is easy to support individuals overseas, even if those people do not work or receive a livelihood. It is something I can do financially and to me, doing something is important. You cannot say that this simple idea is flawed. You can, however, say it is ignored; unless you can tell me there is a leader or more currently setting up programs such as what I have just described.

Out with NAFTA, definitely. What kind of public voice does it take to say hey, if you expect to come into my country and set up shop, then do so respectfully. If not, hit the road? Mexican citizens should abandon all maquiladoras. Who needs NAFTA? Quoting Ralph Nader, "just across the border from Matamoros, a maquiladora town, babies are being born without brains in record numbers; public health officials in the area believe there is a link between anencephaly and exposure of pregnant women to certain toxic chemicals dumped in streams and on the ground in the maquiladoras across the border". Nader informed the public of this years ago. No one should be working in the maquiladoras. NO ONE.
Have all the International Labor Union reps inside workers' groups you want, but not one Mexican citizen should be working in those dehumanizing camps.

How hard is it to buy land throughout Mexico and turn the land into edible and organic community gardens specifically for Mexican citizens? It is not hard to do. There are a lot of us who will support Mexican citizens in their own homes just as if they were our family members overseas. Living in a decent earthdome home is far better than being subjected to transborder governance and abuse.

The OP brings awareness to the crisis. I want to respond, act. I can not stand reading about the 30,000 incidents of BP abuse that took place in the last 3 years and do nothing. This morning I began to read The Culture of Cruelty. The brightest and best must volunteer at NMDs. They prove organization is an Art that can impede lawbreakers, similar to The Underground Railroad.

I am thankful for those who invest in NMDs. Unlike the Sierra Club, the organization appears dedicated without compromising its objectives.

I'll be looking out for you and your NAFTA ending work. Hope the phase it out hit includes the TPPA.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Christopher14
Upvote 0

wintermile

Bioconservative
May 9, 2011
1,320
35
✟24,222.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Single
Also you do realize backing out of NAFTA would actually increase illegal immigration with less work available in mexico, right?

Those factories you speak of had a 15% jump in pay when NAFTA was implemented.

In his book, Ian Fletcher submits Commentator William Greider's quote for argument: "The Mexican maquiladora cities thought they were going to become the next South Korea, but instead they may be the next Detroit".

The only reason they thought they might excel is because they were influenced by unethical economists.
 
Upvote 0

wintermile

Bioconservative
May 9, 2011
1,320
35
✟24,222.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Single
From me, one more comment about assisting Mexican citizens with rebuilding their communities (even in the throes of cartel violence). Another worthwhile reason to build organic farms in Mexico for/with Mexican citizens relates to the coming global food crisis. I listened to an interview online covering this topic. Julian Cribb was interviewed over the material in his book The Coming Famine: The Global Food Crisis and What We Can Do To Avoid It. An imperative duty it is to ensure regions of people are not hard hit from this coming crisis. These days it seems action should be not be organized but in the works. For Mexican citizens, especially those counting on security in the States, I want to assist (or know someone is assisting them). My guess, some of the states, especially water-wasting Arizona, will be lacking in resources. Instead of migrating to the States, Mexican citizens should be assisted to re-build their own self-sustaining communites.

If their communites are re-built, they will not encounter border patrol violence.

To be honest, a lot of us Americans are attempting to look out for our own security. But the potential in Mexico is public and cannot be ignored; so I repeat my request for action.

Mexican citizens should not see the US as a secure nation. At the link, the following article outlines a few perspectives concerning our freedom. Jesse Richard writes, "Here is how free you are in your own home in your own country."

Our Troops do NOT Protect Our Freedom and We Should Stop Thanking Them for Doing So
 
Upvote 0

PHenry42

Newbie
Feb 3, 2011
1,108
43
✟1,527.00
Faith
Muslim
Abolish US corn subsidies, and corn dumping in Mexico will end, allowing Mexican agriculture to recover.

As it is, my tax $$ are used to pay American corn farmers to engage in overproduction, which is both economically inefficient and disastrous for the Mexican farmer, which in turn leads to mass unemployment and a plummeting of maquiladora workers' wages.

Since spending cuts are all the rage nowadays, let's start with the corn subsidies, mkay? We save money, Mexican farmers get back to work, and unemployment in Mexico decreases, giving factory workers more power to bargain for better wages and working conditions. Everyone wins! Well, except for American corn farmers, but what moral claim do they have to subsidies anyway?
 
Upvote 0

TG123

Regular Member
Jul 1, 2006
4,965
203
somewhere
✟29,469.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Married
Abolish US corn subsidies, and corn dumping in Mexico will end, allowing Mexican agriculture to recover.

As it is, my tax $$ are used to pay American corn farmers to engage in overproduction, which is both economically inefficient and disastrous for the Mexican farmer, which in turn leads to mass unemployment and a plummeting of maquiladora workers' wages.

Since spending cuts are all the rage nowadays, let's start with the corn subsidies, mkay? We save money, Mexican farmers get back to work, and unemployment in Mexico decreases, giving factory workers more power to bargain for better wages and working conditions. Everyone wins! Well, except for American corn farmers, but what moral claim do they have to subsidies anyway?
Now THAT's a good solution!!! Too bad there aren't people like you in Congress!
 
Upvote 0