- Feb 5, 2002
- 190,350
- 70,488
- Country
- United States
- Gender
- Female
- Faith
- Catholic
- Marital Status
- Married
- Politics
- US-Others
Consider two couples at a dinner party in a prosperous American suburb. Both are in their late thirties. Both are educated, professionally accomplished, and by every measurable standard of modern life, successful.
The first couple — call them Mark and Claire — are what the culture celebrates. Advanced degrees. Senior careers. A renovated townhouse. Annual trips to Europe. They have been married eleven years. They have no children. This was not an accident or a sorrow. It was, as they would explain, a deliberate choice to prioritize freedom, partnership, and intentional living.
The second couple — call them James and Rebecca — represent something the culture has largely lost its category for. James earns a solidly middle-class salary. Rebecca has not held outside employment in nine years. They have six children, a used minivan with permanently embedded crackers in the back seats, and a house that is never entirely clean. If you ask them about their life, they will use words that sound almost arcane: calling, vocation, blessing, heritage.
Which couple is building something that will last? Which of them is rich?
The U.S. fertility rate dropped to 1.599 births per woman in 2024 — an all-time recorded low. For a civilization to replace itself, you need 2.1. South Korea has reached 0.72, barely above a third of replacement level. Korean demographers have begun describing the situation not as a policy challenge but as civilizational extinction.
We receive these numbers the way we receive news of distant earthquakes: with momentary attention and no change of behavior.
C.S. Lewis once warned that a civilization that loses its confidence in objective values does not merely adopt different values. It produces what he called “men without chests” — human beings with intellect and appetite but no formed moral center, incapable of the sacrificial commitments that civilization requires. A society of men without chests does not maintain marriages through difficult times. And, as we are now discovering, it does not have children.
Continued below.
therobertbshow.substack.com
The first couple — call them Mark and Claire — are what the culture celebrates. Advanced degrees. Senior careers. A renovated townhouse. Annual trips to Europe. They have been married eleven years. They have no children. This was not an accident or a sorrow. It was, as they would explain, a deliberate choice to prioritize freedom, partnership, and intentional living.
The second couple — call them James and Rebecca — represent something the culture has largely lost its category for. James earns a solidly middle-class salary. Rebecca has not held outside employment in nine years. They have six children, a used minivan with permanently embedded crackers in the back seats, and a house that is never entirely clean. If you ask them about their life, they will use words that sound almost arcane: calling, vocation, blessing, heritage.
Which couple is building something that will last? Which of them is rich?
The U.S. fertility rate dropped to 1.599 births per woman in 2024 — an all-time recorded low. For a civilization to replace itself, you need 2.1. South Korea has reached 0.72, barely above a third of replacement level. Korean demographers have begun describing the situation not as a policy challenge but as civilizational extinction.
We receive these numbers the way we receive news of distant earthquakes: with momentary attention and no change of behavior.
C.S. Lewis once warned that a civilization that loses its confidence in objective values does not merely adopt different values. It produces what he called “men without chests” — human beings with intellect and appetite but no formed moral center, incapable of the sacrificial commitments that civilization requires. A society of men without chests does not maintain marriages through difficult times. And, as we are now discovering, it does not have children.
Continued below.
The DINK Delusion: Why the Childless Dream Is a Dead End
Consider two couples at a dinner party in a prosperous American suburb.