• Starting today August 7th, 2024, in order to post in the Married Couples, Courting Couples, or Singles forums, you will not be allowed to post if you have your Marital status designated as private. Announcements will be made in the respective forums as well but please note that if yours is currently listed as Private, you will need to submit a ticket in the Support Area to have yours changed.

Prayer was never going to be answered....

seeker2122

Well-Known Member
Sep 29, 2022
402
104
36
Sarasota
✟45,976.00
Country
United States
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Single
I do believe in prayer and I know it's not necessarily an "ask and you shall receive" sorta deal.
Prayer is about intimacy with God and not using it as some sort of genie in the bottle tactic.
Prayer sometimes is looked upon incorrectly as something you do as a petition to God to get an outcome you want.
The reality is we do not change God in and by prayer but it is we who come out of it changed.

Now onto my scenario.

I'm asking this now because I am able to look back in hindsight and see the outcome clearer than when I was
in the moment and hopeful. I realized that no matter how much I prayed, how earnest, sincere, and genuine it was, or
how faithful even of a person I could have been, nothing was going to change the outcome that came to be.

In other words, I'm a little disturbed that seeing and knowing what I know now, prayer wouldn't have made an ounce of
difference because it was never going to go that way.

Here's what I mean. A year ago, I believed God was doing something special in our little community/church. I was convicted
the Holy Spirit was working and going to grow our group and raise leaders, and continue to develop a core group and foundation
here. I'm going to use made up names for this situation.

I thought to myself if I can be faithful and obey God and follow Him, it is He that will build his church and His Spirit will move
and shape everything that is to happen. So I had prayed about the members and believed they would be a foundational part
of what God was building here and preparing us to do. I prayed for Sally, John, Bob, Jim, and Jane, and other people too.

It turns out few months later, Sally, John, Bob, Jim and Jane, Morris, Donny, and Patty were all moving away due to things we cannot change. Sally moved
hundreds of miles away to pursue further education. John also was assigned to another country from his workplace. Bob also
moved with his wife and kids back to another country to live with his parents. Jim and Jane also moved with their family back
to another country where they originally came from, same goes with Morris, Donny, and Patty. These weren't choices they had an option to stay
or not....they were things they HAD/MUST do and staying here was always just temporary.

Basically, 75% of everyone that used to be here had to move. It was either
work related, family related, or simply their time here was finished (contracts were up etc). So I realized now having known this,
when I look back to a year ago when I didn't know they were all going to move away anyways, I realized no matter how much I would
have prayed, fasted, been faithful to God, believed in the things God was doing here, none of it would have changed a thing because
they were ALL going to move away anyways.

It's not like they got sent away because I or we failed to be faithful and obedient, and failed to repent, fast, and give it our best. If we
had been the perfect Christian like Jesus for 1 year, that wouldn't have changed the fact they were all going to be moving away regardless.
So then prayer wouldn't have changed the outcome.

I just found that kinda interesting and depressing when looking back with the advantage of hindsight because you realize I was sort of
played like a fool not realizing that no matter how much I prayed or how good of believer I was, it was never in the cards and it was always
a dead end.

The group has nearly completely dismantled (I also left but by choice). There is a newer group of members that came in now and of course I know God has an infinite
plan so it's not like one possibility was foiled and now God's plan got screwed up. No. God obviously is in full control and nobody can thwart
his plans so He doesn't need us or me, for His plans to carry on, but He is obviously working still and doing something else (with the reset and
new members that have arrived). I just found this to be eye opening and confusing because it's not like a situation where it could have been
averted such as an accident, tragedy, mishap, poor decisions, timing, etc. No, these moves by Sally, John, Bob, Jim and Jane, Morris, Donny and Patty, were all cemented/arranged ahead of time and they weren't going to be here 100%...I just didn't know that specifically at the time, but I believed we were all here
to be the foundational members/leaders and build this church and raise the community to serve and worship God, be a family in Christ, and glorify Him
in our community.
 

com7fy8

Well-Known Member
May 22, 2013
14,732
6,636
Massachusetts
✟654,559.00
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Single
Yes, prayer is for intimacy with God >

"But you, beloved, building yourselves up on your most holy faith, praying in the Holy Spirit, keep yourselves in the love of God, looking for the mercy of our Lord Jesus Christ unto eternal life." (in Jude 20-21)

And in intimacy with God we are submissive to Him, so we do what He has us doing at each moment. This includes praying what He has us praying, including trusting Jesus to judge and know what He is going to do with us and everything.

"Therefore submit to God." (in James 4:7)

"And let the peace of God rule in your hearts, to which also you were called in one body; and be thankful." (Colossians 3:15)

In the ruling of God's own peace in us, we have God's own creativity and personal leading for how to love each person.

And we love other churches and places, by welcoming our special Jesus people to leave our own churches and go to bless other churches and places. Our cup runs over, with the best of how God blesses us running over to bless others.

And God does better than we now can hope and wish. Therefore we need to keep growing in Jesus so we have the character to benefit from and minister to others all that God is going to do.

Character correction, then, could be the main thing of Biblical prayer > Hebrews 12:4-14 > therefore praying for us all to be conformed to the image of Jesus in His character "gentle and lowly in heart" (in Matthew 11:29) and all-loving and submissive to our Father > Romans 8:29 > Philippians 4:6-7 > praying "for all the saints" to mature in Jesus and how He has us submissive to our Father > Ephesians 6:18. And pray for any and all people > 1 Timothy 2:1-4 < with hope for any person, at all > love "hopes all things" (In 1 Corinthians 13:7).
 
  • Like
Reactions: seeker2122
Upvote 0

Bob Crowley

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
Dec 27, 2015
3,888
2,426
71
Logan City
✟971,188.00
Country
Australia
Gender
Male
Faith
Catholic
Marital Status
Married
God can be frustrating. He often doesn't seem to answer our prayers - at least not the way we would like them to be answered.

When the Israelites were slaves in Egypt, there were no doubt good and holy Israelites asking for deliverance.

How did God start working that one out? He allowed an Egyptian prince, namely Moses who had in turn been a Jewish baby rescued by Pharaoh's daughter, to kill an Egyptian overseer who was beating some Israelite slaves. He then had to flee into the desert, and he stayed there for 40 years.

He thought he was all washed up, although still carrying a concern for his own people. But God hadn't forgotten him. At the right time God called him through the burning bush.

But it took 40 years, and then another 40 just wandering through the desert.

I think for example that eventually Australia will have a revival (long overdue). I also believe, for reasons of my own (to a large extent based on comments by my old Protestant pastor) that it will start in the Catholic Church.

But I don't know when or where. So I'll just have to trust that it's going to happen, and leave it in God's hands.

Now back when I was in that pastor's (Presbyterian) church we often used to pray for revival, but nothing happened. Maybe we were setting our sights too low - we really meant we wanted OUR church to be the centre of such an event, consciously or unconsciously. I believe it will still happen but not in the way we were hoping.

If it does happen it will be a much bigger event, and it will be in God's time, not ours.

I'm currently wading through a book "Deep Calls to Deep" by David Foster OSB (Order of Saint Benedict) which is on prayer. He has one passage entitled "Let God be God".

Part of the passage reads "... We must let go of the ideas we impose on God, whether subconsciously or (with the best will in the world) consciously. The hardest ones are the unconscious ones: we have to be ready to let go of a lot of personal baggage to find ourselves in any kind of real relationship with God..."

Was the OP consciously or unconciously hoping God "... was working and going to grow our group and raise leaders, and continue to develop a core group and foundation here ..?"
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: seeker2122
Upvote 0

Maria Billingsley

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
Oct 7, 2018
11,231
9,280
65
Martinez
✟1,152,867.00
Country
United States
Gender
Female
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Married
So I had prayed about the members and believed they would be a foundational part of what God was building here and preparing....
I am highlighting this statement to point out something very important. Our "foundation" is Jesus Christ of Nazareth. His Kingdom is not of this world. Our Lord may be pointing you back to your first Love by removing those who were in the way. IMHO.
Blessings.
 
  • Informative
Reactions: seeker2122
Upvote 0

chevyontheriver

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
Sep 29, 2015
22,797
19,808
Flyoverland
✟1,367,214.00
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Faith
Catholic
Marital Status
Married
Politics
US-American-Solidarity
I do believe in prayer and I know it's not necessarily an "ask and you shall receive" sorta deal.
Prayer is about intimacy with God and not using it as some sort of genie in the bottle tactic.
Prayer sometimes is looked upon incorrectly as something you do as a petition to God to get an outcome you want.
The reality is we do not change God in and by prayer but it is we who come out of it changed.

Now onto my scenario.

I'm asking this now because I am able to look back in hindsight and see the outcome clearer than when I was
in the moment and hopeful. I realized that no matter how much I prayed, how earnest, sincere, and genuine it was, or
how faithful even of a person I could have been, nothing was going to change the outcome that came to be.

In other words, I'm a little disturbed that seeing and knowing what I know now, prayer wouldn't have made an ounce of
difference because it was never going to go that way.

Here's what I mean. A year ago, I believed God was doing something special in our little community/church. I was convicted
the Holy Spirit was working and going to grow our group and raise leaders, and continue to develop a core group and foundation
here. I'm going to use made up names for this situation.

I thought to myself if I can be faithful and obey God and follow Him, it is He that will build his church and His Spirit will move
and shape everything that is to happen. So I had prayed about the members and believed they would be a foundational part
of what God was building here and preparing us to do. I prayed for Sally, John, Bob, Jim, and Jane, and other people too.

It turns out few months later, Sally, John, Bob, Jim and Jane, Morris, Donny, and Patty were all moving away due to things we cannot change. Sally moved
hundreds of miles away to pursue further education. John also was assigned to another country from his workplace. Bob also
moved with his wife and kids back to another country to live with his parents. Jim and Jane also moved with their family back
to another country where they originally came from, same goes with Morris, Donny, and Patty. These weren't choices they had an option to stay
or not....they were things they HAD/MUST do and staying here was always just temporary.

Basically, 75% of everyone that used to be here had to move. It was either
work related, family related, or simply their time here was finished (contracts were up etc). So I realized now having known this,
when I look back to a year ago when I didn't know they were all going to move away anyways, I realized no matter how much I would
have prayed, fasted, been faithful to God, believed in the things God was doing here, none of it would have changed a thing because
they were ALL going to move away anyways.

It's not like they got sent away because I or we failed to be faithful and obedient, and failed to repent, fast, and give it our best. If we
had been the perfect Christian like Jesus for 1 year, that wouldn't have changed the fact they were all going to be moving away regardless.
So then prayer wouldn't have changed the outcome.

I just found that kinda interesting and depressing when looking back with the advantage of hindsight because you realize I was sort of
played like a fool not realizing that no matter how much I prayed or how good of believer I was, it was never in the cards and it was always
a dead end.

The group has nearly completely dismantled (I also left but by choice). There is a newer group of members that came in now and of course I know God has an infinite
plan so it's not like one possibility was foiled and now God's plan got screwed up. No. God obviously is in full control and nobody can thwart
his plans so He doesn't need us or me, for His plans to carry on, but He is obviously working still and doing something else (with the reset and
new members that have arrived). I just found this to be eye opening and confusing because it's not like a situation where it could have been
averted such as an accident, tragedy, mishap, poor decisions, timing, etc. No, these moves by Sally, John, Bob, Jim and Jane, Morris, Donny and Patty, were all cemented/arranged ahead of time and they weren't going to be here 100%...I just didn't know that specifically at the time, but I believed we were all here
to be the foundational members/leaders and build this church and raise the community to serve and worship God, be a family in Christ, and glorify Him
in our community.
Prayer is never wasted. We are to pray, not necessarily to have the future all figured out.

Perhaps your prayers resulted in an enhanced but temporary fellowship that prepared all of these people for something similar they could be a part of in their new locations. Your prayers did something good. Even if you don’t know yet what it was.
 
  • Like
Reactions: seeker2122
Upvote 0

seeker2122

Well-Known Member
Sep 29, 2022
402
104
36
Sarasota
✟45,976.00
Country
United States
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Single
Thank you for all the good and encouraging replies. Yes, my head knows that God is in full control and His plans always prevail. My heart struggles to understand and even accept the circumstances. It's probably a deep rooted pride issue with me because I do know I have an issue with pride (pride often means we want to/desire to do good for God but in OUR own way or the way we think is best).

A couple months later, a similar thing happened to me. I went to a new community, and miraculously got blessed by meeting someone that I became close with and made a strong connection with. I thought this was going to be the turning of events that would help me heal and move on, but sadly the exact same thing happened. This person also moved 2 months after I arrived and built a good connection. I couldn't understand and still don't understand what is the purpose and meaning of this? Of all the people who are here (in this new community) why would the one person I connected with be taken away. It was already in the cards for that person to move even before I arrived and met them. But of course I didn't know at the time so in those 2 months I was praying and believing this was going to be a great start of something and road back to healing. I look at this the exact same way. Whatever I prayed ultimately wasn't going to change the outcome. The person was never going to stay and be a big part of my life. They were already cemented to move before I had even arrived but all that time I was thinking my prayers meant something and that I had found a good relationship and connection, but now I realize, nothing I could have done was ever going to change the outcome.

It's very depressing to me and I probably am seeing it in the same neurotic way. I also tend to be neurotic (meaning stubborn and seeing things the same way and the only way as if there is no other possible angle to look at things).
 
Upvote 0