Is it God's will?

Vandaldog

New Member
Nov 24, 2016
4
1
64
Missouri
✟15,542.00
Faith
Baptist
Marital Status
Single
I'm a 56 year old man and I've dated a wonderful Christian lady for eight months, now, and it's been, easily, the absolute deepest, most mature and loving relationship I've ever known. We've brought each other more joy and fulfillment than either of us has ever known. We agree on all of the big issues in life -- spiritual, moral, political... you name it! We've spent a tremendous amount of time together in the short span that we've known each other and have never, not once, had an arguement or cross words. It's been, truly, the answer to both of our prayers and we've both professed as much to each other.

A month ago she believes God spoke to her heart and told her to put Him first, not me. I, of course, know that He speaks to we believers and have no problem, whatsoever, in taking a back seat to God. She has decided that she should draw closer Him. I agree, we ALL should make such an effort! The catch is that she has interpreted His word to mean that we are not meant to be together, wonderful as our relationship has been. Both of us are absolutely broken-hearted about this and there have been many tears. For the last month our only limited interaction has been through texts as its too painful for either of us to even speak on the phone to each other.

We are both product of divorce. One of the only things we have disagreed about is the fact that she believes that God spoke to her and, even though there was no abuse or infidelity, told her she was free to divorce her first husband. While I know she's asked and been forgiven for this sin she is still of the belief that God gave her permission to divorce. While no biblical scholar, I do know that God hates divorce and, in her situation, would never have given her such a word. This, of course, makes me question her discernment regarding the word she says she's been given regarding our relationship. I cannot imagine a loving God not smiling on what we have found together. As a matter of fact, I'm strongly of the belief that He was central to us finding each other -- that He brought us together.

My plea here is to find words of wisdom. Like her, I want God's will to be done. Unlike her, I believe His will is that we grow together in His word and, as we had begun discussing before He spoke to her, grow old with each other.

I will, of course, accept any help anyone here might be able to provide -- for or against my wishes. Biblical grounding in responses is most appreciated. Thank you for any insight as well as taking the time to read through my ramblings here. Prayers are most appreciated, as well!
 
Last edited:

blackribbon

Not a newbie
Dec 18, 2011
13,388
6,674
✟190,401.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
I have no idea what God has told your GF and what just may be personal fears talking. My advice to you is to pray that God either heal your heart or speak clearly to hers. There is no way to know what God is saying to her. Maybe He needs her to pick Him first at this moment in time. If she starts dating other people during your "apart" time, then you will know that she wasn't being honest. However, if she really does focus exclusively on God, then just turn to God.

Honestly, the fact you have never had a disagreement doesn't mean that you are perfect for each other...it might just mean that you are avoiding disagreements and just "stuffing" the feelings or that your relationship hasn't been tested yet. However, that also doesn't mean that this isn't a good fit. If she walked out on a marriage so easily, maybe God is saving your from a marriage that she is able to easily walk away from just based on her feelings. Sometimes we assume that the other person cares about us as much as we care about them...when really they are just going through the motions. I am sorry that this does hurt so much.
 
Upvote 0

Vandaldog

New Member
Nov 24, 2016
4
1
64
Missouri
✟15,542.00
Faith
Baptist
Marital Status
Single
Thank you, so much, for taking the time to respond to my plea.

I must step in to defend my girl. This is very real to her, of that I have no doubt. While I believe she has misinterpreted the word God has laid on her, there's absolutely no doubt in my mind that she is being genuine here. As a matter of fact, I can't help but admire her for her faithfulness to God with her response to what she thinks He's told her!

Also, she did not "walk out on a marriage so easily." She spent 28 miserable years with the man before she, wrongly, heard God tell her that she was released.
 
Upvote 0

blackribbon

Not a newbie
Dec 18, 2011
13,388
6,674
✟190,401.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
I don't know what you want to hear then.
She isn't "your girl" anymore. She broke up with you.

I hope that her marriage wasn't miserable for a full 28 years because I hope she actually married a man that she loved and intended to commit to for life. The simple fact is that she left. She didn't stay and figure out what it was that she needed to change to return the relationship back to what it started out to be. I am sure that he isn't faultless but even you said he didn't do any of things that make it "okay". Even you believe she mistook what she thought was the Word of God, so if she is doing that again, why do you assume she won't do it in the future too.

My advice to you is to simply honor her commitment to God and let her go. No reason to text and as you said, it extends the pain. Pray that God either changes your heart toward her and frees you from the pain or speaks to her to come back. But regardless, what is the purpose of even texting if she has said that she can't be with you. Yeah, it hurts and I am sorry that it hurts but if you respect her, then respect her decision and let her go.
 
Upvote 0

Evie1980

Learning to thrive
Sep 30, 2005
3,081
473
Where the Lord wants me
✟26,473.00
Faith
Presbyterian
Marital Status
Single
I am not sure. But I think, if she believes this is real for her and that it is what she desires (the closer relationship with God but without you) then you must honour her wishes regardless of the heart ache. As much as I would like to give you a definite answer either way, this is her decision and only she can change that through seeking wisdom and guidance. You may want to argue you the point of whether it is God's will or not but nothing I say here will alter the fact that her is her choice.

I hope and pray that both of you come to a place of healing and a place where you both can decide the next step in your relationship as either partners, friends or any other path you decide to take from here.
 
Upvote 0

Victor E.

Disciple of Christ
Site Supporter
Aug 3, 2016
2,712
404
31
U.S
✟201,211.00
Country
United States
Faith
Non-Denom
Marital Status
Married
I'm a 56 year old man and I've dated a wonderful Christian lady for eight months, now, and it's been, easily, the absolute deepest, most mature and loving relationship I've ever known. We've brought each other more joy and fulfillment than either of us has ever known. We agree on all of the big issues in life -- spiritual, moral, political... you name it! We've spent a tremendous amount of time together in the short span that we've known each other and have never, not once, had an arguement or cross words. It's been, truly, the answer to both of our prayers and we've both professed as much to each other.

A month ago she believes God spoke to her heart and told her to put Him first, not me. I, of course, know that He speaks to we believers and have no problem, whatsoever, in taking a back seat to God. She has decided that she should draw closer Him. I agree, we ALL should make such an effort! The catch is that she has interpreted His word to mean that we are not meant to be together, wonderful as our relationship has been. Both of us are absolutely broken-hearted about this and there have been many tears. For the last month our only limited interaction has been through texts as its too painful for either of us to even speak on the phone to each other.

We are both product of divorce. One of the only things we have disagreed about is the fact that she believes that God spoke to her and, even though there was no abuse or infidelity, told her she was free to divorce her first husband. While I know she's asked and been forgiven for this sin she is still of the belief that God gave her permission to divorce. While no biblical scholar, I do know that God hates divorce and, in her situation, would never have given her such a word. This, of course, makes me question her discernment regarding the word she says she's been given regarding our relationship. I cannot imagine a loving God not smiling on what we have found together. As a matter of fact, I'm strongly of the belief that He was central to us finding each other -- that He brought us together.

My plea here is to find words of wisdom. Like her, I want God's will to be done. Unlike her, I believe His will is that we grow together in His word and, as we had begun discussing before He spoke to her, grow old with each other.

I will, of course, accept any help anyone here might be able to provide -- for or against my wishes. Biblical grounding in responses is most appreciated. Thank you for any insight as well as taking the time to read through my ramblings here. Prayers are most appreciated, as well!

If you are married, it is not Gods will that you get a divorce (Mark 10:1-12) (it is her own emotions running amok), If you are not married, it is entirely possible and if you two were happy, she is putting God first in her life which is commendable (Romans 12:1-2). I would try and speak to her for her reasoning. If you are married, she is very unstable, and it is nothing you have done.
 
Upvote 0

Brigitte

Active Member
May 13, 2004
314
303
59
Maryland
✟12,560.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Single
If you doubt her discernment now then even if you get back together you'll doubt it again and again. This is not good for your relationship with her. If you ever get back together you'll need to discuss this. For the moment, take the opportunity that she is not seeing you to pray and seek God's guidance about this relationship.
 
Upvote 0

Vandaldog

New Member
Nov 24, 2016
4
1
64
Missouri
✟15,542.00
Faith
Baptist
Marital Status
Single
Thank you, everyone, for your replies. I spoke to her on the phone this morning for the first time in a month. I made my final plea for her to see a Christian counselor with me and she rejected it. She is sticking to the path she has started down and we are finished. This isn't my first heartache but hopefully it'll be my last. I'd rather break a half dozen ribs than go through this sort of anguish!
 
Upvote 0
This site stays free and accessible to all because of donations from people like you.
Consider making a one-time or monthly donation. We appreciate your support!
- Dan Doughty and Team Christian Forums
Jun 18, 2011
3,097
664
San Francisco Bay Area
✟65,034.00
Country
United States
Faith
Non-Denom
Marital Status
Divorced
Thank you, everyone, for your replies. I spoke to her on the phone this morning for the first time in a month. I made my final plea for her to see a Christian counselor with me and she rejected it. She is sticking to the path she has started down and we are finished. This isn't my first heartache but hopefully it'll be my last. I'd rather break a half dozen ribs than go through this sort of anguish!

Blackribbon is right. Yes,remarkable things has happened in the year of 2016. Before.I got married,for the first time,I was infatuated with a lady,whom I thought was perfect for me. Her name is "B".
She is smart,average looking,with a great figure,and wanted to be a Pediatrician. She did not care for me.But,I cared a lot for her. When she finally told me,"S....,you are a nice guy.You will make a good husband,and a great father.But,I have no feelings for you". I was very hurt.Then I started to pursue the "bad women". Because I thought and felt that,the women who,"had a lot going for themselves" did not want me. One day,I picked a fight with my first wife,after I saw a character,in a movie,that reminded my of my "first love". I was frustrated because my wife was not "B".
So,pray that God will heal you from this hurt.

I just thank God,that I did not turn out like this character,that I saw last week in Alfred Hitchcock's "Annabel".After "his girl" had broken up with him. After she got married,he would still send her flowers,and other gifts.He bought her a house,and had a picture of her in almost every room of the house.He had a beautiful dress,and shoes for her in the bedroom. If you can get a DVD of this episode,it will show you how potentially dangerous an obsession may become. I saw a part of my past in this movie.
 

Attachments

  • annabel.jpg
    annabel.jpg
    65.2 KB · Views: 16
  • Like
Reactions: dayhiker
Upvote 0
Jun 18, 2011
3,097
664
San Francisco Bay Area
✟65,034.00
Country
United States
Faith
Non-Denom
Marital Status
Divorced
I have no idea what God has told your GF and what just may be personal fears talking. My advice to you is to pray that God either heal your heart or speak clearly to hers. There is no way to know what God is saying to her. Maybe He needs her to pick Him first at this moment in time. If she starts dating other people during your "apart" time, then you will know that she wasn't being honest. However, if she really does focus exclusively on God, then just turn to God.

Honestly, the fact you have never had a disagreement doesn't mean that you are perfect for each other...it might just mean that you are avoiding disagreements and just "stuffing" the feelings or that your relationship hasn't been tested yet. However, that also doesn't mean that this isn't a good fit. If she walked out on a marriage so easily, maybe God is saving your from a marriage that she is able to easily walk away from just based on her feelings. Sometimes we assume that the other person cares about us as much as we care about them...when really they are just going through the motions. I am sorry that this does hurt so much.
Yes,I agree with you on this issue. It took me over five years to get over one break up.Shw was one of the reasons that I decided to join the U.S. Navy,and leave home. I thank God that I did not end up like this character in Alfred Hitchcock's "Annabel",which I saw for the first time last week.
 

Attachments

  • annabel.jpg
    annabel.jpg
    65.2 KB · Views: 11
Upvote 0

rubyinprogress

God's Daughter
Site Supporter
May 5, 2012
130
80
Texas
✟53,200.00
Faith
Non-Denom
Marital Status
Single
Thank you, so much, for taking the time to respond to my plea.

I must step in to defend my girl. This is very real to her, of that I have no doubt. While I believe she has misinterpreted the word God has laid on her, there's absolutely no doubt in my mind that she is being genuine here. As a matter of fact, I can't help but admire her for her faithfulness to God with her response to what she thinks He's told her!

Also, she did not "walk out on a marriage so easily." She spent 28 miserable years with the man before she, wrongly, heard God tell her that she was released.

I am very sorry for your heartache. My concern is that you think so little of her ability to hear and obey the Lord on her own. She alone must stand before God regarding her reasons for divorcing. If she spent "28 miserable years" with the man, there must have been something going on. God granted divorce because of the hardness of hearts. Was her husband so hard hearted that she was released to divorce? And why are you so certain it is she who misheard God about your relationship? My concern here is that you seem to want to pursue a woman for whom you lack enough respect to believe that she is just as likely to be right and to hear God correctly on these two matters as you are. I don't mean to sound harsh. It is so difficult to get across the sensitivity in the written word.
 
Upvote 0