Should I break up with him? I feel guilty, and don't know what God wants me to do.

cwtk001

New Member
Jan 22, 2009
2
0
✟7,612.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
In Relationship
I'm having a problem with my boyfriend of 2 years. He and I were best friends during high school, and when senior year ended he asked me to be his girlfriend. I felt kind of bad for him because he was a realllyyy nice guy, cute, and girls always took advantage of him. But we also spent most of our time together and I figured being his girlfriend wouldn't be much different. Also, we are both virgins and believe in no sex until marriage, so I thought it was fate. As college started I went through a really tough time and he was always there for me. He exceeded all my expectations and has always been the sweetest guy in the world to me. However, now the subject of marriage has come up. This is a totally different story. I do love him very much, but there are a few things about him that worry me. First of all, he has zero dedication to school. We're both supposed to be starting our junior year of college this fall, and he has 20 credits (he's still a freshman). He doesn't have a job, and he spends all his time playing video games. Also, he is two inches shorter than me which shouldn't bother me, but since his personality has gotten so submissive in the last year or so, it really does bother me now. His personality used to make up for the height difference, but now I feel like he's my little brother more than my boyfriend.
In the time we've been dating I've tried three times to break up with him. The first time he started crying and it freaked me out so much that I told him I didn't mean it. The second time he got really mad and told me that if I broke up with him I'd end up with some jerk who wouldn't respect me and wouldn't care about my plans to stay a virgin till marriage. I thought about it and I figured he was probably right, so I agreed to stay with him. The third time he actually pretended not to hear me, and I felt guilty and selfish and just ignored it too. I've tried SO hard to be happy with him, but I feel like we're not getting anywhere. Plus, at this rate I'll be graduated from college before he even finishes freshman year, and then the two inch height difference and submissive personality will have the added weight of me paying the bills and him coasting along at his own pace. I've talked to him about it, and he's even gone to the psychiatrist and gotten on anti-depressants. Nothing has changed, though. I explained to him that I feel like he's not as committed to the relationship as I am, because as much as he says he wants to marry me, he doesn't act like it. At first he said he was saving up for a ring, and then he bought a $1,000 flatscreen TV for his room on credit. I feel really bad for him and don't want to add to his problems by breaking up with him, and I feel like I owe it to him to stay with him, because he has invested so much in me. Every time I think about breaking up with him I think of our pet bunny, the fact that all our friends look up to our relationship as perfect, and how much we've talked about marriage.
I've prayed about this, and I told God that I would stay with my boyfriend until He gave me a clear sign that I should break up with him, and since then he's gotten kicked out of the university for low grades and still hasn't signed up for community college even though I filled out the application for him. I'm very frustrated, and half of me feels like I should stay with him and help him through this, but the other half feels like I've tried enough to no avail and should break it off now before it gets any harder.

Please, anyone's advice would be greatly appreciated. What would Jesus do?
 

c71clark

Junior Member
Jan 19, 2009
436
18
New York City, Ny
✟8,164.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Single
Politics
US-Libertarian
I think you were right before, and should have followed through with the first break-up attempt. This is not a man. This is a boy in a man's clothing. Until (if) he learns what it is to be a man, to take responsibility, to be a leader, to provide for and care for you, and all the other biblical instructions to men, he is not right for you.
You will prolong the pain, lengthen the healing process, and spend your days unhappy. This will detract from your walk with God.
YOU CAN NOT BE HIS MOTHER!! And that is what you are right now. Leave him, wash your hands of him. Pray for him. Come back in a year and see if he has turned the corner. In the meantime, open your eyes to other honorable men in your church, finish your schooling, live your life.
And I respect your decision to wait for marriage. You should consider being a spokesperson to other younger girls in your neighborhood!

IMHO
 
Upvote 0

AveLaw2011

Legen -- wait for it -- dary
Jun 1, 2008
89
12
✟259.00
Faith
Baptist
Marital Status
Private
Thanks. I broke it off today and I hope everything works out.

I wish you the best! You sound like a really nice girl and though ending the relationship was tough, judging from what you wrote, I am sure it was the best decision in the end.
 
Upvote 0

seekingvirtue

сладостная девушка
Jan 24, 2009
12
6
33
North America, at the moment
Visit site
✟7,658.00
Faith
Nazarene
Marital Status
Single
Politics
US-Constitution
Sadly, it doesn't sound like he was ready to be the man in your life, only the little boy. I don't think the height thing matters, but the personality problems surely do! How can he move into the next stages of your relationship when you're taking care of him? It's just like you said, a little brother, not a boyfriend or future husband. Maybe now that you've ended it, he'll see that he can't expect to coast aimlessly through life, forever being a child, and being a burden on you. You may have just helped both of you. God bless!
 
Upvote 0
This site stays free and accessible to all because of donations from people like you.
Consider making a one-time or monthly donation. We appreciate your support!
- Dan Doughty and Team Christian Forums

Peter_in_Christ

Disciple of Jesus Christ
Jan 10, 2004
130
13
✟15,530.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Single
cwtk001,

Did you know that the heart (emotional thinking) has a little brain, it communicates with the big brain in the head (logical thinking), and the heart brain overrules the head brain.

Follow your heart, which you are doing, and continue to seek God's guidance through prayer :)

A relationship requires responsibility from both sides... to grow, encourage, develop and etc... heading in the direction that honours God through our love for Jesus.

Peter

http://www.heartmath.org/research/overview.html
 
Last edited:
Upvote 0

Luther073082

κύριε ἐλέησον χριστὲ ἐλέησον
Apr 1, 2007
19,202
840
41
New Carlisle, IN
✟31,326.00
Faith
Lutheran
Marital Status
Married
Politics
US-Others
I would have given him an ultimatum about growing up and getting it together. Thats just me I just like to be very clear if I find things wrong.

However i don't think he would have changed that much in that short of time for you. He needs to show more dedication in his life to something other then entertainment. Either by working or going to school.

I'm curious as to how he bought a flat screen TV if he has no job, but either way he clearly valued it over getting you a ring.

So in the end I think I would have been very straightforward and clear about what he needed to do but in the end I think the result would have probably been the same.
 
Upvote 0