Yes, I'm a Christian nationalist — and you should be, too

[Michie]

I am a Christian nationalist.

In the aftermath of Charlie Kirk’s worshipful memorial service, the political left has predictably busied itself with slander, labeling the event “Christian Nationalism’s biggest moment” or even a Nazi rally.

Neither of these heinous descriptions are accurate. The Babylon Bee satirically mocked these claims with the headline “Nazi Rally Inspires Millions to Forgive And Love Their Enemies.” Indeed, Erika Kirk’s public and emotionally charged forgiveness of her husband’s murderer was one of the most powerful redemptive moments of our time.

It’s now undeniable that the Left aims to label everyday conservative Christians who are politically active as “Christian Nationalists.” Their exaggerated smear tactics are now widely recognized, consistently branding anyone who disagrees with them as Nazi, racist, homophobic, transphobic, “far right” and other melodramatic terms.

This lengthy list of slanderous accusations has lost its ability to intimidate. It has so altered and diluted the meaning of these terms that some on the political right are now proudly adopting them. The Left intends to attach a negative connotation to Christian nationalism and use it as a cudgel to slander Christians. We should embrace the term and welcome the challenge.

But what is Christian nationalism? Why does the Evangelical community seem so divided on this issue, with some condemning Christian nationalism as heresy and others embracing it as the conduit for the coming millennial Kingdom of Jesus Christ?



Continued below.

Yes, I'm a Christian nationalist — and you should be, too

We should embrace the term and welcome the challenge

www.christianpost.com

ETA:

Pope Leo criticizes Trump’s hardline immigration policies: ‘I don’t know if that’s pro-life’

Pope questions what it means to be ‘pro-life’ amid the ‘inhuman treatment of immigrants’ in the US

www.theguardian.com

 

[Maria Billingsley]

I am a Christian nationalist.

In the aftermath of Charlie Kirk’s worshipful memorial service, the political left has predictably busied itself with slander, labeling the event “Christian Nationalism’s biggest moment” or even a Nazi rally.

Neither of these heinous descriptions are accurate. The Babylon Bee satirically mocked these claims with the headline “Nazi Rally Inspires Millions to Forgive And Love Their Enemies.” Indeed, Erika Kirk’s public and emotionally charged forgiveness of her husband’s murderer was one of the most powerful redemptive moments of our time.

It’s now undeniable that the Left aims to label everyday conservative Christians who are politically active as “Christian Nationalists.” Their exaggerated smear tactics are now widely recognized, consistently branding anyone who disagrees with them as Nazi, racist, homophobic, transphobic, “far right” and other melodramatic terms.

This lengthy list of slanderous accusations has lost its ability to intimidate. It has so altered and diluted the meaning of these terms that some on the political right are now proudly adopting them. The Left intends to attach a negative connotation to Christian nationalism and use it as a cudgel to slander Christians. We should embrace the term and welcome the challenge.

But what is Christian nationalism? Why does the Evangelical community seem so divided on this issue, with some condemning Christian nationalism as heresy and others embracing it as the conduit for the coming millennial Kingdom of Jesus Christ?

Continued below.

Yes, I'm a Christian nationalist — and you should be, too

We should embrace the term and welcome the challenge

www.christianpost.com

I am registering my complaint that this article is woefully misleading and dangerous . Christian Nationalism is not in the will of the Father. One just needs to go back to basics and read His words in scripture. Even the Pope is against Christian Nationalism.
Be blessed.

 

[Michie]

I am registering my complaint that this article is woefully misleading and dangerous . Christian Nationalism is not in the will of the Father. One just needs to go back to basics and read His words in scripture. Even the Pope is against Christian Nationalism.
Be blessed.

I hope you realize not everything I post means I agree with it. Been that way for years. I thought I should bring that up since you mentioned the Pope. These topics are meant for reading and discussion.

 

[FAITH-IN-HIM]

I am a Christian nationalist.

In the aftermath of Charlie Kirk’s worshipful memorial service, the political left has predictably busied itself with slander, labeling the event “Christian Nationalism’s biggest moment” or even a Nazi rally.

Neither of these heinous descriptions are accurate. The Babylon Bee satirically mocked these claims with the headline “Nazi Rally Inspires Millions to Forgive And Love Their Enemies.” Indeed, Erika Kirk’s public and emotionally charged forgiveness of her husband’s murderer was one of the most powerful redemptive moments of our time.

It’s now undeniable that the Left aims to label everyday conservative Christians who are politically active as “Christian Nationalists.” Their exaggerated smear tactics are now widely recognized, consistently branding anyone who disagrees with them as Nazi, racist, homophobic, transphobic, “far right” and other melodramatic terms.

This lengthy list of slanderous accusations has lost its ability to intimidate. It has so altered and diluted the meaning of these terms that some on the political right are now proudly adopting them. The Left intends to attach a negative connotation to Christian nationalism and use it as a cudgel to slander Christians. We should embrace the term and welcome the challenge.

But what is Christian nationalism? Why does the Evangelical community seem so divided on this issue, with some condemning Christian nationalism as heresy and others embracing it as the conduit for the coming millennial Kingdom of Jesus Christ?

Continued below.

Yes, I'm a Christian nationalist — and you should be, too

We should embrace the term and welcome the challenge

www.christianpost.com

Jesus taught, “No one can serve two masters. Either you will hate the one and love the other, or you will be devoted to the one and despise the other. You cannot serve both God and money.”

Is another argument against Christian nationalism needed? I don’t think so!

 

[Maria Billingsley]

I hope you realize not everything I post means I agree with it. Been that way for years. I thought I should bring that up since you mentioned the Pope. These topics are meant for reading and discussion.

Yes I know. My complaint is not with you, it is with the article. Maybe consider posting what the Pope said outside his summer residence on Tuesday about this administration?

 

[Michie]

Jesus taught, “No one can serve two masters. Either you will hate the one and love the other, or you will be devoted to the one and despise the other. You cannot serve both God and money.”

Is another argument against Christian nationalism needed? I don’t think so!

Ignore it then. Many do.

 

[Pepperdoodle]

Yes I know. My complaint is not with you, it is with the article. Maybe consider posting what the Pope said outside his summer residence on Tuesday about this administration?

Are you catholic?
If not, why would you heed what their leader says?

Did you support the Biden administration?

 

[Michie]

The Trump administration has again found itself tussling with a pope.

Press secretary Karoline Leavitt on Wednesday pushed back on Pope Leo XIV’s suggestion Tuesday that people who support the “inhuman treatment of immigrants in the United States” may not be “pro life.”

Continued below.

https://www.politico.com/news/2025/10/01/white-house-pushes-back-on-pope-leos-statement-that-immigrants-are-subject-to-inhuman-treatment-in-the-u-s-00590470

 

[Maria Billingsley]

Are you catholic?
If not, why would you heed what their leader says?

Did you support the Biden administration?

You keep asking me personal questions . Please stop.

 

[Michie]

Why MAGA Christianity should fear the new pope

(RNS) — Pope Leo’s election also offers hope, because he reminds the world that religious conviction need not serve nationalist power.

religionnews.com

 

[FAITH-IN-HIM]

Ignore it then. Many do.

Over the past three to four decades, Christians in the United States have observed a notable shift within evangelical Christianity toward increased political engagement, resulting in political identity often superseding the faith-based identity centered on following Jesus Christ. Throughout this period, individuals dedicated to traditional Christian values typically refrained from critiquing those who appeared to prioritize political allegiance above their religious convictions.

But today it is clear that Christians have frequently overlooked the complex relationship between Christian churches and the Republican Party, as well as African American churches and the Democratic Party. What was once regarded as a background noise has evolved into a central issue. At present, some Christians actively promote Christian nationalism from the pulpit, contribute articles to Christian publications, and pastors are increasingly announcing, "I love Jesus and America; what is wrong with that?"

It is essential to address such pervasive theological ideology with seriousness and to endeavor to remove them from our congregations. Currently, many churches devote substantial attention to opposing the political left and its agenda for social change. Nonetheless, I maintain that it is essential for Christians to prioritize preserving the theological integrity of their own congregations, addressing doctrinal issues internally before focusing on broader outreach and evangelism efforts.

 

[FAITH-IN-HIM]

Are you catholic?
If not, why would you heed what their leader says?

Did you support the Biden administration?

How is any of this connected to Christian nationalism being unbiblical?

 

[Pepperdoodle]

You keep asking me personal questions . Please stop.

You're on a faith based forum sharing faith based opinions, so talking about where someone comes from in their faith they share about isn't wrong or personal, since we shouldn't hide it under a buschel..."Nor do people light a lamp and put it under a basket, but on a stand, and it gives light to all in the house." Matt 5:15.
Instead of seeming sensitive about it, Scripture says in 1 Pet 3:15 "always being prepared to make a defense to anyone who asks you for a reason for the hope that is in you; yet do it with gentleness and respect".
Anyone asking that isn't getting personal. It's not like we're asking for your social security number, that would be personal. Asking about one's faith on a faith based forum should be ok. So don't be offended by those type of questions.
As I told you yesterday, I'm of no denomination either.
Just asking since you said yesterday you are of no denomination also.
It doesn't matter what the catholic religion's leader says.
All that matters at the end of each day is what does God and the principles in His word say.

On the political side of this forum, to ask you "Did you support the Biden administration?" isn't personal or wrong either due to that fact.
To Michie you said in part "...about this administration?"
So to ask if you supported the Biden administration is inline with what you mentioned.
Can you answer the question please?

 

[Maria Billingsley]

You're on a faith based forum sharing faith based opinions, so talking about where someone comes from in their faith they share about isn't wrong or personal, since we shouldn't hide it under a buschel..."Nor do people light a lamp and put it under a basket, but on a stand, and it gives light to all in the house." Matt 5:15.
Instead of seeming sensitive about it, Scripture says in 1 Pet 3:15 "always being prepared to make a defense to anyone who asks you for a reason for the hope that is in you; yet do it with gentleness and respect".
Anyone asking that isn't getting personal. It's not like we're asking for your social security number, that would be personal. Asking about one's faith on a faith based forum should be ok. So don't be offended by those type of questions.
As I told you yesterday, I'm of no denomination either.
Just asking since you said yesterday you are of no denomination also.
It doesn't matter what the catholic religion's leader says.
All that matters at the end of each day is what does God and the principles in His word say.

On the political side of this forum, to ask you "Did you support the Biden administration?" isn't personal or wrong either due to that fact.
To Michie you said in part "...about this administration?"
So to ask if you supported the Biden administration is inline with what you mentioned.
Can you answer the question please?

Now you are trolling.

 

[Pepperdoodle]

Now you are trolling.

No I'm not.
Stop mislabeling me just because you don't agree with some of my replies.
That is misrepresenting me because you don't want to answer simple questions.

 

[Michie]

No I'm not.
Stop mislabeling me just because you don't agree with some of my replies.
That is misrepresenting me because you don't want to answer simple questions.

I believe she brought up the Pope’s opinion because I am Catholic.

 

[Richard T]

How is any of this connected to Christian nationalism being unbiblical?

The author makes a good point. It is great to support your nation but that one does not need to be extreme about it. A sort of different, moderate version of what Christian nationalism is.

 

[rebornfree]

In the link which Michie provided, the photo showed a cross with the Stars and Stripes on it. That really bothers me, just as it would if it was my own country's, or any other nation's, flag. Has anyone read The Screwtape Letters by C S Lewis? In it a senior devil is coaching a junior one. If I remember rightly, one of the things he suggests is to get Christians to link their faith to another thing, so they talk about 'Christianity and....'. He points out that it doesn't really matter what the 'and' is, as long as it gets the person away from focusing on Christ.

I understand, Michie, that you are not necessarily supporting the views in the articles you post.