Nonsense. These are trained professionals who do their jobs. Whether they are transgendered or not doesn't affect their performance.
That's not entirely true...
So if we unpack it by looking at transgender individual (both without, and with affirming care), and look at the prevalence of certain mental health situations
Per the NIH, without affirming care:
- Anxiety disorders: Around 40-60% of transgender individuals report experiencing anxiety, compared to about 14% of the general U.S. adult population.
- Depression: Around 30-50% of transgender people have been diagnosed with or experienced major depressive episodes, versus 7-10% in the general population.
- Suicidal ideation: About 40% of transgender adults report having attempted suicide at some point in their lives, compared to roughly 4.6% in the general U.S. population.
With affirming care (per JAMA, 2023 American Journal of Psychiatry, and the NIH)
Condition | General Population | Trans people with affirming care |
---|
Depression (past year prevalence) | ~7–10% | ~19–31% |
Anxiety disorders | ~14% | ~28–32% |
Suicidal ideation | ~4.6% | ~22–28% |
So even for people who've received, what is currently considered the best treatment option available, by the advocates, we're still talking about
Triple the rates of depression
Double the rates of anxiety disorders
5x the rate of suicidal ideation
That is a cause for concern...
Not to mention, those things, as stand-alone diagnoses, can be disqualifying measures on their own in many cases.
Condition | Generally Disqualifying? | Waiver Possible? |
---|
Anxiety disorders | Yes — if current or recent, or if it required medication/therapy. Some isolated, resolved cases may be waiverable. | Sometimes, if mild, well-documented as resolved, and no current symptoms. |
Depressive disorders | Yes — especially if there’s a history of major depressive disorder, multiple episodes, hospitalization, or recent symptoms. | Sometimes, for mild, situational, well-resolved cases with good documentation. |
Suicidal ideation or attempts | Yes — a history of suicidal thoughts or behaviors is typically a hard disqualifier. | Very rarely, and only in exceptional, historic, well-treated, and documented cases, usually with strong medical endorsements. |