I understand what you said. But you did not answer my question: Is the scapula part of the body or part of the leg?
Um..
OK, wow...
Yes, I did answer your question - I answered it directly:
"part of the shoulder girdle, which is/are the bone(s) to which the upper forelimb bone articulates."
I don't know how else to answer that question. It is not part of the body OR the limb, it is the bone that articulates with the upper limb bone and IN SOME CASES articulates with the body. I am having a hard time understanding how a person with your claimed background:
Biography Geologist.
A YEC but work with OE models. No contradiction at all.
Fundamentalist.
Interests build conceptual models
Occupation Research and teaching
is having such a hard time with this - is your difficulty real or are you just out to antagonize? We're only talking about one bone here...
If it is part of the body, then you don't have an argument.
It is not part of the body - if by part of the body you mean part of the axial skeleton. Considering how this is going, I see a 'but if it is not part of the body, how do we have one?' coming...
How does the scapula connected to other bones of the body is not part of the question.
Then you don't really know what questions to ask.
As naive as I am, I do feel my shoulder bone belongs to my body rather than being a part of my arm. So, my arm is attached to my body by a bone link, not a muscle link.
YOURS is, yes. I never said otherwise, which means you are just really having a hard time here (on purpose?). Your scapula articulates with both the humerus (sort of) and the clavicle, the clavicle articulates with the sternum.
Elephants, deer, rhinos, bison, bears, etc. HAVE NO CLAVICLE, thus, there is NO bony attachments between their forelimbs and their body.
My point was that even in us, when we DO have a clavicle, and a clavicle that DOES attach to the body, our scapula can move all over the place - yet we can support our weight just fine.
Menton stepped in it.