Let's say I murder a person. I am genuinely sorry, and ask God to forgive me. Is God's forgiveness contingent on me turning myself in and facing the State-sanctioned consequences for my actions? What are people's thoughts on this?
Starting today August 7th, 2024, in order to post in the Married Couples, Courting Couples, or Singles forums, you will not be allowed to post if you have your Marital status designated as private. Announcements will be made in the respective forums as well but please note that if yours is currently listed as Private, you will need to submit a ticket in the Support Area to have yours changed.
Let's say I murder a person. I am genuinely sorry, and ask God to forgive me. Is God's forgiveness contingent on me turning myself in and facing the State-sanctioned consequences for my actions? What are people's thoughts on this?
This logic is a little circuitous. Please bear with me.
Of course you can be forgiven for murder by God. Look at King David who was as guilty as any for maneuvering to cause the death of Bathsheba's husband.
The question is whether or not it is a sin to not turn ones self in.
If it is a sin and you deny that, then you are not forgiven.
If governments are, indeed, ordained by God to rule over us, then failure to obey the laws is, in effect, a sin against God. The U.S. government, in its God ordained wisdom, has decided that we have a right to not incriminate ourselves. If we turn ourselves in we are definitely incriminating ourselves. We, therefore are not required to turn ourselves in, and thus are not sinning.
If our government said that we had to incriminate ourselves then I would say otherwise.
Let's say I murder a person. I am genuinely sorry, and ask God to forgive me. Is God's forgiveness contingent on me turning myself in and facing the State-sanctioned consequences for my actions? What are people's thoughts on this?
I believe I read, that in the case of going to Cofession, the Priest has to be certain the murderer is handling the victims responsibilities in regards to minor children being supported or the bills being paid by the murderer. Otherwise, it is considered that the sin is on going. Therefore the Priest will not exonerate or offer penance.
We are called to do our penance on earth.
If we ask, I am sure we are forgiven, yet we will suffer the consequences in the second life when God expiates us of our sins and fleshly hold we have with our sins...
In purgatory.
The greater the crime that was left without penance on earth, the longer in purgation.
Other than that, I am not God so I will not surmise to know all of it. Just what has been taught.
The Apostles taught penance.
Peace!
If governments are, indeed, ordained by God to rule over us, then failure to obey the laws is, in effect, a sin against God. The U.S. government, in its God ordained wisdom, has decided that we have a right to not incriminate ourselves. If we turn ourselves in we are definitely incriminating ourselves. We, therefore are not required to turn ourselves in, and thus are not sinning.
If our government said that we had to incriminate ourselves then I would say otherwise.
This is confusing what is legal with what is moral. There are any number of things that are legal (to take an extreme example, let's say abortion) that are sinful.
In any event, it is not illegal to incriminate yourself. Lots of people plead guilty to charges against themselves. It is only illegal to be compelled to incriminate yourself.
Let's say I murder a person. I am genuinely sorry, and ask God to forgive me. Is God's forgiveness contingent on me turning myself in and facing the State-sanctioned consequences for my actions? What are people's thoughts on this?
I think if you are truely sorry, then that genuine sorrow would lead to one owning up. Not necessarily turning yourself in, but caring for the responsibilities of the victim, otherwise, neglecting to do so would mean being in perpetual sin, ie unable to obtain the state of grace because the sin continues.God is willing to forgive every sin ever committed. That is what Jesus shed blood does for us. His blood atones every sin. The question therefore should not be directed at God, but should be directed at the sinner, since the only sin that God does not forgive is the unrepented sin - or in other words, "blasphemy of the Holy Spirit".
In Christ
I think if you are truely sorry, then that genuine sorrow would lead to one owning up. Not necessarily turning yourself in, but caring for the responsibilities of the victim, otherwise, neglecting to do so would mean being in perpetual sin, ie unable to obtain the state of grace because the sin continues.
There is a difference between repenting and feeling guilty.
I think if you cannot forgive yourself, due to the consequences and loose ends, it is a very strong signal that the requirements for repentence have not been met. Otherwise, it just smacks of protestant relativism.
So, allow the sins to continue and build and ruin many more lives?
I was listening to a Priest on Catholic radio a couple days ago, he stated that the priest may not ask someone to turn themselves in to the authorities.You misunderstand me.
Whatever the priest says to do for penance, do. That may include turning oneself in. Depending on the circumstances it may not.
The motive of most victims is for vengeance, not for things such as; reparations, support of survivors, or an opportunity for that most difficult of things, forgiveness.
If you think turning yourself in is an opportunity for any of those, except possibly forgiveness, you are mistaken. But, if the priest thinks it appropriate to turn oneself in, you must do so.
Vengeance is an ugly thing. It involves and eye for an eye, a tooth for a tooth, a death for a death. How many lives has the desire for vengeance ruined?
What if the act was murder under the law but is justified on moral grounds? What if I murdered a Hitler or Stalin to stop their reprehensible acts? Should I then turn myself in? Would I have sinned in not doing so?
Each case must be heard by the priest in confession and a decision made as what to do. He will decide where the greater good lays.
For those who do not have the Catholic Church, they must pray for guidance from the Holy Spirit.
</IMG></IMG>
Are you sure? I mean, was _he_sure? I'd have thought priests could _ask_whatever they liked, but it would be up to the guilty party as to what they did. Seal-of-confession-wise, my understanding is priests can't say anything themselves, _unless_ they are very convinced some terrible crime is going to be committed again. But as a general rule, they are not compellable.I was listening to a Priest on Catholic radio a couple days ago, he stated that the priest may not ask someone to turn themselves in to the authorities.
Foundthelight said: What if the act was murder under the law but is justified on moral grounds? What if I murdered a Hitler or Stalin to stop their reprehensible acts? Should I then turn myself in? Would I have sinned in not doing so?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?