expos4ever
Well-Known Member
- Oct 22, 2008
- 11,257
- 6,246
- Country
- Canada
- Gender
- Male
- Faith
- Christian
- Marital Status
- Private
Some posters here seem to think that bringing up the matter of Mr. Trump's fitness is a cheap trick, or 'whataboutism'.
The matter of Mr. Trump's competence certainly is relevant- as should be clear. The logic here is simple, clear, and irrefutable:
1. The issue of Mr. Biden's fitness to be President was raised;
2. The claim is made that Mr. Biden will be 'un-electable' if the voters deem him to be 'unfit' to serve.
3. It is obvious that finding a counterexample - a case of a person being elected despite seeming to be unfit - is a relevant contribution to this line of argument. How could it possibly not be relevant? If I say 'Mr. X cannot be elected because he has characteristic Y', even an 8-year old will know that if there is an historical example of a Mr. Z being elected despite having characteristic Y, this is directly relevant to the claim about Mr. X.
4. Mr. Trump is just such an example, or at least a strong case can be made to this effect.
People have to learn to take their lumps - you may not like that someone has brought in Mr. Trump, but you brought it on yourselves by connecting the elect-ability of Mr. Biden to matters of his 'fitness' to serve.
The matter of Mr. Trump's competence certainly is relevant- as should be clear. The logic here is simple, clear, and irrefutable:
1. The issue of Mr. Biden's fitness to be President was raised;
2. The claim is made that Mr. Biden will be 'un-electable' if the voters deem him to be 'unfit' to serve.
3. It is obvious that finding a counterexample - a case of a person being elected despite seeming to be unfit - is a relevant contribution to this line of argument. How could it possibly not be relevant? If I say 'Mr. X cannot be elected because he has characteristic Y', even an 8-year old will know that if there is an historical example of a Mr. Z being elected despite having characteristic Y, this is directly relevant to the claim about Mr. X.
4. Mr. Trump is just such an example, or at least a strong case can be made to this effect.
People have to learn to take their lumps - you may not like that someone has brought in Mr. Trump, but you brought it on yourselves by connecting the elect-ability of Mr. Biden to matters of his 'fitness' to serve.
Upvote
0