• Starting today August 7th, 2024, in order to post in the Married Couples, Courting Couples, or Singles forums, you will not be allowed to post if you have your Marital status designated as private. Announcements will be made in the respective forums as well but please note that if yours is currently listed as Private, you will need to submit a ticket in the Support Area to have yours changed.

The Proposal

Moonrise Lu

Newbie
Jul 23, 2014
149
42
Texas
✟24,437.00
Country
United States
Gender
Female
Faith
Non-Denom
Marital Status
Married
Ladies, how did your husband propose? Men, how did you propose?

Bonus Question: When you were proposed to, did you see it coming or was it a complete surprise?
My boyfriend and I have been discussing marriage a lot recently, so I feel like when he proposes I will be expecting it, to a degree. I can't imagine I'll be like those women in proposal videos who are so shocked and were totally blindsided by it XD. Just wondering, was it something you expected or was it a surprise? I wanna know how it all went down :3
 

Inkachu

Bursting with fruit flavor!
Jan 31, 2008
35,357
4,220
Somewhere between Rivendell and Rohan
✟77,996.00
Gender
Female
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Married
Politics
US-Others
I knew my husband was going to propose, I just didn't know exactly when or how. We knew from the moment we met that we were going to get married, so in that way it was not a surprise :)

He had planned several, elaborate, romantic proposals that, for one reason or another, kept falling through. I felt so awful when I learned about his ideas later on, they were SO amazing and he had worked so hard! Anyway, we had spent a day out together, and I knew he'd had a proposal planned that day (I could just tell lol) and we weren't able to get into this particular restaurant where I knew he'd planned it, we were headed home and we were both pretty depressed at that point. We still hadn't eaten, so we stopped at some random steakhouse that we saw. He still got me, as he'd managed to slip away and ask the staff to help out without me noticing. They brought a dessert plate with my ring in the center and "will you marry me" written in chocolate drizzle lol.

It's still kind of sad to think of the grand, romantic events he had planned, but the thing is, he's a romantic person anyway, so the romance hasn't ended after the wedding :) He's the sort of man who still enjoys plotting and planning romantic surprises, and I love it!
 
Upvote 0

turkle

Blessed
Jan 25, 2004
918
642
✟267,648.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Married
Mine was similar to Inkachu. I knew that he wanted to marry me. He suddenly proposed over a wonderful Italian dinner. He later apologized, saying that he wanted to do something special, but he just couldn't wait one more minute to ask me. I loved the way it happened.

Frankly, I think the proposal videos are a horrible disservice to people. I am sure that most of them are quite staged, since how is someone going to explain the setup and camera before the proposal. These videos set people up for extremely high expectations, and when the actual proposal doesn't happen according to that expectation, there is disappointment. A proposal, no matter how it is done, is such a wonderful, beautiful thing. I loved that my husband could not contain himself any more.
 
Upvote 0

DZoolander

Persnickety Member
Apr 24, 2007
7,279
2,114
Far far away
✟127,634.00
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Faith
Lutheran
Marital Status
Married
Politics
US-Libertarian
Ladies, how did your husband propose? Men, how did you propose?

Bonus Question: When you were proposed to, did you see it coming or was it a complete surprise?
My boyfriend and I have been discussing marriage a lot recently, so I feel like when he proposes I will be expecting it, to a degree. I can't imagine I'll be like those women in proposal videos who are so shocked and were totally blindsided by it XD. Just wondering, was it something you expected or was it a surprise? I wanna know how it all went down :3

Well, we'd already discussed it prior to actually becoming engaged, had gone out and picked/bought the rings, etc...so she knew the actual proposal was coming.. It was just a matter of "when?"

...which posed a bit of a problem for me - because she knew where the ring was. Every time we went any place special - I'd catch her checking the place where the box was kept...cuz she's like that...lol

We went on a cruise to the Bahamas one year with her family - and I decided that would be as good a time as any. The issue then was how to surreptitiously get the ring and bring it along without her knowing it. So I bought a different box and had her sister hold on to it.

The night I decided to propose - we were having a good time with her sisters until pretty late. Her sisters knew I was going to do it. I asked her if she wanted to go for a walk - and since she was having such a good time with the family she's like "Nah, later". Bah. Her sisters then came to the rescue and said "We're really tired - so we're going to bed".

Took her to a lounge, played a little piano, then asked her. :) She was totally shocked...and said she didn't expect it to be this time..."because she'd checked and saw the box hadn't moved back home".

;)
 
Upvote 0

NothingIsImpossible

Well-Known Member
May 22, 2015
5,618
3,253
✟289,942.00
Gender
Male
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Married
Well my original plan was to fly to my wifes country and as she met me at the doors to leave (your not allowed inside unless your flying) I would pretend I tripped and fell on my knee. Then when she went to help me up I'd life my hand up and propose to her ring and all.

But since things don't always go as planned (and because of ticket prices) I proposed online. Wasn't a dream proposal but she still loved it because I spilled out my heart to her. Granted this came after fasting to get Gods answer about it all first since she was overseas. I do plan on surprising her on one of our anniversaries with a diamond ring. Shes not into fancy jewelry or diamonds but I know she would feel so special since she to is priceless.
 
Upvote 0

LinkH

Regular Member
Jun 19, 2006
8,602
671
✟58,853.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Married
I was living in Indonesia where my wife was from. There, you take other people out for your birthday and treat, so I told her I wanted her to dress up nice to take her out for my birthday. I wore a suit.

Many months before, I'd gone to this Lebanese restaurant outside this complex that had a hotel, nice restaurants, and lots of other places in it, and the garden and pool outside were beautiful. Jakarta is a concrete jungle and there aren't a lot of pretty places in the city, not in the part I lived in. (The country has lots of beautiful locations.) So I made a mental note of the place.

She didn't care for Lebanese food, so I took her to a buffet right by the garden. We were both dressed up. I hate all I could with the ring burning a hole in my pocket.

I took her outside. It had rained outside and there was a covered tile sidewalk out there. A pool of rainwater had formed. I took her to the garden, got on one knee and washed her feet. She asked what I was doing. I told her in Indonesian, "What I do you do not know, but you will know later", paraphrasing the words of Christ in John 13 the best I could in her language.

Then I told her what she meant to me and proposed. They don't do the on-one-knee proposals there, so she'd never seen anything like it. She kept saying, "That's wonderful" instead of answering my question as she cried and tried to catch her breath. Then she said of course she'd marry me.

But in her country, you get engaged by going to meet the parents. So I road a PELNI ship. It's like a refugee ship, overloaded, with people packed in like sardines carrying black garbage bags full of stuff. You have to barely squeeze through to go get water or food. Food is a scoop of rice, cabbage soup, and a boiled egg, so you have to bring snacks or buy snacks or ramen noodles on the boat. I think it was two or three days. Water fills up the bathroom and women invade the men's room rather than fight through the crowd to get the women's. The ships crew lock the fire safety doors, while people smoke though they aren't supposed to in the crowded room you are crammed in. Loud Muslims talk really loud to make sure everyone is awake before the call to prayer, then you see the same people somehow able to sleep when you can't.

Then I got there, and the family spoke Batak. I thought I'd be able to know what was going on a bit because I'd learned some Indonesian. But they were willing to accept me as family, so that was good. We decided on what we were going to do and got married when we could book the facilities. Fortunately, Muslims don't like to marry during Rahmadan, so we were able to book a place for the wedding party in a hotel. As usual, there a small crowd showed for the ceremony but a large crowd came for the food. The wedding party was delayed, and my Muslim coworkers sure tore up the buffet we provided for them when we did open the doors and start the festivities.
 
Upvote 0

HerCrazierHalf

closet atheist
Aug 11, 2014
293
74
SoCal, US
✟36,773.00
Gender
Male
Faith
Agnostic
Marital Status
Married
Ladies, how did your husband propose? Men, how did you propose?

Bonus Question: When you were proposed to, did you see it coming or was it a complete surprise?
My boyfriend and I have been discussing marriage a lot recently, so I feel like when he proposes I will be expecting it, to a degree. I can't imagine I'll be like those women in proposal videos who are so shocked and were totally blindsided by it XD. Just wondering, was it something you expected or was it a surprise? I wanna know how it all went down :3

Well, for me proposing to my wife was not as grand an event as one of my friends but I guess it works anyways. When I decided that I was going to pop the question I realized I had a big issue. I didn't know her ring size. So, I had to get rather creative and tease her about an old class ring she had to find out if it fit or not. It didn't so I quietly pocketed the ring, got the size, and went a size up and ordered a custom made stone ring from some guy next to a cornfield in Idaho.

Over the following weeks I scoped out a few locations and tried to come up with some sort of poetic speech about love and stuff.

I had the ring on me for a few weeks because something kept popping up. Finally, we happened to be hanging out near spot I previously chose and there was no one's birthday or anything that is be stepping on. On the way home from our day out I pulled into a scenic area and asked her to walk with me so we could take in the view (we were on a hill).

We got to the spot overlooking the city and suddenly my speech turned into incoherent ramblings. I pointed out something behind us and as she was distracted I grabbed the ring box and hid it behind me. Then when she turned around I got on my knee, opened the box, and popped question. To my surprise she said yes pretty quickly.

She told me that she didn't know that I liked her that much and was surprised I proposed. What shocked me was that it took me weeks upon weeks of research and careful thought before I decided to propose. It took her under 20 seconds.
 
Upvote 0

ValleyGal

Well-Known Member
Dec 19, 2012
5,775
1,823
✟129,255.00
Country
Canada
Gender
Female
Faith
Anabaptist
Marital Status
Divorced
My husband and I had discussed marriage, but I would not commit until we met in person. I flew out to his city and one evening he brought out a basin of hot water and a towel, he got down on the floor - both knees, not just one - and he discussed how Jesus served his disciples, his friends, and he wanted to spend the rest of his life serving me, emulating the relationship between Christ and the church. As he spoke, he washed my feet. I said yes, and then we prayed together. It was beautiful, unforgettable... and he has lived up to his word by being the best friend and husband any woman could ever want!
 
Upvote 0