• Starting today August 7th, 2024, in order to post in the Married Couples, Courting Couples, or Singles forums, you will not be allowed to post if you have your Marital status designated as private. Announcements will be made in the respective forums as well but please note that if yours is currently listed as Private, you will need to submit a ticket in the Support Area to have yours changed.

The Assumption of Mary

Zeek

Follower of Messiah, Israel advocate and Zionist
Nov 8, 2010
2,888
217
England
✟19,164.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Private

I'm afraid that is incorrect...I don't know where you get your information.
The Jews NEVER replaced all references to G-d with the word Adonai...what they did was when YHVH (Yahweh or Jehovah) was written, they copied it exactly as written...to do less would be to alter the Word of G-d...but when it came to reading aloud the word YHVH they would substitute it with the word Adonai. When I am with Orthodox Jews, and even secular Jews, I tend to use the word HaShem (the name) as even using the word Adonai can seem unrighteous outside of a religious function.

When you look at the Greek, you see a distinction between the word Kurios and Theos...Kurios was not a substitution for Theos....as I have shown before using the Hebrew, no written word was ever substituted, so your argument is invalid.



Oh I see...it's the old 'corrupted translation argument now'

In Hebrew the word 'magnify' comes from translating the root word 'gadal'...it can also mean 'promote', which in this day and age I think gives a better sense of the intent....so how you reason that I use a corrupted translation is worrying.






I think I understand what you are saying....and it could well be that we have lost something in translation regarding the depth of grace and favour that G-d placed on Mary, and the complete uniqueness of her calling.



Now you've lost me. Mary was not pre-saved or sinless....in her unique position, her Son was also her Saviour.



AND you cannot deny it, because Elijah stood in the glorified body , and Moses when Peter, James and John saw them with Jesus.

HOW?

God works out side of time.
Stop putting Him in human boxes.

So are you confident that both Moses and Elijah had ressurected bodies, and that what happened wasn't part of a vision that Peter, James and John were granted to see?

It's funny so telling me not to put G-d in human boxes....because so much of what I disagree with amongst my Catholoic and Orthodox friends relies almost wholly on man-made boxes.




I guess I'm a bit thick sometimes.



I really don't know what you mean about envy...who's envious and why?

No I am not accusing Mary of exalting herself....that has to be a daft question....I am trying to show that others(those that initiated these doctrines) have exalted her to a position she cannot possible hold, and in doing so have created a different Mary to the woman described in Scripture....one that emerges from the futility of darkened minds...eg. Bad teaching, poor theology, unbiblical reasoning.


__________________

Now my friend...I don't want you to feel you are wasting your time here...and if you do, I'm sure you are free to dis-engage at any time...I won't be offended, honest. If you produce a good argument, I will give it my utmost consideration...but if you produce weak arguments and shaky facts, then I will say so...surely that is fair?

What I was trying to show you by using this verse (and it would need to be by the revelation of the Spirit) was how we can still put others before G-d....even His mother.
 
Upvote 0
Replaceable? Jonah did as God commanded once God had to put him in the belly of a fish. We are all unique. I am sure your calling in the Lord is not the same as my calling is in the Lord. But it is the Lord who is to be glorified and the person with the calling
 
Upvote 0
T

Thekla

Guest

Exactly; and it was through her humility and the fulfillment of her calling that God is glorified.
"... he who humbles himself will be exalted."
 
Upvote 0

sheina

Born Crucified
Mar 30, 2007
1,042
188
Mississippi
✟24,514.00
Faith
Baptist
Marital Status
Married
Politics
US-Republican
Exactly; and it was through her humility and the fulfillment of her calling that God is glorified.
"... he who humbles himself will be exalted."
God is glorified because He is God...not through the humility of any man, woman or child.

Isaiah 42:8 I am the LORD: that is my name: and my glory will I not give to another, neither my praise to graven images.

"The Lord our God is but one only living and true God; whose subsistence is in and of himself, infinite in being and perfection, whose essence cannot be comprehended by any but himself;...." (The Philadelphia Confession of Faith, The Baptist Association at Philadelphia, Sept. 25, 1742)
 
Upvote 0
D

DiligentlySeekingGod

Guest
The Assumption of Mary Reviewed

This is a most excellent article debunking the Assumption of Mary. In fact, the author is a former Eastern Orthodox.

The argument that her remains have not been found has already been brought up in this thread as a defense to her supposed assumption. But...

Argument #3: The No Body Fallacy

Argument: No one knows where the body of the Virgin Mary is, therefore it must have been assumed.

Dilemma: By this line of thinking, any person whose body has not been found must have been bodily assumed. Many murder victims' have yet to have their bodies found...are we going to tell their families that they must not be found because they've been bodily assumed into heaven? Mozart was buried, but to this day no one knows where, and his body has not been found - are we to assume Mozart was bodily assumed into heaven? Should any person of antiquity whose remains have yet to be found be automatically identified as having been bodily assumed? This is simply fallacious thinking.
 
Last edited:
Upvote 0
S

Studious One

Guest
Excellent point!

One could carry that further concerning Melchizedek. Hebrews tells us that Melchizedek was without beginning or ending. (meaning there are no records telling who his parents were) Now, I have traced my father's lineage back to 1405 in Leichestershire, England. But on my mother's side, I cannot find anyone beyond my grandfather. Since there is no record of his father's birth and death, am I to assume that my great-grandfather is Melchizedek? LOL
 
Upvote 0

MarkRohfrietsch

Unapologetic Apologist
Site Supporter
Dec 8, 2007
30,981
5,810
✟1,008,744.00
Country
Canada
Gender
Male
Faith
Lutheran
Marital Status
Married
From the pen of Rev. William Weedon; the rest of the Homily can be found here: Weedon's Blog: Homily for St. Mary, Mother of Our Lord (2010)



12 August 2010

Homily for St. Mary, Mother of Our Lord (2010)



 
Upvote 0

laconicstudent

Well-Known Member
Sep 25, 2009
11,671
720
✟16,224.00
Faith
Christian Seeker
Marital Status
Private
Politics
US-Democrat

That's a terrible argument. Most people whose bodies haven't been found aren't major Christian figures. Comparing the body of the Theotokos to someone's grandfather or even Mozart is patently absurd. I seem to remember another person's body disappearing (this one in the Bible) being fairly significant to Christian theology.... hmm?
 
Upvote 0
S

Studious One

Guest
Arguing that the body of Mary was assumed into heaven is a terrible argument in light of the Scriptures.
Arguing that Mary is a perpetual virgin is a terrible argument in light of the Scriptures.
Arguing that Mary is CoMediatrix is a terrible argument in light of the Scriptures.
Arguing that Mary is the queen of heaven is a terrible argument in light of the Scriptures.
Arguing that Mary is full of grace is a terrible argument in light of the Scriptures.
Exalting Mary above her human status as mother is a terrible argument in light of the Scriptures.
Praying to Mary is a terrible argument in light of the Scriptures.

By the way, Peter, James, John, Paul, and other Apostles of the Lord Jesus Christ are Christian figures who were responsible for thousands upon thousands being saved. Yet no claims of them being assumed at all.

Hmmmmm
 
Upvote 0

laconicstudent

Well-Known Member
Sep 25, 2009
11,671
720
✟16,224.00
Faith
Christian Seeker
Marital Status
Private
Politics
US-Democrat

So says Studious One, therefore it must be true.

Sorry, but not everyone reads Scripture and comes to the same conclusions as you do, but when I quote Scripture on these subjects, I am routinely ignored, so I no longer bother.
 
Upvote 0
S

Studious One

Guest
Please give us the Scripture that states that Mary was bodily assumed into heaven.
Please give us the Scripture that states that Mary is a perpetual virgin.
Please give us the Scripture that states that Mary is CoMediatrix.
Please give us the Scripture that states that Mary is the queen of heaven.
Please give us the Scripture that states that Mary is full of grace.
Please give us the Scripture that states that Mary is the dispenser of grace.
Please give us the Scripture that states that Mary is to be exalted.
Please give us the Scripture that states that Mary is most holy.
Please give us the Scripture that says Mary is blessed above women.

You have shared some Scripture in this thread, but none of which you have shared reveal any of the above claims.

I'll be waiting for those Scriptures.... but I won't hold my breath.
 
Upvote 0

laconicstudent

Well-Known Member
Sep 25, 2009
11,671
720
✟16,224.00
Faith
Christian Seeker
Marital Status
Private
Politics
US-Democrat

Neither would I, I've gone through the cycle of

1. Give us the Scripture.

2. Ok *links Scripture*

3. Where's the Scripture?

4. Its right there. *links again*

5. I don't see it. I guess this proves that X is unscriptural.

6. But I just posted it. This is the third time! *links again futilely*

7. NO SCRIPTURE FOR X I WIN!!!

Too many times.
 
Upvote 0

Zeek

Follower of Messiah, Israel advocate and Zionist
Nov 8, 2010
2,888
217
England
✟19,164.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Private

LS... if and when you give any Scripture to back up a point...it might just be that it isn't conclusive....because I promise you that if I ever see anything that is clearly demonstrated through Scripture....then that is the authority that causes me to sit up and think, and reconsider and search out other Scriptures to see if it really is the case. I think all of us on these threads would do that.

I'm waiting for the day when one on my Catholic or Orthodox brethren come back at me, not with their Church apologetics...but actually confess that they never saw things quite that way....and that the point I was making might even have some merit....not because I said it....but because Scripture convinced them...even in the face of what they have been taught.

Never give up...always live in hope.
 
Upvote 0
D

DiligentlySeekingGod

Guest

Amen Zazal. Well said, brother.
 
Upvote 0

laconicstudent

Well-Known Member
Sep 25, 2009
11,671
720
✟16,224.00
Faith
Christian Seeker
Marital Status
Private
Politics
US-Democrat
No matter how many times you claim you posted the Scripture that proves the claims, it is clearly obvious that you have done no such thing.

Thank you for making my point.

There is nothing in scripture to validate such beliefs regarding Mary.

It is obvious from Scripture that Mary was ever-virgin, and is now Queen of Heaven.


I've quoted Scripture many times, but the truth of Sola Scriptura is that nobody is really interested in Scripture unless it is being used to agree with them.


Um, ok?

Never give up...always live in hope.

I do, but I'm not wasting my time by quoting Scripture any longer. Despite what the people who deride the Theotokos and the saints say, they really aren't interested.
 
Upvote 0

Zeek

Follower of Messiah, Israel advocate and Zionist
Nov 8, 2010
2,888
217
England
✟19,164.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Private
 
Upvote 0
Feb 3, 2011
550
23
✟23,272.00
Faith
Baptist
Marital Status
Married
Politics
US-Others
All of us who use scripture as the final authority know that none of the claims made about Mary can be justified. The RCC and OC people do not accept the scripture as final authority. Both call scripture 'canon', yet it does not stop them from continuing to believe what they do.

They also believe in 'replacement theology'. These last days will show how correct all this is. Almighty God will allow people to follow deception, but Almighty God will not/has not changed.
 
Upvote 0