I appreciate your help.
Currently it looks like my options have narrowed down to English and Biology. So, I will go into more depth of why I would choose each of these, and maybe someone, or yourself, can offer me insight.
English, as you have said, has nearly ALWAYS been my fall-back degree. That is, I will debate about majors I would like, but I nearly always end up back on English. Why English? Well, I love reading, I love writing. However, I have always thought I would love to be an English teacher or professor.
If I went onto English I would more than likely pursue at least a Masters and potentially a PhD. So, while you said this would be almost necessary, this is my plan. Whatever major I get, I plan on getting at least a Masters. Though, I know my plans are susceptible to change over time, I've never saw myself without a Masters, if not a PhD.
Those are the pros, in my eyes. The cons, is as mentioned, I don't find much of a job market for it beyond teaching. Though, I've considered teaching many times before, and if it were college level classes (even at a CC), I think I would enjoy it.
My wife believes of the two, I should go for English. She feels that if I were to go for Biology or Math it would only be out of fear, but she knows how much I love Literature and writing. Even if I were to get a biology major, I would still get a minor in Literature.
With that said, let me move onto biology.
Biology has been a growing interest to me. Actually, science in general. With my personality, I feel biology would be a good fit because of the numerous of possibilities within the field. I wouldn't be stuck with one job. And needless to say, money wouldn't be as much of a problem as it would be if I were a English major. Though, money isn't much of a concern to me. I just want a job I'd enjoy. I'd be fine making minimum wage, so long as I enjoyed my job. I think that biology has more of a practical result, in that I would be benefiting society. Which is something I would like my career to do.
Now for the cons. The con with biology is I don't really accept evolution. I've done my research on it, and while some would call me intellectually dishonest, I realize that from a science standpoint evolution is more or less a fact. However, I do not have a dogmatic stance on evolution. That is, God could have used evolution, or He could have just created everything. It doesn't really matter to me. But, I tend to side with the latter. I guess I'm the person Richard Dawkins usually bashes for knowing evolution is a fact, but denying it because of an ancient book.
I don't have any logical reasoning for this, and perhaps it is indoctrination I've received, but as far as the origins of life, I don't see that this really matters.
Now, let me say, I do accept things like speciation, micro-evolution, and such, but I don't necessarily agree with a common ancestor. Though, I'll admit, it is possible.
I would probably have a problem teaching a common ancestor as fact to students, so I don't know that I would, and to some degree, I believe majoring in biology would hurt my conscience.
So, this somewhat leans us towards environmental sciences. I believe I would enjoy this, but not far as much as biology/zoology, or any animal biology. My reasoning for ever becoming a biologist would be to work with animals and the like.