• Starting today August 7th, 2024, in order to post in the Married Couples, Courting Couples, or Singles forums, you will not be allowed to post if you have your Marital status designated as private. Announcements will be made in the respective forums as well but please note that if yours is currently listed as Private, you will need to submit a ticket in the Support Area to have yours changed.

struggling with a non-affectionate husband

T

tohisglory

Guest
hi, this is my first post. I'm struggling with a husband who isn't comfortable with affection, except with our two-year old. It's a real struggle with me. I have decided to surrender it after years of fighting about it and praying about it, but I still struggle with it. Additionally, our intimacy level has reduced dramatically due to career reasons as well as toddler reasons. I really long for more physicality in my marriage but think that will never happen. How do I obtain peace without resentment? I know he's faithful - this is my second marriage and I did lots of due diligence this time around. I know I have a faithful husband, but the lack of a physical relationship is a real struggle.
I'll take any suggestions from anyone. Yes, we've been through therapy and he seems to try to be affectionate certain days and there's other times, he makes no effort.
This is where I could kick myself for not realizing the importance of being equally yoked; I really with my husband didn't just know Jesus but loved Him above all else.

Thanks for any advice and prayers.
 

free4all

Senior Veteran
Dec 25, 2005
2,194
141
Midwest
✟25,461.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Married
Tohisglory,

I am sorry you are going through this. I go through this in phases with my wife. I'm afraid I don't have all the answers.

Do I struggle with resentment? Absolutely. Does it draw me to God more? Yes. Does it force me to realize what the priority is in my life, my walk with the Lord? Yes. Does it make me yearn for eternity to come sooner? Sometimes.

Did you learn anything about your husband's fears, or whatever is holding him back, from therapy? Was he distant from his mom, or something like that? (You don't need to answer, I'm just thinking out loud.) Are there reasons why he tries certain days but doesn't other days? Is that related to his schedule? Is a career change a possibility, or is that out of the question? Do you encourage him when he does try, and tell him how much you appreciate his efforts? Is he harboring anger toward you, or toward his mom? Does he need a lot of personal space after being close to you? What was his childhood like pertaining to showing affection? Again, you don't need to answer. I've just trying to bounce some ideas off of you.

Is your husband not a Christian?

tohisglory said:
I'll take any suggestions from anyone.
As Christians, we are strictly limited on how we can get our physical needs met, which I'm sure you know. I'm also sure you know the importance of physical touch, and the consequences of a lack of physical touch. At the risk of offending some, I'll tell you what I do when my wife avoids me for long periods of time. It is not a replacement for touch with her, but it is better than nothing.

There is a reputable spa in the town where I live. It has a school associated with it, where they train masseuses and maseurs. They offer student massages for very reasonable prices. They are reputable and discrete in every way, monitored by licensed trainers, no tipping allowed, and they keep certain areas covered during the entire massage. And by the time the students accept public patronage, they are quite good.

Does this totally replace intimacy with my wife? Not even close. Does it calm me, lower my blood pressure, remind me what physical touch is? Absolutely. I even had a talk with my wife recently during one of her vindictive moods, and calmly told her what I intended to do, that is, visit the spa whenever she avoided me for long periods of time. She was upset, but my actions are a natural consequence of her sin of withholding from me. At least I'm not going out and finding a girlfriend. I have no problem with going to the spa, with not hiding it from her, or with telling those on this forum what I have just told you. Some won't be able to accept it. That's okay, they don't have to live with the stress in my body that results from no touch. I'm certain that the people around me, and those I share the road with, are very happy when my stress levels decrease.

Anyway, that may not be an option for you based on where you live, your personal beliefs, or your income if your husband controls all the finances. But you asked for suggestions, and that's all I have. Oh, I just thought of one more small thing I can do... when I jog or exercise intensely, that also lowers my stress levels some, and sometimes makes me so tired I don't think about the lack of physical touch. And of course I pray often during those times.

I'm sorry if these options don't help you. That's all I have to offer.

I'm also sorry you are going through this. I know only too well what it feels like.

God bless,
Wayne
 
Upvote 0

rainbowpromise

Senior Contributor
May 10, 2006
8,761
274
British Columbia
✟34,021.00
Country
Canada
Gender
Female
Faith
Baptist
Marital Status
Widowed
Politics
CA-Conservatives
I know! I have been there and am there. After 29 years of marriage, nothing has changed.
As a woman you have more options than men. Nothing strange! I get my weekly hugs from a number of older ladies in our church. Many of these ladies are alone now and others their spouse is battling illness.

My husband actually cringes when I get too close. I truly think he has headaches, backaches and other muscle aches. Nothing against me.

Our intimacy level has been non-existent for about five years now. It was not easy at first, but I am used to it now.
 
Upvote 0

kayd1966

Don't just listen to the Word...Do what it says.
Mar 19, 2005
3,996
213
Visit site
✟20,154.00
Faith
Baptist
Marital Status
Private
my hubby is changing but its been about 7 years...ok, our whole marriage.

The change came when he started reading Men are from Mars, Women are from Venus. (OK, no giggling, its true!). What changed is that he just didn't understand what a woman "needs" and this book has cleared alot of these misconceptions and misunderstandings. I'm currently reading it because he asked me too. Its a very interesting book...definately not biblically based but interesting.

It is frustrating and really compounds the loneliness one can feel...spiritually and physically.

I'm not much help, but I can pray for you and your family.

God Bless...
 
Upvote 0

AbidingInHim

Senior Veteran
Sep 28, 2005
4,505
117
✟27,712.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Married
Fogive my abrupt post, I must really go study.....

http://www.fivelovelanguages.com/


I've had to accept my h's love language was not mine.....but I do see him speaking to me in his language....as I've learned to appreciate that....The Lord has blessed me by giving him more of an ability to speak to me in my love language......

Be content with what you have for God has said, never will I leave you never will I forsake you Hebrew 13:5

It is then, when you find that true contentment that you will be blessed with your hearts desires......

I have experinced it, I am not attempting to be trite or make lite of your situation, I know it all too well and have cried myself to sleep about it, please know I understand your plight........I have also experinced God's healing......
 
Upvote 0

christianstoic

Active Member
Apr 1, 2010
40
1
✟15,165.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Private
hi, this is my first post. I'm struggling with a husband who isn't comfortable with affection, except with our two-year old. It's a real struggle with me. I have decided to surrender it after years of fighting about it and praying about it, but I still struggle with it. Additionally, our intimacy level has reduced dramatically due to career reasons as well as toddler reasons. I really long for more physicality in my marriage but think that will never happen. How do I obtain peace without resentment? I know he's faithful - this is my second marriage and I did lots of due diligence this time around. I know I have a faithful husband, but the lack of a physical relationship is a real struggle.
I'll take any suggestions from anyone. Yes, we've been through therapy and he seems to try to be affectionate certain days and there's other times, he makes no effort.
This is where I could kick myself for not realizing the importance of being equally yoked; I really with my husband didn't just know Jesus but loved Him above all else.

Thanks for any advice and prayers.
In what ways do you expect him to be more intimate with you?
Would you prefer a soft, sensitive man? Would you prefer a man
with a heart of yolk? Is it kind words you need? Does he show you
love in other ways? Have you thanked him for these other ways,
if he does show it?

I don't know. I know a lot of men out there who can be stones
on the outside because of their personality, and often, if they are
honest men, this does not change when they around their spouses,
as they do not feel a need to be anything other than who they are
around those they love...

However, they, like every human, do have feelings and love, they just
choose to show it in other ways.

I'm sure you two can work it out.
 
Upvote 0

moonkitty

Senior Veteran
May 5, 2006
6,025
698
✟24,445.00
Faith
Atheist
Marital Status
Married
In what ways do you expect him to be more intimate with you?
Would you prefer a soft, sensitive man? Would you prefer a man
with a heart of yolk? Is it kind words you need? Does he show you
love in other ways? Have you thanked him for these other ways,
if he does show it?

I don't know. I know a lot of men out there who can be stones
on the outside because of their personality, and often, if they are
honest men, this does not change when they around their spouses,
as they do not feel a need to be anything other than who they are
around those they love...

However, they, like every human, do have feelings and love, they just
choose to show it in other ways.

I'm sure you two can work it out.

Seriously, do you really expect an answer from the OP? The post is 4 years old and she is not an active user. She hasn't been on this site for years. Do you in all honestly believe you will get an answer from the OP? Why bother dreading up all these old threads?
 
Upvote 0

savedbygracebre

Regular Member
Jun 26, 2005
318
23
✟579.00
Faith
Protestant
Seriously, do you really expect an answer from the OP? The post is 4 years old and she is not an active user. She hasn't been on this site for years. Do you in all honestly believe you will get an answer from the OP? Why bother dreading up all these old threads?

Do you think you are really showing grace to this person by the remarks you made? I think this person overlooked the actual date of the post and by the GRACE in their heart felt compelled to answer. Also, it certainly can't hurt for this person to respond. I, like others, have the same exact problems as other UY couples and will read ALL responses because sometimes great wisdom is provided. ALL responses are good-no matter how old. The same sins and problems that started with Adam and Eve still exist today-so all help is relevant-no matter how old!
 
Upvote 0

moonkitty

Senior Veteran
May 5, 2006
6,025
698
✟24,445.00
Faith
Atheist
Marital Status
Married
Do you think you are really showing grace to this person by the remarks you made? I think this person overlooked the actual date of the post and by the GRACE in their heart felt compelled to answer. Also, it certainly can't hurt for this person to respond. I, like others, have the same exact problems as other UY couples and will read ALL responses because sometimes great wisdom is provided. ALL responses are good-no matter how old. The same sins and problems that started with Adam and Eve still exist today-so all help is relevant-no matter how old!

Do you think I'm all that worried about grace? I'm about as graceful as a mac truck. ANd don't throw the bible at me on this one. I have never once tried to pretend as if I was a christain so that wont work on me. I've always been blunt--sorry if you do not like that. But at least with me you will know excatlly where you stand. I honestly can not say that about most chrsitians I know in real life who are sweet to your face--showing grace and all that--but talk trash about you behind you back.

As to the thread--For several weeks it seemed as if there was one person with several sock puppet accounts going back and reviving thread that were many years old. I really do not think they were doing to be nice.
 
Upvote 0

janman345

Well-Known Member
Jun 15, 2010
918
21
✟1,170.00
Faith
Non-Denom
Marital Status
Married
I know! I have been there and am there. After 29 years of marriage, nothing has changed.
As a woman you have more options than men. Nothing strange! I get my weekly hugs from a number of older ladies in our church. Many of these ladies are alone now and others their spouse is battling illness.

My husband actually cringes when I get too close. I truly think he has headaches, backaches and other muscle aches. Nothing against me.

Our intimacy level has been non-existent for about five years now. It was not easy at first, but I am used to it now.

I dont think men have any less options than women do.
 
Upvote 0

katautumn

Prodigal Daughter
May 14, 2015
7,498
157
44
Atlanta, GA
✟31,699.00
Country
United States
Gender
Female
Faith
Other Religion
Marital Status
Married
Politics
US-Others
I think this person overlooked the actual date of the post and by the GRACE in their heart felt compelled to answer.

Sorry, but I have to side with MoonKitty on this one. Bumping ages old threads is considered poor net etiquette. It's considered a disruption of normal forum operation, as it's usually done intentionally to bump currently active threads down to the next page or so. In fact, I think CF has a rule that says to be mindful of dates on posts you're responding to. I could be wrong, though. Most other forums I'm a member of implore their members to take notice of posting dates so as not to resurrect old, dead threads and push new, active discussions down the page.

And, yes, we had several sock puppet accounts with one post each a few weeks ago going around and bumping threads that were about five and six years old. One resurrected a thread from 2002! All they post is something like, "yeah, I agree with this praise God!" You know that's trolling, so I doubt pointing out the age of the OP is going to bother them much.
 
Upvote 0

jmsclayton

Newbie
Sep 7, 2010
17
0
Midwest USA
✟15,127.00
Faith
Non-Denom
Marital Status
Private
Politics
US-Others
Hi

sharing

Even if he is unequally yoked, SOmetimes men dont understand that women need nonsexual affection through out the day. He may just be one of those that lacks information or his past his a contributor.Have you been able to sit down and talk to him when he is in a good mood and ask him what he knows?

What do you think?

Judith:prayer:
 
Upvote 0