Starting today August 7th, 2024, in order to post in the Married Couples, Courting Couples, or Singles forums, you will not be allowed to post if you have your Marital status designated as private. Announcements will be made in the respective forums as well but please note that if yours is currently listed as Private, you will need to submit a ticket in the Support Area to have yours changed.
It also brings up another good point - there are 28 Fundamental Beliefs for SDAs -- not "a million and 8".
To my knowledge, #18 still remains and still stands as confirmation that the SDA denomination endorses the quotes I cited as representing the teachings of the SDA denomination. One might wonder why you seek to distance yourself from them.
BFA
#1. FB#1 states that All SDA doctrines stand or fall "sola scriptura".
#2. There is NO FB stating that we have as many doctrinal statements as someone can find out-of-context-EGW-snippets to post.
#3. Going back to each one and posting the full context - would flood this subject with what is sometimes called "data blindness", get's into an endless round of "prove-EGW by more quotes of EGW" and defeats the purpose of the thread.
So -- I guess you might say that I am just stating the obvious here - but it seems like that is the question you are asking.
in Christ,
Bob
Bob said
How can salvation 'hinge" on "looking to see if you are a good tree" AS IF a good tree "turns into a bad one" if you look at it??
If the "looking" is not changing your salvation state then how is your salvation status "hinging" on that "looking"???[quoe]BFA
Because--if I've correctly understood your position--you have connected your ultimate salvation, your status as a justified person at the end of time, with your works.
We are saved by grace through faith. The law is not of faith. Please explain how "looking" at things that can be seen is consistent with faith.
Bob said
It is like saying "my cancer hinges on the Doctor's exam next week" AS if the exam will either give me cancer or the exam will "take away cancer".
BFA
I assert that it is nothing like that.
Rather, it is like going to the divine healer and being told that, regardless of any short-term illnesses or tumors you may see, you will ultimately realize all of the benefits of being cancer-free.
I've often heard various SDAs suggest that the context might alter the way one views certain plain teachings of Ellen G. White. However, I have yet to find any place where Ellen G. White recants her position and later teaches that she was incorrect
BFA
It is not a question of recant -- it is a question of accuracy on your part.
Snippet quotes are by definition a text-of-document without a context -- which as we all know -- is a pretext.
Christ is the one that said "you shall know them by their fruits"
and Paul argues "EVERYONE will be judged according to the DEEDS done in the body whether they be good or evil" 2Cor 5:10. You seem to argue that God "can not let anyone look" at the tree - because to LOOK is to "change it".
On the contrary you keep arguing that the exam itself is a threat to health and that health "hinges on the result of the exam".
But in Matt 7 Christ is not arguing this is "how to BECOME a good tree" he is arguing that once choices are made and people either ARE or ARE NOT good trees - you can TELL by their fruits.
Notice that in Heb 6 Paul addressed the problem you are having here
you refuse to get past step-1 the POV of the LOST that needs to BECOME saved.. .the POV of the terminally ill that NEEDS to be made well, the POV of the BAD tree that NEEDS to BECOME the good tree.
I have already agreed a long time ago that this is not HOW the bad tree BECOMES a good tree -- rather it is the objective and accurate rule of Matt 7 that SEES that the tree either IS bad or good. Looking at the tree -- does not change the tree.
You seem to stumble when it comes to the Bible doctrine of "perseverance of the saints"
by choosing to ONLY allow your thoughts to dwell on the context of the lost needing to BECOME saved. A thing that happens basically in an INSTANT!
I don't see that line of argument working for you as well as you may have at first supposed.
We can discuss the dynamics of the passage, but for now I ask of you...is works the foundation of the justification here? Why or Why not?
PAST Justification "example"
"Having BEEN justified by faith we HAVE peace with God" Romans 5:1
FUTURE Justification "example"
"It is not the hearers of the law that are just before God but the DOERS of the Law WILL BE JUSTIFIED"
Notice that the past justification is "By faith alone"
Notice that future justification is based on evaluation of the fruit IN the life -- what the person DOES reveals what the "tree that is" or as Paul says in Romans 2:7 "PERSEVERING in doing GOOD"
BOTH deal with Gospel "Justification"
in Christ,
Bob
By AT:
Works or performance may justify your faith as genuine faith before others, but never God.
BY BobHmmm the text about "justifying your faith before God" -- I guess I missed that one. Please quote it.
The closest I see is when God himself says "NOT everyone who SAYS Lord Lord..." Matt 7
Is this where you paraphrase to mean "claims to have faith"?? If so.. then ok - I agree!
Once again - we may be good on this point as well.
By BobPaul places FUTURE justification as a reality at that FUTURE judgment when HE says "WILL be justified... on the DAY WHEN God WILL JUDGE".
Impossible to miss that one in Romans 2
By Bob And of course we know that because we SEE in vs 7 the RESULT of that "perseverance in doing GOOD" is as Paul states "eternal life"
It is right there in vs 7 -- all we have to do is read it and not ignore the inconvenient details in the text.
By bobReally? How so?
Why not go ahead and exegete Rom 2:7-8 to show how Paul is really saying "To those who Persevere in doing good -- the lake of fire -- and to those who choose to do evil -- also the lake of fire"
Because I have to say that from the actual reading of the text -- it is just not there.
Also note that in Romans 2 succeeding cases come from BOTH Jews AND Gentiles "to the Jew first and THEN to the Gentile"
And in Romans 2 failing cases also come from BOTH groups not "just from Jews" as we notice again those inconvenient details in Rom 2:7-13.
The foundation of justificaiton if faith and works. Cause one cannot be without the other. Faith first, and works second.
Review Matthew 7:14 and think about what that means.
"Because strait is the gate, and narrow is the way, which leadeth unto life, and few there be that find it."
Why would it be narrow? Why would only few find it?
Luke 11:4
"And forgive us our sins; for we also forgive every one that is indebted to us. And lead us not into temptation; but deliver us from evil."
What is sin, what is temptation, what is evil?
John 14:15
"If ye love me, keep my commandments."
What are the commandments?
Rom 2
13 for it is not the hearers of the Law who are just before God, but the doers of the Law will be justified
14 For when Gentiles who do not have the Law do instinctively the things of the Law, these, not having the Law, are a law to themselves,
15 in that they show the work of the Law written in their hearts, their conscience bearing witness and their thoughts alternately accusing or else defending them,
16 on the day when, according to my GOSPEL, God will judge the secrets of men through Christ Jesus
By Bob
Paul places FUTURE justification as a reality at that FUTURE judgment when HE says "WILL be justified... on the DAY WHEN God WILL JUDGE".
Impossible to miss that one in Romans 2
Well Im having a hard time finding this quote by you. Perhaps you can give the scripture to show it?
AT
By AT:
Works or performance may justify your faith as genuine faith before others, but never God.
BY Bob
Hmmm the text about "justifying your faith before God" -- I guess I missed that one. Please quote it.
The closest I see is when God himself says "NOT everyone who SAYS Lord Lord..." Matt 7
Is this where you paraphrase to mean "claims to have faith"?? If so.. then ok - I agree!
Once again - we may be good on this point as well.
AT
My only point is that justification by works in James 2 is only a validation that your faith is genuine. Your works testify that you have genuine faith before others and never God. Our Lord does not need to see your works to determine if we are genuine.
17 Even so faith, if it hath not works, is dead, being alone.
James 2:17 (KJV)
By Bob And of course we know that because we SEE in vs 7 the RESULT of that "perseverance in doing GOOD" is as Paul states "eternal life"
It is right there in vs 7 -- all we have to do is read it and not ignore the inconvenient details in the text.
And please tell me who is justified in this way? You? Me?
If not then who is without ever doing any wrong and always persevering in doing good?
Paul was making a point, and you seem to miss the point by not understanding the doctrine of law and gospel. You make it about you, and take the glory away from the cross of Christ.
We all are sinners and deserve death.
6 who WILL RENDER TO EACH PERSON ACCORDING TO HIS DEEDS
7 to those who by perseverance in doing good seek for glory and honor and immortality, eternal life ;
8 but to those who are selfishly ambitious and do not obey the truth, but obey unrighteousness[/font], wrath and indignation
9 There will be tribulation and distress for every soul of man who does evil , of the Jew first and also of the Greek,
10 but glory and honor and peace to everyone who does good, to the Jew first and also to the Greek
11 For there is no partiality with God.
Bob
The argument of Romans 2:7 and 13 are discussing rebellion vs obedience where obedience in the Romans 2 context is always "good" because it is always the gospel context of "perseverance of the saints" seen in vs 7.
False...not so!
Bob said --
Really? How so?
Why not go ahead and exegete Rom 2:7-8 to show how Paul is really saying "To those who Persevere in doing good -- the lake of fire -- and to those who choose to do evil -- also the lake of fire"
Because I have to say that from the actual reading of the text -- it is just not there.
Also note that in Romans 2 succeeding cases come from BOTH Jews AND Gentiles "to the Jew first and THEN to the Gentile"
And in Romans 2 failing cases also come from BOTH groups not "just from Jews" as we notice again those inconvenient details in Rom 2:7-13.
AT
IF you recall...the chapter headings where not installed by bible writers.
Paul continues over in chapter 3 that we are all under sin and that justification is by faith and not by works.
Justification happens at a moment in time
Bob said
Snippet quotes (of Ellen White in this case) are by definition a text-of-document without a context -- which as we all know -- is a pretext.
BFA
If this is relevant, than please demonstrate how the context finds Ellen G. White recanting the statements I've cited. Without such a retraction, the statements are--on their face--heretical.
AT
Tell me something...do you recieve the Holy Spirit because you follow the law or because you are born again by grace through faith?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?