• Starting today August 7th, 2024, in order to post in the Married Couples, Courting Couples, or Singles forums, you will not be allowed to post if you have your Marital status designated as private. Announcements will be made in the respective forums as well but please note that if yours is currently listed as Private, you will need to submit a ticket in the Support Area to have yours changed.

Status
Not open for further replies.
B

BushwigBill

Guest
Hey!

I was thinking about this the other day, and realised I don't really understand the whole concept as well as I thought I did. As I understand it, Jesus was sinless, and it isn't really possible for a regular human being to go through life without sinning, because we inherited original sin from Adam (whatever literal or figurative form of Adam you believe in). The definition of sin seems to involve us exercising our free will to separate ourselves from God, but if it's not really possible not to sin, can we really be blamed for it? Do we have any choice but to be sinners?

Please can someone explain this to me? It has to make sense somehow.
 

CaliforniaJosiah

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
Aug 6, 2005
17,496
1,568
✟229,195.00
Gender
Male
Faith
Lutheran
Marital Status
Private
Politics
US-Republican

Well, I can give you my viewpoints...


1. Jesus Without Sin

First of all, this is something the Bible teaches (John 8:46, John 8:29, John 17:19, John 18:36, Matthew 27:19, Luke 23:41, Matthew 27:4, 2 Cor. 5:21, etc.)

HOW is it so is something that IMO the Bible doesn't answer (the Bible isn't a Q&A book). There are different theories. Catholics are apt to point to the "Immaculate Conception of Mary" and Protestants to the Communication between His two natures (Human and Divine).


2. Original Sin


Here's how I understand it. Original Sin is like a disease (inherited in a spiritual but not biological sense). It's a twisted, perverted, "bent" or "broken" aspect in our nature.

"Actual sins" are the SYMPTOMS of this nature. These "actual sins" can be of thought, word or deed - omission or comission. But they are SYMPTOMS of our sinful nature. Right now I have a cold but at this moment I'm not caughing or sneezing or blowing my nose. RIGHT NOW, I have no observable symptoms of my cold - but I still have the disease. While WE can decrease the symptoms of our "disease" of sin (actual sins) we can't cure the disease.


I hope that helps a bit...


MY $0.01...


Keep the faith! Share the love!


- Josiah



.
 
Upvote 0

winsome

English, not British
Dec 15, 2005
2,770
206
England
✟26,511.00
Faith
Catholic
Marital Status
Married

This seems to be a common misunderstanding. The Immaculate Conception is a doctrine about Mary's conception not Jesus'. But lets not get sidetracked down that road here. Lets stick to original sin.


I wouldn't put it quite like that, but fairly close.
Catholics see original sin as a loss of the sanctifying grace, which we need to enter heaven. This has been made available to us through Jesus Christ, we believe we receive this in Baptism.

The Catholic Catechism puts it this way

"The harmony in which they [Adam and Eve] found themselves, thanks to original justice, is now destroyed; the control of the sould's spiritual faculties over the body is shattered; the union of man and woman becomes subjest to their tensions.... Harmony with creation is broken... Death makes its entrance into history."

Frank Sheed (Catholic apologist) puts it this way
"Originally they were created with their body's subject to their souls, the lower powers of the soul to the higher, natural habits to supernatural, the whole united with God in-dwelling" (Genesis Regained). This they lost with their rebellion. And we continue to be born without that supernatural life that was originally theirs.
 
Upvote 0

DiscipleDave

Well-Known Member
Mar 10, 2006
486
35
Midwest
Visit site
✟834.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Married
BushwigBill said:
Hey!

...... ...... ...... ...... ...... ...... ..... The definition of sin seems to involve us exercising our free will to separate ourselves from God, but if it's not really possible not to sin, ... .... .... .... .... .... ... ... .

Mt:19:26: But Jesus beheld them, and said unto them, With men this is impossible; but with God all things are possible.

Mk:9:23: Jesus said unto him, If thou canst believe, all things are possible to him that believeth.

So then if you believe you can't then you will never, but if you believe you can, with Christ's help, then you can, i am a witness, that it is possible.
 
Upvote 0

DiscipleDave

Well-Known Member
Mar 10, 2006
486
35
Midwest
Visit site
✟834.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Married
The very first sin ever was Greed, and this was done through Lucifer, when he desired to have God's position in Heaven. Matters of fact, all sin that is knowingly and willingly committed is done because of Greed or a form of it.

We are born in sin, not because of anything that we have done, but because we are born flesh. Flesh while on the Earth will always desire to be satisfied, flesh is evil because flesh is of the earth, not of Heaven. Now the spirit is from Heaven, because it is the breath of God that gives us life, the breath of God does not come from Earth, nor from Hell, but in fact comes from Heaven, where God is.
This spirit that is from Heaven, is inside the flesh that was made from the earth, just as Adam was made from the Earth. The flesh and the spirit is always at war with each other, the spirit knows to do good and desires to do good, yet the flesh, wants to do evil, and desires to do evil, when we are children, we know not christ, nor do we give Christ much thought, so children lie, steal, rebell and the such because they are children, the only people they have to listen to and obey is their parents, but when they become of age, and they learn of Christ, this is when they are in need of repentence, and are in need of Salvation, because of all their sinning and all their mischiefs, they are bound for Hell, this is when they have a need for Christ to save them, This is all part of God's plan for the human flesh while on the Earth. we are children, then teens, and we commit many sins, we become adults, put off childish things accept Christ and walk the walk of a Christian no longer doing those things which are evil in the eyes of Christ.
Jesus even though He was 1/2 human, had something us humans never had, He had a direct communication with the FAther, many times in times of need, He was able to directly talk to the Father, in being able to do this, He was able to withstand all the temptations that His flesh was giving Him, and He did not sin. We do not have a direct line to the Father, but we have Jesus to talk to the Father for us, on our behalf, he is our mediator between us and His Father, so then through Christ we too can have communication to the Father when we are being tempted by satan to commit some kind of sin.

There is a war going on between the spirit that is in us, and the flesh that tries to rule us, everything the flesh desire, the spirit despiseth, and everything the spirit desires the flesh despiseth. a person can lose many battles, but in the end wins the war, it is only when people stop trying to win the battles is when they will lose the war in the end.
Many people ask me if i am Saved, i say if i die right now i will go to Heaven, but to say i KNOW i will feel the same way in 50 years, that i cannot say. What if God decides to test me, and takes my wife from me, my kids, my job, my health, my reputation, my respect, what if He takes everything from me to test me, and because all this is happening maybe i turn away from Him, curse Him because He took all that i love away from me, for no reason. Now i can sit here and tell you with my mouth, i still would not turn away from God, and that is how i feel right now, but one must go through it to actually know how they will handle it. therefore i cannot possibly know what will happen to me in the future that may make me sway my belief one way or another. That is why it is written " He that endures to the end, shall be Saved " endures what ???? whatever comes, is what. IF you endure what is to come, THEN you shall be Saved at the end. So then if i die right now, my end is now, and i have endured, therefore if i die right now, i am Saved, will i be tomorrow ? i like to think so, yes, Do i know for a fact that i will be ? Well we shall see tomorrow, today is enough to be concerned about. Why worry about the battles of tomorrow when there are battles yet today.
When you look in the mirror, you are looking at the very person who can put you into Hell, your flesh and its evil desires. this is why the Bible teaches us to look to the spirit, to obey the spirit, to obey the teachings of Christ, to put off the flesh and its desires. If it were possible to even step out of your flesh, stop satisfying the very thing that can put you in Hell, Know you not that flesh and blood will not enter into the Kingdom of Heaven, the very thing you try to please all the time, will not enter into Heaven.

The spirit within you, yearns for you to do those things which please the spirit and not pleases the flesh. Those who live after the flesh, that is those who continually commit sins to satisfy their own flesh, will die in the flesh, those who live by the Spirit are those who have killed the deeds of the flesh, no longer obeys the desires of the flesh that are sinful, know you not, your flesh is your biggest enemy, yes satan is an enemy, but he only uses your flesh to bring you down, he has no other toold to work with, except only your flesh, that is the enemy.
i beg you even crying:

Rom:13:14: But put ye on the Lord Jesus Christ, and make not provision for the flesh, to fulfil the lusts thereof.

Rom:6:12: Let not sin therefore reign in your mortal body, that ye should obey it in the lusts thereof.

Rom:8:13: For if ye live after the flesh, ye shall die: but if ye through the Spirit do mortify the deeds of the body, ye shall live.

Col:3:5: Mortify therefore your members which are upon the earth; fornication, uncleanness, inordinate affection, evil concupiscence, and covetousness, which is idolatry:

Mt:26:41: Watch and pray, that ye enter not into temptation: the spirit indeed is willing, but the flesh is weak.

Jn:6:63: It is the spirit that quickeneth; the flesh profiteth nothing: the words that I speak unto you, they are spirit, and they are life.

Rom:7:25: I thank God through Jesus Christ our Lord. So then with the mind I myself serve the law of God; but with the flesh the law of sin.

the flesh will always serve the law of sin, it has the sin nature and always desires to sin, tell me if your mind is led by the spirit, then you would not allow your body to commit sins. Question if your mind obeys the laws of God and your flesh desires to sin, which controls which, Doesn't your mind control what your body actually does ? Yes, therefore if your mind is serving the laws of God, you will not allow your body to serve the laws of sin, even though your flesh desire to serve the laws of sin. let not your body control you, but let your mind which is governed by God control your body, that is why it is written:

Jms:3:2: For in many things we offend all. If any man offend not in word, the same is a perfect man, and able also to bridle the whole body.

Sorry i can show verse after verse after verse that says to not obey the flesh and its desires, i will stop now
 
Upvote 0
B

BushwigBill

Guest

I'm not sure I understand how you're a witness? Have you never sinned or do you know someone who's never sinned? What I'm really saying is how can it be our fault that we need saving, if we all sin as a result of original sin? Does a little child really have the option of not stealing a sweet he wants, when he doesn't even understand what sin is or what its consequences are? Is the Christian belief that it's our fault that Jesus had to die, or does all the blame lie with Adam? Having inherited original sin, if I went through life without sinning, would I still need to be saved?
 
Upvote 0

Firefall

Flame Elemental
Apr 29, 2004
2,168
93
37
Elemental Plane of Fire
✟25,310.00
Faith
Protestant
Marital Status
Single
I have thought about this topic as well, and my belief, which makes sense, is as follows;

We know that Jesus was the second Adam. Adam and Eve before the fall had no sin nature. They were naturally perfect and selfless. However, when they made the choice, not out of sinful nature, but from free will to sin, their spiritual connection with God was broken. This led to all their descendents being born spiritually dead and having to physically die.

Jesus = God's spirit in a human body (the same way that we have our inner self/spirit/heart/soul in a human body). So in the same way that I am 100% me and 100% human, so too was Christ 100% God and 100% human on earth.

Now comes the answer: Jesus was just like Adam was before he sinned, except that Jesus had and has full knowledge of good and evil since He is God. So Jesus was not naturally inclined towards sin, but was still able to be tempted because he was human as well.

So basically he had non-influenced free will to sin but didn't. That is the same position we have when we become Christians, except that we have remnants of our old fleshly self that will be done away with at the end.

**********

I'll leave everyone with this brief summary of why we have free will. God=Love. Love=Selflessness. Selflessness needs other beings by its own definition. Love is a relationship. God=Love. The beings God needs, have to be able to love Him back by relationship's definition. Love can not be forced, otherwise it becomes mindless devotion and not Love. To be able to Love, you therefore need free will to do it. Thus God gave us free will to Love.
 
Upvote 0

linssue55

Senior Veteran
Jul 31, 2005
3,380
125
76
Tucson Az
✟26,739.00
Faith
Non-Denom
Marital Status
Private
Politics
US-Republican
DOCTRINE OF THE OLD SIN NATURE ......(Worth the read)


A. Definition.
1. Biblical documentation of the sin nature is found in Rom 5:12. “Therefore, just as through one man [Adam], sin [the sin nature] entered into the world, and [spiritual] death through [the] sin [nature], so [spiritual] death spread to the entire human race because all sinned [when Adam sinned].”
2. The characteristics of spiritual death include:
a. The status quo of dichotomy in the human race, having only a body and soul at birth, but no human spirit. Without a human spirit you can have no relationship with God, 1 Cor 2:13.
b. Total depravity can be moral or immoral degeneracy, depending upon one’s trend in his sin nature. If a believer’s fragmentation (becoming arrogant and staying that way) is perpetuated, the believer becomes morally or immorally degenerate.
c. Total separation from God.
d. Total helplessness to perform any work, sacrifice, or any change of life by which we can enter into a relationship with God. The only way we can enter into a relationship with God is to accept God’s work on our behalf; i.e., to believe on the Lord Jesus Christ.
3. The threefold essence of the old sin nature.
a. The area of weakness produces personal sins and eventuates in consequent evil in the form of moral or immoral degeneration, Heb 12:1.
b. The area of strength produces human good, resulting in moral degeneracy, Isa 64:6; Rom 8:8.
c. The lust pattern motivates sin and evil, lasciviousness and asceticism, moral and immoral degeneration, Rom 7:7; Eph 2:3.
4. The old sin nature is Adam’s trend after the Fall in action. Immediately after Adam sinned, two things occurred simultaneously.
a. He had a new trend historically.
b. He had spiritual death.
5. A trend occurred toward sin, producing personal sin in three categories: mental, verbal and overt.
6. A trend occurred toward good and evil, producing the Satanic policy for the pseudo-millennium. The trend toward good and evil also became a part of the function of Adam’s trend. The trend toward good and evil is still an issue. Because of the judicial imputation of all personal sins to Christ, sin is no longer an issue except in rebound. When Adam chose the tree, he chose Satan’s policy, immediately making Satan the ruler of the world. The Garden was not so much a coup d’etat as a surrender.
7. The Fall of man resulted in numerous changes from the Garden.
a. Satan became the ruler of this world.
b. The old sin nature became the ruler of man’s body.
c. Mankind became spiritually dead, and therefore under the condemnation of the justice of God, which became our new point of reference.
8. Adam took a perfect soul and, by his negative volition, he revolted against divine authority and created the old sin nature. Adam’s volition was a perfect instrument. But being free, he could reject divine authority.
9. We all have this original mold. While the soul is not occupied by the old sin nature, the soul becomes the battlefield which the old sin nature attacks and where it is often tactically successful.
10. The influence of the old sin nature on the soul is seen in mental attitude sins and motivations. The condition and status of the body often affect how you think. There is no question that the body effects the soul and the mentality, just as the soul effects the body (psychosomatics). This phenomenon of not only the immaterial influencing the material but also the material influencing the immaterial is noted in the “heart” passages of Jer 17:9; Mt 12:34-35; Mt 15:19; Mk 7:21-23.

B. Biblical Synonyms for the Old Sin Nature.
1. The singular of the Greek word HAMARTIA generally refers to the old sin nature, Rom 5:12, 7:14; 1 Cor 15:56; 1 Jn 1:8. The plural generally refers to personal sins.
a. Rom 5:12, “Therefore, just as through one man [Adam], sin [the sin nature] entered into the world, and [spiritual] death through sin [the sin nature], so [spiritual] death spread to the entire human race because all sinned [when Adam sinned].”
b. Rom 7:14, “Certainly, we know that the law is spiritual, but I am of [belonging to the realm of] the flesh [sin nature], sold in bondage to sin [sin nature].”
(1) Of course the law is spiritual, for it came from God. It is God’s establishment mandate for the entire human race.
(2) “Flesh” (SARXZ) is another word for the old sin nature.
(3) We are sold into bondage at birth, when the imputation of Adam’s original sin to the old sin nature occurs.
c. Actually, HAMARTIA in the singular can refer to:
(1) Adam’s original sin.
(2) Old sin nature, usually found with the generic use of the definite article.
(3) Principle of personal sin.
2. The Greek word SARXZ means “flesh,” and it emphasizes the location of the old sin nature in the cell structure of the body. Because the sin nature is related to the biological life, it is called the flesh.
a. Gal 5:16, “But I say, walk by means of the Spirit and you will not execute the lusts of the flesh.”
b. Eph 2:3 mentions the lust of the flesh; 1 Jn 2:16; Rom 6:6, 7:14.
3. “The old man” (PALAIOS ANTHROPOS) emphasizes the origin of the old sin nature: Adam’s original sin perpetuated through the twenty-three male chromosomes which fertilize the female ovum in copulation.
a. Eph 4:22, “With reference to your former lifestyle [self- fragmentation through post-salvation sinning], you yourselves lay aside [through rebound] the old man [sin nature], you who are becoming degenerate on the basis of the lusts of deceit.”
b. The sin nature is classified as the old man because it originated in the Garden of Eden; it’s older than anything else, Col 3:9.
c. “You who are becoming degenerate” refers to being corrupted in polarized fragmentation from the trends of the sin nature.
d. The “lusts of deceit” include power lust, money lust, approbation lust, sexual lust, chemical lust, and emotional lust (fear, worry, anger).
4. “Carnal” (SARKINOS) means “fleshly,” “of the flesh,” or “belonging to the flesh.” This refers to the believer under the control of his old sin nature and therefore out of fellowship with God through personal sin and resultant cosmic involvement.
a. Rom 7:14, “Certainly, we know that the law is spiritual, but I am of [belonging to the realm of] the flesh [sin nature], sold in bondage to sin [sin nature].” (See point 4 for Rom 7:14-25.)
b. 1 Cor 3:1-3, “And I, brethren, could not speak to you as to spiritual persons [believers in divine dynasphere], but as to belonging to the sin nature [carnal believers controlled by the sin nature], as to babes in Christ [childish believers]. I gave you milk, and not solid food [advanced doctrine], for you were not able to receive it; in fact, you are not yet able. For you are still belonging to the sin nature. For since there is jealousy and strife among you, are you not belonging to the sin nature, and keep walking in conformity with men?”
(1) The Corinthians believers were still not able to learn advanced doctrine because they were under the control of the old sin nature, which limits what you can learn.
(2) The fact that they are still carnal means they don’t use rebound to recover fellowship.
(3) Note what Paul mentions as an example of carnality. He mentions one of the mental attitude sins of arrogance: jealousy.
(4) The Corinthian believers are therefore “of the sin nature", i.e., carnal, and walking as unbelievers.
5. “Our body of sin” in Rom 6:6 emphasizes the old sin nature’s headquarters where it resides in the cell structure of the body. Its genetic home is in the cell chromosomes.
6. “Corruptible man” refers to the sin nature in Rom 1:23. Corruptions means the old sin nature and the result of the old sin nature. Man is corrupted physically, spiritually, and therefore morally.
7. “Corruptible seed” in 1 Pet 1:23 refers to the transmission of the old sin nature. 8. There are passages which describe sin, good or evil as coming from the “heart.” The heart, or right lobe of the soul, has nothing to do with the old sin nature. But the old sin nature always gets to the soul of man by attacking the heart. This is the old sin nature influencing thought so that sin, good and evil are motivated in the thinking, being programmed in the brain. Jer 17:9; Mt 12:34-35, 15:19; Mk 7:21-23.

C. Further Biblical Documentation of the Old Sin Nature.
1. There are three references to the old sin nature in Rom 6:6. “Knowing this, that our old man [old sin nature] was crucified with Him [retroactive positional truth], that our body of sin [old sin nature] might be rendered powerless, in order that we should no longer be slaves to sin [old sin nature].” The implication of this verse is that we are in slavery to the old sin nature apart from retroactive positional truth.

(cont)
 
Upvote 0

linssue55

Senior Veteran
Jul 31, 2005
3,380
125
76
Tucson Az
✟26,739.00
Faith
Non-Denom
Marital Status
Private
Politics
US-Republican
2. When the old sin nature gains control of the soul, it is often called a “desperately wicked heart.” Jer 17:9, “The heart of man is deceitful above all things and desperately wicked.”
a. The Hebrew word LEB is used for the right lobe of the soul, but here it refers to the right lobe connected with the old sin nature’s temptations. They are filtered through the soul and its functions.
b. The right lobe is the place where sin is defined before volition grabs it and runs with it. All sin originates from your own volition, but temptation goes through your soul.
c. This explains Jer 17:9 which relates the right lobe to the old sin nature. Mt 12:34-35 and 15:19 says the heart is the source of certain sins. This doesn’t refer to the right lobe by itself, but as it is related to the old sin nature.
(1) In other words, the sin nature comes from the cell structure of the body and presents a temptation which goes into the right lobe. There it is defined in terms of language. Or it can be defined in terms of emotion. So once the source, the old sin nature, gains entry to the soul, then the temptation is defined. At this point, you know you are being tempted according the language of your own soul.
(2) Then you face a decision toward that temptation. Negative volition means you will commit the sin you are tempted with, whether you know it’s a sin or not. Positive volition means you say no to committing that sin, so that the temptation merely remains a temptation. A temptation can never become a sin until your volition is involved. This is true of all people, normal or abnormal. All people are held responsible for their sins before God. 3. Rom 7:14 has two references to the old sin nature. “For we know that the law is spiritual [comes from God, a Spirit], but I am of the flesh [old sin nature in body], having been sold into bondage to sin [slavery to old sin nature].”
4. 1 Jn 1:8, “If we say [contend, maintain, assert] that we have no sin [nature], we deceive ourselves, and doctrine is not in us.”
5. 1 Jn 1:10, “If we say [contend, maintain, assert] that we have not sinned [after salvation], we make Him a liar and His doctrine is not in us.”

D. The Source of the Old Sin Nature.
1. The old sin nature is the genetic home for the imputation of Adam’s original sin at physical birth causing real spiritual death. Real spiritual death is separation from God in a state of total depravity.
2. The old sin nature resides in the cell structure of the body and is the source of all inner temptation. Anything that is a temptation to you must be filtered through your soul. The sin nature is passed down genetically through the twenty-three male chromosomes in copulation. 3. While the soul of man comes from God, the old sin nature originates from the original sin of Adam in the Garden. The old sin nature works through the soul. All inner temptations come from the old sin nature. Most temptation comes this way, though occasionally we face an overt temptation.
4. Two imputations occur simultaneously at birth. When the fetus emerges from the womb, God imputes human life to its home, the human soul. That human life is, in every case, created by God. Secondly and simultaneously, the justice of God imputes Adam’s original sin to the genetically-prepared home of the sin nature residing in the cell structure of the body. The result is real physical life and real spiritual death.
5. Adam’s original sin was acquired by imputation. Adam’s sin nature is attained genetically.
6. There is a vast difference between biological life and soul life.
a. Biological life originates from copulation. Soul life originates from God at birth.
b. The sin nature does not become active until birth, when biological life is combined with soul life to form the human being.
c. God cannot and did not create the sin nature. The sin nature originated from Adam’s disobedience. God is not the author of sin or temptation; that is blasphemous and unthinkable.
d. Biological life is genetic, originating from one cell, the zygote. Soul life originates from God at birth.
e. Biological life begins at conception; soul life begins at birth.
f. The sin nature is transmitted through biological life. Therefore, the sin nature is transmitted through the body, not the soul. For this reason, the word SARXZ or the flesh is used as a synonym for the sin nature.
g. Biological life begins with mother dependence in the womb. Soul life begins with God dependence at birth.
7. While both the man and the woman are carriers of the old sin nature, transmission of the old sin nature occurs
only through twenty-three male chromosomes passed down from the man. The man is the transmitter of the old sin nature in copulation because Adam committed the original sin of cognizance, and Eve committed the original sin of ignorance.
a. 1 Tim 2:14, “And it was not Adam who was deceived, but the woman, being deceived, was in the transgression.
b. Rom 5:12, “Therefore, just as through one man [Adam], sin [the sin nature] entered into the world, and [spiritual] death through the sin nature, so [spiritual] death spread to the entire human race because all sinned.”
c. Ps 51:5, “Behold, I was born in iniquity, and in sin [the sin nature] I was conceived.” David means that Adam’s original sin was imputed to the old sin nature at the point of birth. He is not saying that he was born a *******.
8. The sin nature is genetically formed in the womb, along with biological life. Because there is no soul life in the womb, God is not the author of sin.
 
Upvote 0
B

BushwigBill

Guest
Cool, thanks everyone for your opinions. I think I will stick with the concept of original sin as a disease, and personal sins as symptoms we can control. Perhaps it's an oversimplification, but I think it makes a very nice starting point. Still a few things I'm not entirely clear on, but I'll mull it over for a while and perhaps after a while I'll achieve some kind of clarity on this.

Thanks again!
 
Upvote 0
Status
Not open for further replies.