Michael, Walt, and Naomi

FatBurger · May 17, 2007

No, I don't think Naomi is Walt's real mother
I was thinking today about whether or not Michael and Walt made it off the island. Ben seems to be genuine with his promise of helping them off the island, which to me means that they did make it off, and assumedly got rescued.

If they didn't...
Where are they now?
Where have they been for the past ~25 days?

If they did...
Wouldn't Naomi know about them?

EDIT
The possible explanations I can think of are:
1. They didn't get away from the island.
2. They did, but were never rescued and died at sea. (Seems extremely unlikely)
3. They lied about the events of the crash.
4. Naomi is lying, either partly or fully.

goat37 · May 17, 2007

If they got off the island and were rescued, then I think the whole story of them finding the plane and all of the passengers dead would be completely false.

I don't think we're getting a straight story from Naomi.

Sign Of The Fish Burger · May 17, 2007

I totally agree with both of you. Naomi seems extremely sketchy to me and has since she was introduced (the whole jungle scene with Mikhail speaking different languages etc.)

Re: Ben- since when do we believe anything he says? I'm not so sure he can be believed at all...

MtDoraAngel · May 18, 2007

I wondered about the whole "you're all dead" story, except Cooper said the same thing to Locke.

I think Naomi has Other written all over her.

And I still don't trust Juliet. To me, she is telling the Losties what she needs to in order to stay as "one of them". I think her loyalties will come out in the Season Finale.

snoochface · May 18, 2007

Naomi prodding Charlie for information about the attack on Wednesday was a HUGE red flag to me. Alarm bells were going off in my head. Why would she be digging for information on who they were going to attack, just out of the blue?

Made me wonder if that isn't why Ben decided to move up the beach raid by a day. I don't trust her either.

I wonder if we will see Michael and Walt inside the Looking Glass.

FatBurger · May 18, 2007

MtDoraAngel said:
I wondered about the whole "you're all dead" story, except Cooper said the same thing to Locke.

Did he say everyone was? Or did he just say "my son died"?

Sign Of The Fish Burger · May 18, 2007

I thought he said my son died when I pushed him out a window.

FatBurger · May 18, 2007

Synopsis off Lostpedia

Cooper is yelling through his gag. Sawyer removes the gag and gestures at Cooper to keep quiet. Sawyer yells at Locke and threatens to shoot through the door. John tells him if there had been bullets in the gun, Sawyer wouldn't have held a knife to his throat earlier. Cooper chuckles about not raising a dummy and explains that Locke is his son. Sawyer asks Cooper how he got to the Island. He says he was driving down I-10 through Tallahassee when someone slammed into the back of his car, sending him through the divider at 70 miles per hour. He remembers being put in an ambulance, where one of the paramedics smiled at him, and then waking up gagged and tied to a chair. A door opened and he was staring at his dead son Locke. Sawyer is confused: he asks if Locke died from falling out of the window, but Cooper says that only paralyzed him. Locke died, he says, when his plane crashed in the Pacific. Sawyer tells him that he was on the plane, Locke wasn't crippled, and they crashed on the Island, not the Ocean. Cooper suggests that they're not on an island. Wherever they are, it's too hot to be Heaven...

gracepaints · May 18, 2007

I hadn't thought about Walt and Micheal. I dunno, if we're in a parallel universe or something, it's possible they got away.

I just don't Naomi 'cuz her accent bugs me.

Redguard · May 31, 2007

gracepaints said:
I hadn't thought about Walt and Micheal. I dunno, if we're in a parallel universe or something, it's possible they got away.

I just don't Naomi 'cuz her accent bugs me.

Naomi's accent is music to my ears!

Anyway, I think that this "ship" that Naomi came from probably intercepted Michael and Walt during their journey off the island.

Michael, as expected, jumps up and down screaming, "Help!! We need rescue!!" and the ship's crew picks them up and then.....

HOLDS THEM HOSTAGE!!

So, right now, Michael and Walt are being held captive in this ship off the coast of the island. Probably being tortured into offering information about the island's inhabitants.

MtDoraAngel · May 31, 2007

Cool theory Red

Waaaaaallllllllllltttttttttttt!

Daaaaaaaaadddddddddd!

*slap* "Shut up"

snoochface · May 31, 2007

LOL @ Red and Dora

MissVegas · Jun 1, 2007

hmm all good theories... and where are we with this thread?? I am just now subscribing...

MtDoraAngel · Jun 1, 2007

Did the writers ever confirm that we will learn the fate of Michael and Walt? I want to know what, why and how Walt was so special. How long has it been since they got off the island? A few weeks.

snoochface · Jun 1, 2007

MtDoraAngel said:
Did the writers ever confirm that we will learn the fate of Michael and Walt? I want to know what, why and how Walt was so special. How long has it been since they got off the island? A few weeks.

Yeah, they said not this year, and I don't think they even comitted to next year, but they said "before the series is over" we would have the completion to their story.

MtDoraAngel · Jun 1, 2007

That's good to know. I was needing some closure.

Michael, Walt, and Naomi

14% + Jesus = victory

Skeet, skeet!

Black holes are where God divided by zero.

Legend

Meet the new boss -- same as the old boss.

14% + Jesus = victory

Black holes are where God divided by zero.

14% + Jesus = victory

gracepaints

Guest

Make It So, Number One!

Legend

Meet the new boss -- same as the old boss.

Veteran

Legend

Meet the new boss -- same as the old boss.

Legend

Similar threads

Privacy & Transparency

Privacy & Transparency