Starting today August 7th, 2024, in order to post in the Married Couples, Courting Couples, or Singles forums, you will not be allowed to post if you have your Marital status designated as private. Announcements will be made in the respective forums as well but please note that if yours is currently listed as Private, you will need to submit a ticket in the Support Area to have yours changed.
proper context is key and when you have issues with Mary as a mother, what kind of context will there be?But it does mean that there is nothing in the orthodox express of blessed Juliana that is against the faith.
I get your concern. But I think people are a bit jumpy as of late. Some of it is with good reason...but some is a bit hair-trigger.
Here is a brief overview of her work from the Catholic encyclopedia: link
And, as it says...and as is always the proper context to look at:
Throughout her revelations Juliana submits herself to the authority of the Church:"I yield me to our mother Holy Church, as a simple child oweth."
In that example and careful expression we can find the riches of her theology without falling into error.
and KTS, having the problems she does with Catholicism, has to be careful this is not where she ends up. I think stuff like this is truly meant for ppl who are strong in the faith. Much like De Montfort is...
You know how it is when we do not defer to the Church and we wing it on our own, thinking the the Spirit leads us...
This can lead into full blown New Ageism and given the issues with Mary and authority and not really getting anywhere with them... this can be dangerous ...is all I'm saying... when one does not defer to the authority of the Church to TEACH them and they feel they can TEACH themselves.
I'm not down with this notion of let me pick and chose what i like about Catholicism and discard what i don't.
This is not getting the person anywhere to do that.
proper context is key and when you have issues with Mary as a mother, what kind of context will there be?
Or even better - we can take the grace He gives us and work our butt off to seek and apply healing to our lives--instead of just staying wounded and seeking comfort. Jesus doesn't just suffer and die- He is resurrected. Too many people use Jesus as a crutch- and an excuse to stay wounded and victimized their whole lives. Yes, He is a comfort. Yes, Jesus might mirculously in one fail swoop heal us--but more often than not--as with all things we have to participate in redemption by going past being coddled, and work to heal ourselves. He gives us the strength and fortitude and courage to facilitate our healing, be we have to go out and pursue that peace.
I am sorry you lost your mom. That is a tragedy, for sure. But hopefully you aren't still defining relationships by that loss. If you are then you have my prayers-if you aren't, you have them anyway.
Jesus is fully human, whilst being fully divine. His divinity has no gender, but His inseperable humanity most certainly does. We can't separate the hypostatic union, even if it gives us warm fuzzies to do so.
Seriously let's not over react too much.
If Kisstheson had said, Jesus nurtured me like a mother, I don't believe anyone would have had an issue. God has attributes that are both male and female and things we can't even relate to.
...
Seriously God is. His attributes and actions can be compared to that of both men and women.....heck, His constant love and affection is also similar to my dog but it doesn't make Him a dog.
...
I'm sorry about your early loss and blessed to see that God was able to fill the needs you have in His abundance. I hope that you see with all the good teaching that has gone on, what the difference is between Jesus being mother and Jesus acting as a mother.
Or even better - we can take the grace He gives us and work our butt off to seek and apply healing to our lives--instead of just staying wounded and seeking comfort. Jesus doesn't just suffer and die- He is resurrected. Too many people use Jesus as a crutch- and an excuse to stay wounded and victimized their whole lives. Yes, He is a comfort. Yes, Jesus might mirculously in one fail swoop heal us--but more often than not--as with all things we have to participate in redemption by going past being coddled, and work to heal ourselves. He gives us the strength and fortitude and courage to facilitate our healing, be we have to go out and pursue that peace.
I am sorry you lost your mom. That is a tragedy, for sure. But hopefully you aren't still defining relationships by that loss. If you are then you have my prayers-if you aren't, you have them anyway.
I am only sharing about how Jesus was like a mother to me and healed some deep emotional needs in me. I can't believe that some people could read the different posts on this subject that I have written and be upset with my sharing. All I wanted to do is talk about Jesus...
While Mary certainly is our Mother Jesus is the greater Mother as he feeds and nourishes our souls with His very own Body and Blood.
This is all too sad...Can't we just talk about Jesus and how He heals the motherless and fatherless? Why make a big issue out of this just because I didn't include Mary in my topic? Can't you see the true heart of the matter? Wouldn't it be better if you are offended that you just moved on instead of debating a very sensitive issue? Please permit those of us who have experienced Christ in this way the freedom of expressing what has been our healing and may possibly be healing for others.
"I will not leave you as orphans. I will come to you." (Christ-The gospel of John.)
Seriously let's not over react too much.
If Kisstheson had said, Jesus nurtured me like a mother, I don't believe anyone would have had an issue. God has attributes that are both male and female and things we can't even relate to.
[/quote]Annie's addition of the inaccurate translations is what leads this thread down the bad path but I'm sure no harm was intended and that has clearly been corrected.
I spent time in a liberal protestant community that tried to define God as female every time they had a chance. Quite disturbing and totally unnecessary. "Ruah is a feminine word and is the Holy Spirit so the Holy Spirit must be female." That type of stuff. One of the girls in my youth group at the time said, "So because the word "table" has a feminine form all tables are female?"
Seriously God is. His attributes and actions can be compared to that of both men and women.....heck, His constant love and affection is also similar to my dog but it doesn't make Him a dog.
Kisstheson,
I'm sorry about your early loss and blessed to see that God was able to fill the needs you have in His abundance. I hope that you see with all the good teaching that has gone on, what the difference is between Jesus being mother and Jesus acting as a mother.
May you be blessed.
I am not saying Blessed Juliana's Theology is not tricky and complex. It is. But it can be validly expressed. Remember one of the earliest representations of Christ was as a mother Pelican. In many ways the mystical side of the theology stems from that. And I didn't read anything in Kisstheson's analysis that is unorthodox.
I do understand the worry of some. Given how modernism twists things in this day and age...this type of expression is right in the wheelhouse for misinterpretation. But I will not start kicking valid mystics to the curb because modernist heresy attempts to appropriate them.
It is the theology of the Church we must stand firm in, not the theology of mystics David.That is all the more reason to stand firm with the correct expression of their work and theology in the light of the Truth in Church teaching.
Just because a mystic wrote something that does not elevate it to the level of Divine Revelation or make it appropriate for our use today.
What was more easily understood in a time centuries removed from ours, does not mean it is well understood in our time, or even right to use.
The CHURCH has never sanctioned called God/Jesus "Our Mother".
It is the theology of the Church we must stand firm in, not the theology of mystics David.
David, are you saying Pope Benedict is wrong?And the words of our Pope Benedict XVI"Even if we can't give absolutely cogent reasons, the language of the prayer of the entire Bible remains normative for us, in which, the great metaphors of maternal love notwithstanding, 'mother' is not a title of God, and is not an appellation with which one may address God. We must pray as Jesus, on the basis of the Holy Scripture, has taught us to pray, not as it might strike us or please us. Only thus do we pray in the right way."
Jesus of Nazareth
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?