• Starting today August 7th, 2024, in order to post in the Married Couples, Courting Couples, or Singles forums, you will not be allowed to post if you have your Marital status designated as private. Announcements will be made in the respective forums as well but please note that if yours is currently listed as Private, you will need to submit a ticket in the Support Area to have yours changed.

It's Never "Just a Movie"

coastie

Hallelujah Adonai Yeshua!
Apr 6, 2002
5,400
48
45
Central Valley of CA
Visit site
✟8,286.00
Faith
Baptist
Marital Status
Married
Politics
US-Libertarian
IT'S NEVER 'JUST A MOVIE'

by Chris M. Leland, Ph.D.
Senior Fellow – Christian Worldview Studies
Focus on the Family Institute When I fly, God puts me next to people who want to talk. The conversation usually stays on small talk until they ask the inevitable question; “So, what do you do for a living?” I know that my answer is going to elicit one of two responses; either a pronounced look of disapproval and disagreement or (more often) a glazed and confused face. When I say that I teach Christian Worldview Studies for the Focus on the Family Institute, they either bristle at their “luck” of being placed next to a religious fanatic, or they have no earthly idea what I do.

On a flight last year, the latter was the case. A woman in her mid 50’s who had been visiting her new grandbaby asked what I did. There it was; the glazed, empty, and perplexed look. Then something caught her attention and she shared that she was a Christian, but she said it under her breath, leaning in toward me, like it was some secret password and that at any moment we would be discovered and thrown out of the plane at 30,000 feet. A fellow believer — hey, this flight wouldn’t be too bad. At least I wasn’t going to play Paul to an “Athenian” this trip.

She wasn’t done though. She wanted to know more about this idea called “worldview.” Ah, here comes the flight-long discussion. I briefly talked about how our lives as Christians must be lived with every part of who we are being directed by our Christian perspective. There it was again; that glazed look that shouted “Huh?”

So I tried a new approach. “What’s that book you’re reading?” She gave me the name of one of the latest best sellers. “Who’s the author?” She flipped to the inside of the back book jacket and showed me his handsome picture and the brief description of who he was and his accomplishments. “Do you like his writing?” Yes, very much.

“Why do you like his writing?”

Silence.

It didn’t last forever, of course. She finally let me know that his stories were not only entertaining and easy to read, but they spoke to her and her life’s circumstance. Now, here comes the clincher: “Do the author and story have a perspective or lesson we are supposed to learn about life?” Oh, yes. We’re supposed to love one another and our families must be cared for, even when it was hard.

Good. But then I continued probing: “Where does the author come from on these issues? What’s his perspective on life?” More silence. Then she said the words I hear so often. “It’s just a book!”

No it’s not. When it comes to the things we read or see or use to entertain us, it’s never “just a book” — or “just a song” or “just a movie” or “just a TV show.” It’s always got something to say about how we think and feel, good or bad. And if we keep reading or watching or listening, it’s liable to affect how we think and feel, good or bad.

For years I’ve taught communication students and now that I teach worldview issues, I see the significance of entertainment more than ever. What has concerned me more and more in recent years is that I am hearing this from otherwise discerning Christians. They’re people of faith who struggle over most decisions in their lives as it relates to their Christianity and wanting to make wise choices, but when it comes to the media, they look just like everyone else on the planet.

This isn’t an accident. Many of us make our media choices precisely because we want to be like everyone else — or at least like a certain group of people we know. I have a Christian friend who will whisper to me that he is a “closet” Sex in the City watcher. He’s in the “closet” around fellow Christians, that is. When pushed on why he watches it, he admits that it’s the main conversation piece on certain days of the week at his office and he doesn’t want to be excluded from the conversation.

Even when we’re not trying to join the crowd, we may end up becoming like them simply by default. Frequently we use media simply for a diversion. How often do you sit down in front of the tube and say, “You know, I want to find something on that is mindless and I can just veg out to”? We think it’s harmless enough. Yet research shows that this is the state of mind that makes us the most vulnerable to ideas we don’t usually agree with. Why do you think advertisers have so much impact on our culture? They hit you when you think you’re not paying attention and aren’t impacted by their message.

As C.S. Lewis sarcastically wrote,

Avoid silence, avoid solitude, avoid any train of thought that leads off the beaten track. Concentrate on money, sex, status, health and (above all) on your own grievances. Keep the radio on. Live in a crowd. Use plenty of sedation. If you must read books, select them very carefully. But you’d be safer to stick to the papers. You’ll find the advertisements helpful; especially those with a sexy or a snobbish appeal. (Christian Reflections, pp. 168-169)

The Christian community must do a better job of showing people how to ask the questions that make a person media literate. If we are indeed the “royal priesthood” that we are described as, then our job description includes the command of Ezekiel 44:23, “They are to teach my people the difference between the holy and the common and show them how to distinguish between the unclean and the clean.” We must live not as passive sponges but as mindful agents.

As Bill Romanowski (author and Calvin College professor) says, “There’s some good stuff out there and lots of bad stuff and, if people are going to live as mature Christians, they’re going to have to learn to tell the difference.”
Every book has a perspective. Every TV show was written, directed and produced by people with perspectives and worldviews. Every article of every magazine that sits on the shelves of our local bookstore or airport gift shop has a perspective. And yes, every movie that hits the silver screen has a worldview driving it.

Our call is not to abandon the media, but to make ourselves “priests” of the culture and help our brothers and sisters in Christ understand that, “It’s never just a movie."


So, what are your opinions?

Zach
 

admtaylor

Well-Known Member
Aug 9, 2003
1,171
83
51
Overland Park, Kansas
Visit site
✟1,768.00
Faith
Non-Denom
Marital Status
Married
Awesome Zach!!! I think this article hits the nail on the head so hard that it drove it through the board and clean out the other side. Even those of faith spend so much time shaping their subconcious with media that isn't pleasing to God. It's no wonder so much is acceptable in the church these days. AMEN!!! And may God save us from this machine that can drain our moral energy.
 
Upvote 0

the Colonel

STARGATE SG-1!
Oct 1, 2003
3,330
184
52
Michigan
Visit site
✟8,067.00
Faith
Baptist
Marital Status
Married
Politics
US-Constitution
There are a couple shows my wife and I watch in order to hone our skills/arguments against the opinions and beliefs put forth on them. We discuss what God has to say about that stuff. I think it's a good way to practice how to make arguments against secular reasoning.

But, in general, I do agree with the sentiment of the article. Garbage in -- Garbage Out. :)

--the Colonel
 
Upvote 0

catch22

Filmmaker for Christ
Sep 17, 2003
656
11
42
Colorado...In 2 weeks, Georgia ;)
Visit site
✟23,358.00
Faith
Christian
I admit, I watch all kinds of movies, and I enjoy all kinds of movies. I am a filmmaker however, and as such it's vital for me to learn technique from those who make films for a living. Perhaps someday, given the opportunity I can put positive messages out there, but for now I have to keep studying regardless of the content. Perhaps I'm not strong enough in my faith yet, but I enjoy movies like Kill Bill. The language and violence presented don't disturb to the point where I refuse to watch it.
 
Upvote 0

admtaylor

Well-Known Member
Aug 9, 2003
1,171
83
51
Overland Park, Kansas
Visit site
✟1,768.00
Faith
Non-Denom
Marital Status
Married
catch22 said:
I admit, I watch all kinds of movies, and I enjoy all kinds of movies. I am a filmmaker however, and as such it's vital for me to learn technique from those who make films for a living. Perhaps someday, given the opportunity I can put positive messages out there, but for now I have to keep studying regardless of the content. Perhaps I'm not strong enough in my faith yet, but I enjoy movies like Kill Bill. The language and violence presented don't disturb to the point where I refuse to watch it.
Do you think that God approves of such movies? That's where we need to focus the attention.
 
Upvote 0

EliasEmmanuel

Gomi No Sensei
Apr 20, 2002
748
42
45
Camdenton, Missouri
Visit site
✟23,787.00
Faith
Protestant
admtaylor said:
Do you think that God approves of such movies? That's where we need to focus the attention.
Personally, I think the above essay (and most similar advisories I've seen from "family values" oriented sources) sort of throw out the baby with the bathwater. IMO there's more to whether a movie (or book, or song) "Glorifies God" than whether it contains violence, profanity or sexual content.

An obvious example would be To End Al Wars, the WWII drama directed by Jerry Jenkins' son which deals with the events that transpired in a Japanese prison camp during the war.... and is rated R. It deals openly with the effect of the Gospel on oppressed people, but takes place in the kind of prison camp (it's a true story) where the wardens would routinely beat people to death or shoot them if they slowed down.

That's an obvious example, but there's probably multitudes of others.... Schlindler's List springs to mind, though I woke up too recently to be able to think of too many offhand ;) IMO you can't deal with redemption on a very deep level until you deal with the needs for it, and thus sin.

I mean, I know of a Christian movie review site that says, in no uncertain terms, that anything unsuitable for a 6 year old is unsuitable for any Christian. I know that's not what this essay is saying, but I do think it more or less ignores context. For my part I'm more concerned with how violence, sex etc are handled that whether they're there.

To ask the obvious question, does God automatically DISprove of movies (books, music etc.) that contain accounts of sin?
 
Upvote 0

BarbB

I stand with my brothers and sisters in Israel!
Aug 6, 2003
14,246
508
77
NJ summers; FL winters
✟33,048.00
Faith
Messianic
Politics
US-Republican
EliasEmmanuel said:
To ask the obvious question, does God automatically DISprove of movies (books, music etc.) that contain accounts of sin?
No, I don't think so. But the Holy Spirit works differently in each of us. I am a 2-1/2 year old Christian who spent most of her life in the slime of bad books, bad movies, bad company, on and on. Now, I cannot comfortable watch most commercial movies, read contemporary fiction, listen to regular music. Instead I have found that Christian fiction is actually as well written as the average romance novel, that Christian music is better than regular contemporary music, and movies - well that's a whole different thing. I'm in a little trouble there. My point is that I'm on a very short curb chain for my protection! and I love it!

I think the key is to not go where we are uncomfortable going. If you hear that little voice in your ear "don't go there" then don't.
 
Upvote 0

EliasEmmanuel

Gomi No Sensei
Apr 20, 2002
748
42
45
Camdenton, Missouri
Visit site
✟23,787.00
Faith
Protestant
newlamb said:
My point is that I'm on a very short curb chain for my protection! and I love it!

I think the key is to not go where we are uncomfortable going. If you hear that little voice in your ear "don't go there" then don't.
Oh, absolutely. And more power to you.

My point was, I guess, that we run into trouble when we try to dictate the the boundaries for absolutely everyone.

Instead I have found that Christian fiction is actually as well written as the average romance novel, that Christian music is better than regular contemporary music
That's not necessarily saying much ;-) But I get your point....
 
Upvote 0

admtaylor

Well-Known Member
Aug 9, 2003
1,171
83
51
Overland Park, Kansas
Visit site
✟1,768.00
Faith
Non-Denom
Marital Status
Married
Newlamb,

I relate to your statement more than you could even know. I'm in the same place. Hang in there, and keep enjoying the good stuff.

Elias,

Movies like Kill Bill and other violence ridden and sex ridden films are worthless. Not redeaming in any way. The show mentioned in the article, Sex in the City, celebrates promicuity. These things aren't for Christians. Your examples are another story all together, but if it includes a pointless sex scene then the baby can go out with the bath water.
 
Upvote 0

EliasEmmanuel

Gomi No Sensei
Apr 20, 2002
748
42
45
Camdenton, Missouri
Visit site
✟23,787.00
Faith
Protestant
admtaylor said:
Movies like Kill Bill and other violence ridden and sex ridden films are worthless. Not redeaming in any way. The show mentioned in the article, Sex in the City, celebrates promicuity. These things aren't for Christians. Your examples are another story all together, but if it includes a pointless sex scene then the baby can go out with the bath water.
I didn't defend Kill Bill or Sex and the City. I've never watched the latter, and have no plans to see the former because more and more I think Tarantino would be a great filmmaker if only he'd grow up a little.

My point is.... well, okay, so one unnecessary scene always invalidates a movie completely? Example; I used to watch Oz with one of my roommates sometimes, and though I can't recommend Oz to ANYone, there were times when the show handled God, redemption and ethics in ways that absolutely floored me. I'm glad I saw those episodes.

My point isn't that everybody needs to watch violent, sexy movies..... heck, a _lot_ of what comes out of Hollywood is ****. My point is that context matters and there's no one standard for absolutely everyone that's the official "Christian Standard of Movie watching". And that "bidden or unbidden, God is present", often in places we don't expect. That seems to be His confusing way.

To relate it to scripture..... I'm not going to criticize someone whose convictions say they can't drink. And I won't have my glass of wine in front of them. But I'm also not going to accept the criticism of someone who says no one anywhere should ever drink alcohol (a la romans 14 and surrounding scriptures). Yes, I know this is a dodgy issue to compare it to, and I don't want to get into that, but I hope you see what I'm getting at. "Rated R for violence" isn't a suitable reason, IMO, to dismiss a movie altogether, but if it's your conviction not to watch it, far be it from me to criticize that.
 
Upvote 0

Lotar

Swift Eagle Justice
Feb 27, 2003
8,163
445
44
Southern California
✟27,144.00
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Faith
Eastern Orthodox
Marital Status
Married
Just to clarify, Kill Bill doesn't have sex in it.

I never mind movies with violence, they just never had any affect on me. I don't watch movies with sex and nudity, like Cabin Fever. And I especially hate movies that mock God, like The Others.

I think it just comes down to what God convicts you on. I had no problem watching Kill Bill. Sure it had tons of violence, but the language was pretty tame for an R rated flick, especially considering it was Tarantino. It had it's share of f's and c's, but tally it up to your average war movie and it's not bad. Unless your a kid who has a problem with taking movies too seriously, I don't see what the big deal is about violence.
 
Upvote 0

catch22

Filmmaker for Christ
Sep 17, 2003
656
11
42
Colorado...In 2 weeks, Georgia ;)
Visit site
✟23,358.00
Faith
Christian
The bible itself is violent in certain places...that doesn't mean we shouldn't read it. I just don't understand how me reading a book by one of the great authors of all time (East of Eden for example) can be looked down upon simply because it presents ideas which aren't totally consistent with Christian ideals. When I'm reading such books, and watching such movies, I'm not rooting for the wicked ones to prevail or anything. I'm hoping for enlightenment and understanding. Nothing can ever change without understanding. To understand our world and the people therein, it's crucial to get inside there heads so to speak. I don't mean to wallow in the dark reccesses by any means, but discover truth or lack thereof in the interest of giving truth.
 
Upvote 0

Godsgrace

Active Member
Oct 24, 2003
89
3
74
Maryland, USA
Visit site
✟219.00
Faith
Non-Denom
We are human... We can not be faithful in our walk with CHRIST unless we realize our weaknesses. Movies, books, and cartoons, you don't really know what to exspect until you view it. The decission is yours and only yours. If in question? Ask the FATHER through JESUS Name. You will get your answer. I have walked away from many shows because it just did not feel good to me. But, I asked first :)
 
Upvote 0