Starting today August 7th, 2024, in order to post in the Married Couples, Courting Couples, or Singles forums, you will not be allowed to post if you have your Marital status designated as private. Announcements will be made in the respective forums as well but please note that if yours is currently listed as Private, you will need to submit a ticket in the Support Area to have yours changed.
How can God give certainty, if you already admitted, your perception of this God, can be fallible.
Relying on something that is fallible, can never give you certainty, because of this fallibility.
Who said there is no doubt that God does not exist?
Have you paid any attention to people's positions after all this time?
I have always said, I do not believe that a God exists and I see no reason to believe a God exists, but I may be wrong.
Have you paid any attention to people's positions after all this time?
I have always said, I do not believe that a God exists and I see no reason to believe a God exists, but I may be wrong.
That's good! I'm glad you can admit that.
Just like you can admit that you may be wrong about a god existing...
You seem to want to sneak in certainty by the back door, as it were.Can you see how my beliefs and God can be seen as separate things?
My beliefs are fallible. God is not.
If God were fallible, He would not be God.
If my beliefs were infallible, they would cease to be beliefs.
Actually, I have to admit that I am indeed "certain" that I exist (in the spirit of "I think therefore I am"). But I really do believe this is clearly a special case that has to do with the fundamental way the world is structured, namely that each thinking individual - person, dog, cat, whatever - has immediate access to its own thoughts and sensations, and even though we can imagine that such thoughts and sensations do not necessarily accurately describe the world out there, it is nigh on impossible to imagine there is not "something" that is thinking those thoughts.Would you ever deny that you exist?
You seem to want to sneak in certainty by the back door, as it were.
I suspect all agree that:
1. It is possible that God exists;
2. It is possible that God has perfect knowledge;
3. It is possible that God transmits knowledge to you.
I think what bothers us all is your claim of certainty. Granted, you concede that, apart from a connection to God, all knowledge you have would be uncertain. So far so good. But you assert that you have a "pipeline" to God and that He downloads "perfect, certain" knowledge to you. And, presto, you claim certainty about such downloaded knowledge.
This is highly suspicious (to me at least) for at least the following three reasons:
1. I have known fellow Christians who made similar claims, yet the way they lived and the things they said suggested not only that such claims to perfect knowledge were incorrect, these people were "out of touch with reality" to a rather disturbing degree. Granted, I would not say this was true of many Christians but I will make the following claim admitting it is based solely on my anecdotal experience: The more certain believers seem to be, the less functional, stable, and mature they seem to be.
2. More importantly, it is my own personal experience that it is more or less impossible to clearly categorize my own thoughts and beliefs as to whether they are "generated by me" or "generated by God". In fact, I doubt such a distinction makes practical sense.
Most definitely. That´s the core of the problem of your arguments, after all.Can you see how my beliefs and God can be seen as separate things?
One of your beliefs is that a God exists.My beliefs are fallible. God is not.
If God were fallible, He would not be God.
If my beliefs were infallible, they would cease to be beliefs.
You clearly did not understand my point but that might be at least partially my fault. I will try to be very precise: Since you agree that we cannot disentangle thoughts generated by ourselves from those generated by God, we cannot be sure that any thought is our own is put there by God. You seem to want to maintain this distinction between the uncertain creaturely thoughts generated by you, and the "certain" thoughts that God has sent you.I would agree with this, which is why I've said many times that I continually deny myself and trust God as much as I can.
Most definitely. That´s the core of the problem of your arguments, after all.
One of your beliefs is that a God exists.
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?