• Starting today August 7th, 2024, in order to post in the Married Couples, Courting Couples, or Singles forums, you will not be allowed to post if you have your Marital status designated as private. Announcements will be made in the respective forums as well but please note that if yours is currently listed as Private, you will need to submit a ticket in the Support Area to have yours changed.

Havoc

Celtic Witch
Jul 26, 2002
4,652
91
63
Realityville
Visit site
✟29,135.00
Faith
Pagan
I talk to God daily. He told me long ago not to worry about the Bible since He didn't write it.
 
Upvote 0

PaladinValer

Traditional Orthodox Anglican
Apr 7, 2004
23,587
1,245
44
Myrtle Beach, SC
✟30,305.00
Faith
Anglican
Marital Status
Single
Politics
US-Others

Here's something that is Biblical: "Do not bear false witness against your neighbor." The idea of chi/ki is one's soul or consciousness for Buddhists (since they [or at least orthodox Buddhists] do not believe in a "self"). That's it. That's their actual, true belief of what Reality is. And Christianity agrees that we do have a soul. If you knock their's, you've just denied orthodox Christian doctrine yourself. No way around it.

And here's another fact: the martial arts teaches that one's power comes from their soul or consciousness. THEIR'S. Not a different spirit's that invades; THEIR'S. Anyone whose ever read their religious texts knows that what I've said is true.

And for the last fact: the martial arts doesn't teach a person that it makes a person a god. It simply teaches discipline, inner harmony, outer harmony, respect, diligance, and self-esteem.
 
Upvote 0

PaladinValer

Traditional Orthodox Anglican
Apr 7, 2004
23,587
1,245
44
Myrtle Beach, SC
✟30,305.00
Faith
Anglican
Marital Status
Single
Politics
US-Others
Tomk80, thank you. I know I sounded a little edgy in that post, but I'm just tired of fellow Christians talking trash about things, as you point out, that they have no idea about.

Luckily, I've taken some world religions classes, do individual study on all world religions, and have some non-Christian religious texts, so I think I've got a good idea on what different non-Christian religions teach and practice. Not that I'm going to convert, but so that I'm not ignorant when I talk about them. In fact, I'm always surprised in how many non-Christian beliefs and practices are the same, are similar, or are reconcilable with those of orthodox Christianity, and the philosophy behind the martial arts is definitely very reconcilable and similar.
 
Upvote 0

Proud Hindu

Veteran
Feb 10, 2004
1,018
41
✟1,394.00
Faith
Hindu
On the topic of prana, check out this pic of a Hindu sage who has gained control of Prana, and can utilize the power stored in the kundalini serpent at the base of the spine at will:

Meditating in the Himalayas for days:
http://www.atributetohinduism.com/images/yogi_himalaya3.JPG

For contrast, Indian army soldiers must dress like this, and only can stay outside for a few hours, or they will freeze to death:
http://www.bharat-rakshak.com/LAND-FORCES/Army/Articles/Article15a.jpg

Some true incidents of Hindu Saints utilizing Prana/Chi

An experience of the great Yogi Shri Paramahansa Yogananda



Recently in the news, there was the story of a Hindu Yogi, who had meditated under water for fifty years. He did not eat, he did not sleep, he did not breathe during this time. It was so unbelievable that many claimed it was a hoax, but upon checking his birth certificate, everything corresponded.
 
Upvote 0

vajradhara

Diamond Thunderbolt of Indestructable Wisdom
Jun 25, 2003
9,403
466
57
Dharmadhatu
✟34,720.00
Faith
Buddhist
Marital Status
In Relationship
Politics
US-Others
Namaste all,


interesting discussion.

i've enjoyed it thus far.

i would like to make a small correction to the record, however. Chi does not correspond with the Buddhist idea of consciousness. Chi is prajna.. the "breath of life" in the Tantric practices and is not considered consciousness.

having gotten that out of the way... to the OP.. yes, Chi/ki is real.. well... it's as real as you are it is a physiological phenomena that is produced by causes and conditions that are favorable to it.. i.e. a biological form and the presence of consciousness, at least from the Buddhist point of view.

like any other natual attribute of the body, it can be developed through practice, usually meditation, to an enhanced capability.

homebound is right on track.. this is the same thing that allows a mother to pick up a car off her trapped child... we could probably make a good argument that most extraordinary physical feats are accomplished through reliance on prajna or Chi.

to explore this topic from a Taoist point of view will take us down some slightly less worn path ways my practice experience in this regard is limited to a very specific school of Taoist praxis and thus, i wouldn't be able to present an overall view of the concept from the Taoist view.
 
Upvote 0

Tomk80

Titleless
Apr 27, 2004
11,570
429
45
Maastricht
Visit site
✟36,582.00
Faith
Agnostic
Although I do not deem the above picture impossible, it does seem a strange picture to me. Somehow the distances between the Hindu sage in front and the mountainrange in back doesn't seem right. Anyone else any informed judgement? I'll try to show it to some people who are able to make a more informed judgement.

Some true incidents of Hindu Saints utilizing Prana/Chi
This might well be an urban legend or a story which is designed to teach a certain moral. How long ago did this take place according to the source? None of the people are named, and for me it would be quite hard to check on it (even if I wanted to).

An experience of the great Yogi Shri Paramahansa Yogananda
I do not doubt the great Yogi had a vision, however, for me this is by no means proof that the Yogi experienced something which was really going on somewhere else.


Sources please?

I do see Chi as a real occurrence, which enables us to do things which are deemed impossible by people who aren't trained in it. However, I am very skeptical about the more extreme claims you are making here. If you can point me to people who can perform these features at present (especially the second one would be nice), I will be happy to try and raise the money to go to them and see for myself.
 
Upvote 0

Fiendishjester

Devil's advocate
Jun 28, 2003
374
2
in a field of pure consciousness
✟534.00
Faith
Hindu
Politics
US-Democrat
First of all, giving Kundalini a negative connotation because it is related to the word "Serpent" is useless for two reasons:

1. Kundalini is called "Serpent power" because the energy is said to be coiled at the base of the spine, akin to the way a snake sits when coiled. Besides the way in which the energy is stored, there is no relation between serpents and Kundalini.

2. Even if Kundalini had a direct relation to Serpents, it would not mean much. Only in Western Abrahamic religion is the serpent associated with negativity and evil. In most Eastern Religions, like Hinduism, snakes are associated with wisdom, mysticism, and healing. It is useless to argue that the Abrahamic interpretation of the serpent as a deceiver and an evil entity is superior, because it cannot, and has never been, proven to be so.

Secondly, the energy of Kundalini is not an outside force, nor is Chi/Ki/Prana for that matter. Chi is something that is created internally, and flows through the body at all times. Kundalini is energy that you are born with, and lays latent inside you until harnessed. It is not possible for something you are born with and constantly operate with to be demonic or external in origin.
 
Upvote 0

Tomk80

Titleless
Apr 27, 2004
11,570
429
45
Maastricht
Visit site
✟36,582.00
Faith
Agnostic
And as an afterthought (with regards to the people who looked at the picture):
How do you know he is meditating there for days? I couldn't find anything on this on the site. If he just meditated for a short time, he could have made it without great training (although he probably would have left his rock a little bit blue in the face ).

edited to correct some terrible spelling mistakes
 
Upvote 0

Proud Hindu

Veteran
Feb 10, 2004
1,018
41
✟1,394.00
Faith
Hindu

I’m no expert on photography, let me know what they say


This might well be an urban legend or a story which is designed to teach a certain moral. How long ago did this take place according to the source? None of the people are named, and for me it would be quite hard to check on it (even if I wanted to).

Yes, I should have given the source, it is from the classic book Autobiography of a Yogi. The incident takes place in the early 1900’s, I will give you an exact date as soon as I find the book. As to its validity, there are those who witnessed it, but I cannot promise to find too much more info on them, as only their first names are given.



Mata Amritanandamayi Devi has been seen to accomplish many amazing Yogic feats, indeed many of Her devotees believe Her to be a God-Realized Soul. Her website is www.ammachi.org She goes on a world tour every year, actually I would highly recommend you to attend it. And of course as a true Saint she does not exploit anyone, you will not have to “raise money” to see Her.



Heh, true I must admit I have no clue as to how long he’s been meditating, but my guess is that he wouldn’t go all the way to the Himalayas to meditate for a few minutes. And as he seems to be a Yogi as a living, as can be seen by the long matted hair - Most Yogis spend days in Samadhi.


Another dramatic examples as to the control of Prana/Chi, you may be familiar with the Indian tradition of Thimiti, or fire walking. This requrires great control over the body:

http://www.noren.nu/4s7/8.jpg
http://cullin.org/cbt/image/14-5.jpg
 
Upvote 0

Tomk80

Titleless
Apr 27, 2004
11,570
429
45
Maastricht
Visit site
✟36,582.00
Faith
Agnostic
Proud Hindu said:
I’m no expert on photography, let me know what they say
Till now they give the same opinion as me. The shadow on the yogi seems different from the shading on the background. Also, the distances between foreground and background seem a bit sketchy. However, the resolution of the photo isn't very high, so it's hard to tell. I'd say, not guilty untill proven otherwise.


Although I don't doubt their sincerity, I approach these accounts with the same skepticism as the stories of Jesus' appearance after his death. The possibility has been raised that this is a mass (well, not exactly a mass ) hallucination.


I will definitely try to go and see her. I would have been more than willing to pay for it, but then again, if I don't have to...


I actually found the meditating yogi on the site. Didn't give a timeframe though. It states that he is able to ignore his senses through meditation. This can mean different things. It could also mean that he can stay out in the cold for a reasonably long time (although not exceptional), but doesn't get to uncomfortable by it. Much like the firewalking below.

Another dramatic examples as to the control of Prana/Chi, you may be familiar with the Indian tradition of Thimiti, or fire walking. This requrires great control over the body:

http://www.noren.nu/4s7/8.jpg
http://cullin.org/cbt/image/14-5.jpg
Here I go again. I've actually seen people doing this without training on tv. Some guy in the Netherlands (my beautifull homecountry which I left some 3 months ago) named Emiel Ratelband, holds seminars which are supposed to give people confidence in themselves. At the end of the seminar he challenges the people to walk over glowing coals, as in the pictures. Although he has been sued a couple of times because of people burning their feet (apparently they weren't confident enough ) , most people actually perform this feat. The guy is nuts, but hey, it works.
But I know yogis to perform amazing feats, just as I already mentioned from the shaolin monks. Mastery of Chi means, as far as I am concerned, having a great understanding of your body and the energyflows within it. This gives you an enourmous potential, as well as inner harmony (which eventually is the objective of the training one goes through). And you feel great and relaxt after doing exercises based on the concept of chi. I would recommend it to anybody for the wholesome effect it has.
 
Upvote 0

peaceful soul

Senior Veteran
Sep 4, 2003
5,986
184
✟7,592.00
Faith
Non-Denom
Havoc said:
I talk to God daily. He told me long ago not to worry about the Bible since He didn't write it.

I really do not thnk that God would confuse us with different messages, Havoc. I know God through Christ, and everything that He has proclaimed, has come to fruition as per Bible and His spoken words to me. He also tells me and shows me that all other attempts to know Him are futile, except throug Holy Spirit. God has to draw you toward Him in order for you to have a relationship with Him. He has to reform your spiritual nature and cleanse it from sin. He will not accept anything that you offer on your own. It is only through Holy Spirit that you come to know how to worship and to please Him.So I guess we will have to disagree, and we will find out in the future what really is true.
 
Upvote 0

peaceful soul

Senior Veteran
Sep 4, 2003
5,986
184
✟7,592.00
Faith
Non-Denom

Yep, I also get suspicious when people try to incorporate things into their lives and not let God develop them the way that He sees fit. I also get suspicious when we believe that noone should be bold enough to speak truth. We have this built in skepticism that noone has "the truth"; so we must be so cautious about how we say things. I say it is truth according to Bible.

Yes, many people will interpret Bible to say almost anything, anyways. I am relying upon God as He teaches me, opposed to my opinion of what Bible says or does not say. I hope that helps you to see where my authority comes from. We are to seek understanding, wisdom, and knowledge from God and not from ourselves.

When people want to tap into energies and energy fields: that is not kosher. There is nothing that Holy Spirit can not protect me or any other person who obeys Christ from and give him strenght to do. That is the mindset that a Christian is to use in His life. We are to totally rely upon God for all things. When we try to manage our own affairs 1st, we are telling God that He is not in front and center of our lives.

If I remember correctly. I said spirits and forces. That would include concepts of chi. My point was:
Tapping into "psychic energies" or "ki" or "chi" is an occultic practice. Any religious practice to seek spiritual gain without God is wrong/

There are some martial arts that are spiritually less threatening than others for Christians, but that does not mean that they are safe to practice. If it is possible to emphasize the phyiscal aspects and not dwelve into the spiritual/mystical aspects of Eastern practices, you may be correct in your beliefs. We also have to be careful of not putting ourselves into altered states, where we allow ourselves to be seduced by other spirits/entities or whatever you want to call them.

For a Christian, God comes first and anything that oposes our spiritual development or that can not be obtained via Holy Spirit is a rebellion to God, and His spirit will not strive with us in those cases. We grieve His spirit whenever we go another way.

So, I hope that things are much clearer now. To all of you who think I am judging you, you are wrong. I am stating principles laid forth from Bible. If you think that I am in error, then you can take me to task with scripture. If you can not find any, then let it be.

Before posting, I thought that I would see how others would see this issue; so I am posting a few paragraphs I found interesting from a website. I will not disclose it yet. I just want you to tell me what you think of the following quotes:

The Chi (Ki) Force. Various martial artists assert that learning to develop and use chi - an alleged mystical force that pervades the universe - is the ultimate means of attaining high proficiency in the
fighting arts. Some believe that "in the Asian system of Martial Arts, ch'i is directed by will power to specific points of the body, resulting in apparently paranormal feats of strength and control."

Practically everyone acknowledges that the traditional concept of chi is deeply rooted in Eastern religion and philosophy. "In the Orient we apply the word ki ('chi') to the state which is also the real
nature of the universe," wrote leading aikido authority Koichi Tohei. "Ki has no beginning and no end; its absolute value neither increases nor decreases. We are one with the universal, and our lives are part of the life of the universal." Tohei's understanding of chi, in line with traditional views of other martial artists, strongly suggests a monistic and pantheistic world view. As stated above, this is incompatible with historic Christianity.

Still, there remains the issue of explaining superhuman acts typically attributed to chi, such as the smashing of multiple slabs of ice with a single blow. Some insist that the only explanation possible is the power of chi. Those on the opposite side of the spectrum, however, believe such exhibitions are accomplished by rigorous conditioning, simple physics, and good technique which, at times, is aided with a dash of trickery (as in the case of thawing the slabs of ice with hot wire). Some have suggested that perhaps certain biochemical reactions - such as an adrenaline surge - may also be involved.


Disclaimer: the above quote is not necessarily my take, but a tool to get you to think. Read it with as little discrimination as possible.
 
Upvote 0

PaladinValer

Traditional Orthodox Anglican
Apr 7, 2004
23,587
1,245
44
Myrtle Beach, SC
✟30,305.00
Faith
Anglican
Marital Status
Single
Politics
US-Others
No, you do not remember correctly. Chi/ki is the consciousness or soul. Christianity has the same idea. I've got their scriptures right here, in my hands, and nothing says chi/ki has anything remote quantity what Christians would call alien spirits or occult practices.

Don't believe me? Check it out yourself, but this brick wall arguement is beying dropped by moi and I wouldn't be surprised if others were sick of it also.
 
Upvote 0

Tomk80

Titleless
Apr 27, 2004
11,570
429
45
Maastricht
Visit site
✟36,582.00
Faith
Agnostic
p I hear a lot of christians say the same as you, peaceful soul, namely that they come to their particular view on wisdom and truth through God. However, they come to different conclusions about the bible than you do. Some of these differences are minor, some are completely opposite. Why? Why are you correct?

A friend of mine went to a monestary for a weekend. The nons there practiced meditation as a way to get closer to God (by using God or God's eternal love as a focus point). I don't think you have to practice aikido without God.

Again, I think it is very much possible to practice martial arts without going against your spiritual developement as a christian. However, this is something every christian will have to sort out for him/herself.

In the quote you gave chi is a mystical force. However, according to Paladin Valer it is the soul. According to others it is 'the life force', which for me would mean the same as the christian concept of soul. The difference in interpretation can be caused by the difference in culture.
Your answer is clear to me, I only disagree in the interpretation of what chi refers to. Then again, I'm not christian, nor buddist nor hindu. I don't agree with the idea that there are other spirits/forces than the one which is your own, and maybe God. This is where we truly disagree.
 
Upvote 0

Fiendishjester

Devil's advocate
Jun 28, 2003
374
2
in a field of pure consciousness
✟534.00
Faith
Hindu
Politics
US-Democrat
Why would tapping into ki go against God? If it is something we are born with, it must also be one of God's creations, there for a purpose. Christians take medicine or undergo surgery to cure illnesses, and using ki is along the exact same lines. In fact, I'd say that using ki, an internal energy that is part of you and part of God's creation, is more Christian than swallowing pills, which is a human creation (and therefore only indirectly God's) to cure your ills.
 
Upvote 0

povman

Junior Member
Oct 24, 2003
1,364
0
39
Canberra
✟23,976.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Private
Wow... it's been like 5 days and 30 replies!
Ok, by now i am fairly convinced that ki/chi is a real thing. I'm just concerned about how far it actually goes, as the 'grounding' technique where you visualise ki from the universe flowing into the centre of your body, i guess that's just a visualisation aid thing. Or the tenkan technique where you turn around the heaven&earth axis (heaven meaning out there in space, not the biblical term), you visualise ki flowing through your body and into infinity. heh, pretty powerful stuff this ki is.
I'm just saying this because a few people who replied to my original post say it's only inside your body, and not external, but sensei teaches that it's the energy of the *universe* which you are taking control of. I'm confused ? :/ can someone who has studied ki for a while please explain?
 
Upvote 0

Tomk80

Titleless
Apr 27, 2004
11,570
429
45
Maastricht
Visit site
✟36,582.00
Faith
Agnostic
For me, this is a visualisation tool. Others may disagree on this.
Visualizing the flows of energy helps you to concentrate on where the energy goes. One exercise I consider particularly strong in this is the 3th suburi if you do sword practice. Here you really can imagine being charged with all the energy from the cosmos. For me, the visualization makes you more aware of what you are doing. It is hard to do the same without it, because it is to abstract.
For me it works like this. In the third suburi you inhale, raising your sword. Then you lower your sword slowly, exhaling. After lowering your sword you quickly strike. Imagining that you absorb energy from the universe makes your breathing more complete, and the subsequent relaxation more relaxed. This way you are in a relaxed but powerfull position, which makes you feel charged. The subsequent strike releases the energy you build up because of this.
Does this explanation make sense to you?
 
Upvote 0

jhollas

Christian Soldier
May 6, 2004
862
22
39
The Shire
✟16,118.00
Faith
Anglican
Marital Status
Single
Politics
UK-Conservative
Nothingness.
Everything is nothing, and nothing is everything.
When your Sensei tells you use the energy of the "Universe," he is telling you to use the energy of everything. (i.e. the living energy)
The Universe contains everything, but is largely nothing.
Now, that probably doesn't make sense, because I have only been practising Martial Arts for about 5 years. I suspect that what I have said will make much more sense if you read the final chapter of Miyamoto Musashi's "Book of Five Rings."
 
Upvote 0