@JojotheBeloved
Hi again, and sorry for the delay! I started writing a reply about three weeks ago, but sometimes it's a good idea to let our brains rest for a while before we revisit a difficult topic!
Okay, I understand that you wanted to discuss your ideas in an informal setting, and of course that's perfectly fine! That's how we learn and increase our knowledge, and we all need to be willing to examine the foundations of our faith. I also definitively agree with you that we should aim to understand the text in its cultural and literary context, and it's no good idea to read ancient texts through the lens of our modern ideas.
So, please regard the following as my contribution to this brainstorming session...
About fairness / the character of God / the courtroom analogy... Well, this is far from the only approach to this issue, (there's another much more direct way of explaining all of this) but I do nevertheless think this approach is valid and biblically sound, even if it is an indirect approach.
Anyways, I'll try to expand a little on this way of thinking, and I'll try to provide further evidence that the justice approach isn't merely our modern way of thinking superimposed onto the biblical text.
As you say, yes, the fairness and justice of God is in fact a reoccurring theme in the Bible, and Scripture abounds with stories about judgment.
To be honest I cannot imagine something more thoroughly biblical and genuinely ancient than the judgment theme: Man committed a crime, was approached by God, got the chance to explain his actions, was judged and sent into exile. It's all there in
Genesis chapter three, the first trial ever recorded in the history of mankind... And then there's the classic twist: Adam had expected immediate punishment, death, but God exceeded his expectations; they were given a second chance and the plan of salvation was revealed... In other words I'd argue that the very concept of judgment isn't a human invention, but is in fact divine, and it's essential to the plan of salvation. It's not just modern people who are preoccupied with courtrooms and trials!
Now, the point in my previous post wasn't primarily that banishing people to death while not being present is wrong from a formal judicial point of view, as much as that it goes against what we know about the character of God. We have to ask ourselves what the purpose of this judgment scene is... Who is it for? First of all we should remember that there was another judgment preceding this scene, the saints have already spent 1000 years in a judicial process, the dead have already been judged before the courtroom scene in
20:11-15. (See
Rev 11:18, 20:4). In other words, we can presume that at this point it is known why each and every one of the ungodly are unfitted for heaven. So, the purpose of this final courtroom scene is something different than establishing the guilt of the wicked, that has already been done during the 1000 years.
So, as I argued in my previous post I think that the final judgment scene is intended first and foremost (but not only) for the benefit of the wicked themselves. The ultimate reason for this is because God hates delusion with an intense passion. He hates it so much that he will remove all lies and all excuses from the minds of the wicked before they are put to rest, and this is what the final judgment scene is about:
The gospels, the book of Daniel and Revelation (
Matt 26:64, Dan 12:2, Rev 1:7) itself is clear about the fact that God will resurrect the ones that were involved in the trial and crucifixion of Christ so that they will get a chance to witness the second coming of Jesus.
Why does God do this? These people are surely lost, so why did he disturb their sleep in order to let them witness his second coming? I think this is motivated by his love as well as his dislike of deception and darkness. These deluded souls wouldn't believe that Jesus was the Messiah, they were blinded by their sins and their preconceptions, their cherished idea that the Messiah would come as a great and mighty earthly conqueror. Even if these people are doomed, God is willing to raise them up from death in order to remove their misconceptions. Even if they still will refuse to love and worship Christ, their excuses will be taken away once and for all. So not only is God both loving and fair, in fact his fairness far exceeds our expectations. He is himself more than willing to go that extra mile, even for people who are lost.
- - -
About whether or not the gospel is fair, well, I understand what you're saying. It's not fair that the innocent had to die in place of the guilty, we agree about this! But this only got negative consequences for the Son of God; he bore the injustice himself. If we were bought free by the blood of fellow men, then I think the Devil rightly could protest, because then the injustice of salvation would have had negative consequences for other created beings. But since Jesus is the only one treated unfairly (in a negative way), the unfairness of what he experienced is mitigated by the fact a) that he is the infinite God who created us, b) that he did so out of a free will. As sinners we surely don't deserve salvation, this is something that demonstrates the love of God.
For while we were still helpless, at the right time Christ died for the ungodly. (For rarely will anyone die for a righteous person, though for a good person perhaps someone might possibly dare to die.) But God demonstrates his own love for us, in that while we were still sinners, Christ died for us. - Romans 5:6-8
Just some thoughts for your consideration...
