How do you justify moral-based laws?

TheBellman · Sep 25, 2006

HolyMary said:
As I said in the other thread, I have no problem with imposing morals on others so long as the morals that are being imposed are correct morals. Morality is absolute and is not relative and therefore it would not be a problem to impose correct morals on another person.

Who gets to decide whic morals are the correct ones, that we're going to impose on everybody?

And this, of course, is where this idea completely collapses. Morality may be absolute, but if it is, we have no reliable way of knowing which morals are correct. As certain as you are that yours are correct, there are other groups which are certain that theirs (which contradict yours) are correct. Who gets to decide?

THIS is why laws based on morals are not only a bad idea, but a terrible idea.

Robinsegg · Sep 25, 2006

TheBellman said:
Who gets to decide whic morals are the correct ones, that we're going to impose on everybody?

And this, of course, is where this idea completely collapses. Morality may be absolute, but if it is, we have no reliable way of knowing which morals are correct. As certain as you are that yours are correct, there are other groups which are certain that theirs (which contradict yours) are correct. Who gets to decide?

THIS is why laws based on morals are not only a bad idea, but a terrible idea.

I assume you mean this with some exceptions, like actions with victims?

Rachel

TheBellman · Sep 25, 2006

Robinsegg said:
I assume you mean this with some exceptions, like actions with victims?

Rachel

No, I don't mean it with any exceptions - but I'm not sure what you mean by 'actions with victims'.

armyman_83 · Sep 26, 2006

"Our constitution was made for a moral and religious people; it is wholly inadequate for any other."
--John Adams

Robinsegg · Sep 26, 2006

TheBellman said:
No, I don't mean it with any exceptions - but I'm not sure what you mean by 'actions with victims'.

I mean actions like murder, child molestation, spousal/child abuse, battery, theft, and the like.

Rachel

kopilo · Sep 26, 2006

TricksterWolf said:
For those of you who feel that it's wrong to force others to conform to your morality outside of free will, how would you justify laws against things like gambling, prostitution, abortion, and pornography, which do not have a direct society-disabling effect on those who do not participate?

You have a right to live life your way and I have a right to live life mine. I can only know what is best for myself, so why should I impose my morals onto anyone else and visa versa.

If your actions impose on my life as well as many others then I have a say just like they do. Theft, battery and many things against the law have been a negative for society as a whole.

TheBellman · Sep 26, 2006

Robinsegg said:
I mean actions like murder, child molestation, spousal/child abuse, battery, theft, and the like.

No, no exceptions. ANY law made purely on moral grounds is a bad law. There are ample reasons outside moral ones for the above to be illegal.

Robinsegg · Sep 26, 2006

TheBellman said:
No, no exceptions. ANY law made purely on moral grounds is a bad law. There are ample reasons outside moral ones for the above to be illegal.

I'm not sure what you mean by "moral", then, I suppose. I always supposed "moral" to mean this is always right, and this is always wrong . . . and no one questions it because it is just fact. Sorry, just my mistake!

Rachel

TheBellman · Sep 27, 2006

Robinsegg said:
I'm not sure what you mean by "moral", then, I suppose. I always supposed "moral" to mean this is always right, and this is always wrong . . . and no one questions it because it is just fact. Sorry, just my mistake!

Rachel

I'm sorry, you've completely lost me here. I don't think the statement that 'this is always right and this is always wrong' is even meaningful - 'right' and 'wrong' always only mean 'approved of (or not) by the speaker'.

elman · Sep 27, 2006

quatona said:
There is a little problem, though: All persons who try to impose their various morals upon others are convinced that these morals are the "correct" ones. It´s where holy wars come from.

Those who inflict their morality that war is immoral and that being unloving is wrong would not be the source of the holy wars would they?

quatona · Sep 27, 2006

elman said:
Those who inflict their morality that war is immoral and that being unloving is wrong would not be the source of the holy wars would they?

I would agree, but how, then, do they inflict their morality on others, practically speaking?

elman · Sep 27, 2006

quatona said:
I would agree, but how, then, do they inflict their morality on others, practically speaking?

I would say by proclaiming their opinions and supporting people in positions of power that agree with them and by refusing to join in with unloving and violent actions.

quatona · Sep 27, 2006

elman said:
I would say by proclaiming their opinions and supporting people in positions of power that agree with them and by refusing to join in with unloving and violent actions.

I wouldn´t call that "inflicting their morality upon others".

elman · Sep 27, 2006

quatona said:
I wouldn´t call that "inflicting their morality upon others".

Some people do. They don't want anyone telling them what is loving or unloving or judging them in any way or even telling them about God and what God might expect from them.

quatona · Sep 27, 2006

elman said:
Some people do. They don't want anyone telling them what is loving or unloving or judging them in any way or even telling them about God and what God might expect from them.

You don´t think it is, and I don´t think it is - so what´s the point in referring to "some people" when discussing our ideas?
Indeed, I myself find "God wants you to..." sermons boring and annoying at times (and I think it is respectless to bring them to people who have told you they don´t want to hear them), but that doesn´t mean that persons who do so "are inflicting their morality upon me." They just give me their opinion.
I mean, that would almost be like complaining about being persecuted whilst in fact merely being criticized.

elman · Sep 27, 2006

quatona said:
You don´t think it is, and I don´t think it is - so what´s the point in referring to "some people" when discussing our ideas?
Indeed, I myself find "God wants you to..." sermons boring and annoying at times (and I think it is respectless to bring them to people who have told you they don´t want to hear them), but that doesn´t mean that persons who do so "are inflicting their morality upon me." They just give me their opinion.
I mean, that would almost be like complaining about being persecuted whilst in fact merely being criticized.

I agree but ours is not the only atitude on this and I have heard many people offended by any mention of God.

Robinsegg · Sep 27, 2006

elman said:
I agree but ours is not the only atitude on this and I have heard many people offended by any mention of God.

Does that mean I can (in a valid fashion) be offended by mention of the tooth fairy? Will people stop speaking of the tooth fairy for me?

Rachel

elman · Sep 27, 2006

Robinsegg said:
Does that mean I can (in a valid fashion) be offended by mention of the tooth fairy? Will people stop speaking of the tooth fairy for me?

Rachel

I don't know about the valid fasion but you are able to be offended at whatever you want. I certainly agree that someone should not be offended by simply mentioning God.

Konkurrent · Sep 27, 2006

You don't have the right to not be offended. However, if someone continues to do something you've told them is offensive to you they are guilty of harassment.

Robinsegg · Sep 27, 2006

I heartily agree. No one has the right to not be offended. I think it's rude (and unconvincing) to continue telling someone about God when they've asked you to stop. But I don't think it's legally wrong, nor should it be.

Rachel

How do you justify moral-based laws?

Well-Known Member

SuperMod L's

Well-Known Member

armyman_83

Guest

SuperMod L's

Envisioner

Well-Known Member

SuperMod L's

Well-Known Member

elman

"God"? What do you mean??

elman

"God"? What do you mean??

elman

"God"? What do you mean??

elman

SuperMod L's

elman

Well-Known Member

SuperMod L's

Similar threads

Privacy & Transparency

Privacy & Transparency