I'm not a parent, but I have been homeschooled all my life.
Not necessaily true, nor is the social skills part. I was homeschooled all my life, and am now in a public, junior college. I went there all last year, and am going full time this year. It wasn't a huge shock, and I am very shy by nature, too...
Both my brothers have gone to public colleges, also, and neither of them had problems with it. Other than getting kind of sick and tired of all the unchristian stuff there....
Do you really get good, Christian friends in a public school?
A Beka is good. Until high school, my mom used mostly A Beka, a few Bob Jones book, and Saxon for Algebra. In high school, we did the A Beka video program thing, which is good, and there are some really, really good teachers there.
I do have one other point to make - about public school "experience." Ok, let's just say that it's true that you might not get as good social skills, or perhaps not as many athletic opportunities.
Which is more important
(1) Becoming a stronger Christian and learning more about it through your school books, parents, etc., and getting a very solid education on top of that;
or...
(2) Having a few public-school-friends and maybe better athletic opportunities.
I don't know, I wouldn't even want my [future] kid
being taught the trash they teach in public schools around here. I totally agree.