ebia said:
Compared to the biblical heros who never killed anyone... Except for David... oh, and Joshua. And... God.
Well, that is true. But you forget Isiah. And Moses. Moses was a murderer.
Killing is bad, basically. Not always, but usually. While the Old Testament does contain much genocide, and as does the history of any nation from that time, the bible does not tell us to kill the infidels and make war on our unbelieving neighbors. Islam does. The funder of Christianity, Jesus Christ told us to turn the other cheek. He told us to love and pray for those who persecute us.
Mohammed told the Muslims to persecute. He told them to kill. He told them we are the descendants of pigs and monkeys, and have ten intestines. (what kind of an insult is that by the way?)
Christ died at the hands of others. Mohammed made others die by his hands.
Yes, there is a lot of killing in the bible. Yes, there is a lot of people doing wrong in the bible. David killing Uriah to get his wife for instance. Or Moses killing the egyptian resulting in his exile. Paul persecuting the converts and leading them to torture and death. But look to them. Paul killed for religious reasons. David for what he believed to be love, and anger against Uriah. Moses for anger as well. None were justified. Paul was given the chance and he repented and changed. David repented as well. Moses faced hardships for his decision, even if it may have been the right thing to do. David may also have been justified in his own eyes. And Paul killed for the same reason Muslims kill today. His religious beliefs. They repented, and were given another chance. What mercy is this that we have been offered a part of? Forgiving murderers who commit such vile crimes.
While we may justify many a death in our own eyes. Killings can seem so incredibly right sometimes. Like the killing of Hitler, who would turn down the opportunity to kill him before WW2 had one been given the chance?
Problem is of course that what seems right and good in our eyes may not be right and good in the Lord's eyes. There's the obvious reason that we simply don't grasp the enormity of this world, His plans and the consequences of our actions. And then there is the subjectivity of the individual which can justify nearly anything. I believe Israel was chosen by God because it was a nation and an ethnic group through which God could reveal His nature and power. Had He chosen Egypt, or Babylon, or Rome - who would be surprised at the survival of such an empire? It could be considered completely logical that either one of the three had survived the test of time and prevailed as the sole power on earth. One government. One power. One religion. But, He chose this puny group of people, who were tossed between the larger and more powerful nations yet prevailed against all odds. Had Israel been destroyed, how then would the bible carry weight as it does today?
And then there are the killings that were justified by God. Judas' death for instance. Or the people who attacked Israel up through the times. Difference is among many things; God has not told us to persecute and kill those who convert from Christianity. He has not told us to slay our unbelieving neighbors. Mohammed has done so. And he did so himself. Jesus walked to His own death, and the martyr death of many of His followers throughout the ages. Mohammed lead his followers to the deaths of others. To me, it seems like ying and yang. They contain similarities, but are still radically different on many/most fundamental issues.
I have serious issues with anyone who kills for religious reasons. Or any reason really.
As for Islam, by it's nature it is violent. We should not meet this with violence though. But we may have to, if they continue their "crusade" against the west. How long until it blossoms into a full scale war? Are we not already at the edge of one? If a war starts, we have the most powerful weapons. But Islamic nations have the most zeal. It will be a bloodbath if/when it starts. And if it does come to war, then I have no doubt the agressors will be the middle eastern nations. Not because of Islam, but because of Islamic extremism being firmly lodged in central positions in their leadership.